Skip to content
Now

Disasters · Tbilisi collapse

Tbilisi building collapse: five dead, two still missing, and a toll that won't add up

A suspected gas explosion brought down a five-storey apartment block in Ponichala on Thursday. Rescuers pulled out a three-year-old alive. The official count changed all day, and no official has explained why the totals don't match.

Written 5 min read · 16 sources

On Thursday the death toll in Tbilisi went up several times in one day. A suspected natural gas explosion brought down a five-storey apartment building in Ponichala, a district of the Georgian capital. Each update from the rubble changed the numbers. By 20:25 local time on November 19, rescuers had recovered two more bodies. The count then stood at five dead and two people still buried. Every one of those figures is provisional until the search ends, and the way the count changed during the day is part of the story.⁠8⁠1

The exact time of the blast has not been reported. A Civil Georgia report time-stamped about 12:36 local time already described a rescue operation, so the explosion happened before then. At that point rescuers said they were searching for seven people.⁠4

How the count moved on Nov 19

  1. Thu Nov 19, by about 12:36

    Rescue under way. Rescuers say they are searching for seven people, and four are reported injured.

    4
  2. Thu Nov 19, afternoon

    Emergency chief Teimuraz Mgebrishvili says the bodies of two women and a child have been recovered and three people are missing.

    256
  3. Thu Nov 19

    A three-year-old girl is pulled alive from the wreckage and taken to hospital.

    71
  4. Thu Nov 19, later update

    The count rises to four dead and two missing.

    3
  5. Thu Nov 19, 20:25

    Two more bodies are recovered. Five dead, two still under the rubble.

    8

Numbers that don't reconcile

Put the official figures side by side and they don't fit together. Mgebrishvili's update of three dead and three missing makes six people. The latest count of five dead and two missing makes seven, the same number rescuers said they were looking for early in the day. Somewhere between those updates, one person was added to the total. That person may have been a resident not counted at first, or the six may itself have been wrong. No official has said which. It is a gap rather than a contradiction, but it is the reason every figure on this page should be read as "so far."⁠2⁠3⁠8⁠4

The fact that the count moved is not in itself a sign of anything sinister. Early casualty counts after a building collapse are almost always guesses about who was home, and they get corrected as relatives come forward and bodies are found. What the authorities owe the public is an explanation of each change, and on Thursday evening that had not come.

A child out of the rubble

In the middle of the search, rescuers reached a three-year-old girl, named in local reports as Taia, and took her to hospital alive. Mgebrishvili said one of the two women found dead was presumably her parent. That one sentence gives the rescue a bleak second half.⁠2⁠7

Four other people were reported injured and hospitalised during the day, one of them in serious condition. Those reports came early in the operation, and their current condition has not been reported.⁠4⁠5

Beyond the building that fell

The damage may reach well past the dead and missing. Tbilisi Mayor Kakha Kaladze said a municipal laboratory was assessing the structural stability of the building and of other residential buildings in Ponichala. He said city services had been mobilised and hotels prepared, and that if necessary all 90 families from the building would be given accommodation.⁠12⁠14⁠16

The 90 families are the hidden scale of this disaster. Most of those households appear to have escaped physical harm. Whether they can sleep in their own flats again depends on what the engineers conclude. A building that has had a five-storey section ripped out of it is not one anyone should rush back into.

A criminal case, and a question of responsibility

Authorities have opened a criminal investigation under Article 240¹ of Georgia's Criminal Code. One report specifies Part 1. Accounts differ on who announced it. Sova, NewsGeorgia and Interpressnews attribute the announcement to prosecutor Levan Vepkhvadze. The Azerbaijani outlet Inter Press credits the Interior Ministry. The weight of the Georgian reporting points to the prosecutor. Either way, the case is open.⁠9⁠10⁠11⁠13

The cause is less settled than the headlines suggest. Officials describe a suspected natural gas explosion. One report called it a gas leak, while another described gas build-up only as the presumed cause. Nothing published so far names the company that supplied gas to the building, quotes a statement from any gas company, or says how old the building was or what condition it was in before the blast. The structural survey Kaladze described took place after the explosion, and it is no evidence that the building was already in poor repair.⁠14⁠16⁠1

That gap is exactly what Georgia's civil society has seized on. Rights advocate Nona Kurdovanidze said it is important to establish what caused the explosion in Ponichala and who is responsible.⁠15

This gravest incident reminds us once again that basic safety conditions are not met in the country.

