דילוג לתוכן
עכשיו

בעולם · Biden memoir

Biden says he refused Trump team’s Putin-talks authorization despite frustration with Zelenskyy

Biden’s reported memoir account separates his frustration with Zelenskyy from his fear of a deal at Ukraine’s expense. The proposed authorization letter remains unseen.

נכתב 5 דקות קריאה · 22 מקורות

זמין באנגלית

Why would Joe Biden refuse to authorize Donald Trump’s incoming team to negotiate with Vladimir Putin while privately finding Volodymyr Zelenskyy difficult and insufficiently grateful? His forthcoming memoir offers a straightforward answer: irritation with Ukraine’s president did not diminish his fear that Ukraine would pay the price of a deal.

unwilling to give them carte blanche for what I expected would be a kind of surrender, at Ukraine's expense.

Joe Biden, in reported memoir excerpts 2

That is the consequential disclosure in the reported passages from Promise Me, America—not merely another collection of presidential insults. Biden presents himself as drawing a boundary between an incoming administration’s diplomatic ambitions and the interests of a country his administration had armed. But his words describe the outcome he feared, not proof that a surrender agreement had already been drafted.⁠2

The distinction matters because the reporting rests on one underlying account. Fox News, Aaj Tak, Ukrainska Pravda and Kyiv Post attribute the passages to The Wall Street Journal’s coverage of the memoir. Their repetition is not independent corroboration of the request. The original Journal review could not be examined for this article, and neither the complete memoir passages nor the proposed letter was available for inspection.⁠1⁠2⁠3⁠4

The supported claim is therefore narrower than “Biden blocked Trump’s talks with Putin.” Biden says he withheld a particular written authorization. That does not establish that he prevented every contact between the incoming team and Moscow. The available accounts do not identify the individual requesters, reproduce the letter, explain its proposed legal effect or set out negotiating terms.⁠1⁠2⁠4

Private irritation was not policy abandonment

The memoir’s assessment of Zelenskyy is blunt, but its wording deserves more care than a shorthand accusation of ingratitude. Zelenskyy “could be moody and stubborn in our private conversations, and not as grateful as I would have expected,” Biden writes, according to Fox News’s account of the Journal review. That describes Biden’s experience and expectations—not an objectively measurable absence of thanks.⁠2

There is a public record of Zelenskyy expressing gratitude. Fox News recounts his thanks to America and its partners around a December 2023 White House meeting, where Ukraine’s requests included stronger air defenses, expanded weapons production and help disrupting Russian military logistics. Public appreciation and demanding private exchanges can coexist. One does not disprove the other.⁠2

After his February 2025 Oval Office confrontation with Trump and Vice President JD Vance, Zelenskyy again emphasized his appreciation in an interview with Fox News’s Bret Baier: “I'm thankful to President Trump and to Congress, bipartisan support, and I was always very thankful from all our people.” Those remarks cannot settle what happened privately with Biden. They do show why “not as grateful as I would have expected” should not be rewritten as “never said thank you.”⁠2

Biden’s judgment of Zelenskyy is also mixed rather than uniformly hostile. The Ukrainian leader’s acting background “turned out to be very good training,” he writes. Aaj Tak describes that praise as recognition of how the experience helped Zelenskyy lead during war. Keeping the praise beside the complaint preserves the actual assessment: a wartime partner Biden could admire and find exasperating.⁠1⁠2

His portrait of Putin is different. The Russian president “liked to slouch during a meeting, feigning indifference, like a teenager,” Biden writes. The comparison concerns meeting-room posture and performed disinterest; the reports also describe a petulant or irritable manner. These are personal impressions, not evidence of a new Russian policy.⁠1⁠2⁠3

The stakes were weapons and leverage

The material background to Biden’s refusal was Ukraine’s ability to keep resisting Russia’s full-scale invasion, launched in February 2022. American weapons and air defenses were part of that capacity. A dated example of Biden’s policy is his September 26, 2024 assistance announcement, issued before the election and the transition dispute.⁠1⁠13

That announcement committed $2.4 billion through the Ukraine Security Assistance Initiative for additional air defense, drones and air-to-ground munitions, alongside support for Ukraine’s defense industry, maintenance and sustainment. Separately, Biden authorized $5.5 billion in presidential drawdown authority before it expired, enabling equipment to be drawn from American stocks and those stocks replenished using congressionally appropriated funding. The figures describe different mechanisms, not interchangeable totals of aid delivered.⁠13

Biden also directed provision of the Joint Standoff Weapon long-range munition, refurbishment and provision of an additional Patriot air-defense battery, more Patriot missiles and expanded F-16 training, including support for 18 additional Ukrainian pilots in 2025. The statement described an earlier redirection of American air-defense exports intended to supply hundreds of additional Patriot and AMRAAM missiles over the following year. These were commitments; the announcement does not establish subsequent deliveries or completed training.⁠13

“The United States will provide Ukraine with the support it needs to win this war,” Biden said in that statement. His memoir presents the refused authorization as consistent with protecting Ukraine’s position. On his telling, finding Zelenskyy difficult did not make concessions to Putin more acceptable. That is a coherent distinction between personal chemistry and policy—even if the account still needs documentation.⁠13⁠2

מה ידוע

  • Biden’s reported memoir account says he refused a Trump-team request for written authorization to negotiate directly with Putin before Trump returned to office. 123

מה לא ידוע

  • The available material does not identify the requesters, reproduce the letter or independently substantiate the exchange.

מה הלאה

  • Look for the complete memoir account, supporting documents and accounts from other participants that clarify the request’s wording and scope.

Little, Brown and Company has scheduled Promise Me, America for November 17, 2026, a date it announced on July 15. John Murray is to publish simultaneously in the United Kingdom and Commonwealth. Publication is the next opportunity to examine these passages in fuller context, though it will not by itself supply independent confirmation.⁠10

For now, the memoir’s answer to the apparent contradiction is clear: Biden could resent how an ally spoke to him and still oppose what he feared would be a settlement at that ally’s expense. What remains unproven is not his stated explanation, but the request’s precise terms—and how the other participants would describe it.

מקורות21

מבין המקורות המצוטטים כאן, Українська правда פרסם ראשון, 25 שעות לפני שידור הדיווח הזה. 14 כלי תקשורת נוספים פרסמו בעקבותיו.

6 כלי תקשורת ללא תאריך:menatribune.comapnews.comarchive.phGovInfopromisemeamerica.comucsb.edu

כל המקורות, לפי כלי תקשורת

22 מקורות