Nona Kurdovanidze, rights advocate 15

Her point is broader than one building, and the evidence on Thursday night cannot yet prove it or disprove it. But it identifies the question the investigation will be judged on. Domestic gas explosions are not acts of God. Somebody installs the pipes, somebody inspects them, and somebody is meant to notice a leak before it fills a stairwell. An article of the criminal code has been invoked. What matters now is whether the case reaches the people and institutions responsible for gas safety in that block, or stops at whoever was nearest the spark.

Known

  • Five people are dead and two remain missing as of 20:25 local time on November 19. 8
  • A three-year-old girl was rescued alive. One of the dead women was presumably her parent. 72
  • A criminal investigation is open under Article 240¹ of the Criminal Code. 91011
  • The city says hotels are ready for all 90 families if needed, pending structural checks. 12

Unknown

  • Why the dead and missing went from a total of six to seven, and whether the count is now final.
  • The confirmed cause, the gas supplier, and the building's age and condition before the blast.
  • The current condition of the people hospitalised.

Next

  • Whether the two people still under the rubble are found alive.
  • What the structural surveys decide for the families of Ponichala.
  • Who the investigation holds responsible for gas safety in the building.

In Ponichala on Thursday night, rescuers were still digging for two people. The toll stood at five, and it could still rise.

Sources9

Of the sources cited here, Interpressnews published first, 10 hours before this report aired. 7 more outlets followed.

1 outlet with no date:1tv.ge

Every source, by outlet

16 sources from 9 outlets· Most cited first

As aired
  1. An apartment block collapsed in Tbilisi, killing five, and two people are still buried.
  2. A suspected gas explosion brought down the five-storey building in the city's Ponichala district on Thursday. Ninety families lived there, and the city says it's ready to put every one of them in hotels if it has to.
  3. Nobody can say yet whether the two missing will be found alive, or why the official count keeps shifting.
  4. The blast hit a residential block in Ponichala, a district of the Georgian capital. Nobody has said exactly when it went off, but rescuers were already working the site by about half past twelve local time.
  5. In the middle of the search, rescuers pulled a three-year-old girl named Taia alive from the wreckage and took her to hospital. Emergency chief Teimuraz Mgebrishvili said one of the women found dead was presumably her parent.
  6. Four other people were hospitalized, and one of them is in serious condition.
  7. The toll climbed all day. Early on, rescuers said they were searching for seven people. Mgebrishvili later reported three dead, two women and a child, with three missing. Then came four dead and two missing. By 20:25 local time, rescuers had recovered two more bodies, and the count stood at five dead, two missing.
  8. Those figures don't line up. Three dead and three missing makes six. Five dead and two missing makes seven, the number rescuers first said they were looking for. No official has explained the gap, so every figure stays provisional until the search ends.
  9. Two people are still under that rubble, and we'll keep following the search. Subscribe to this channel, and find more at heyday dot news.
  10. Officials suspect natural gas, but nobody has confirmed what caused the blast.
  11. The damage reaches past the building that fell. Mayor Kakha Kaladze said a municipal laboratory is checking the stability of the blast building and other apartment blocks in Ponichala. He said hotels are ready, and if needed, all 90 families from the building will get rooms.
  12. Most of those households escaped unhurt. Depending on what the engineers find, they could still lose their homes for a while.
  13. Authorities have opened a criminal investigation under Article 240 prime of Georgia's Criminal Code. Prosecutor Levan Vepkhvadze has been named as announcing the case. No gas company has spoken, and nothing's been said about the building's age or condition before the blast.
  14. That has drawn a sharp response from Georgia's civil society.
  15. Rights advocate Nona Kurdovanidze said it's important to find out what caused the explosion and who's responsible. She said this gravest incident reminds us once again that basic safety conditions are not met in the country.
  16. In Ponichala tonight, rescuers are still digging for two people, and the toll stands at five dead, a number that could still rise.

Aired recently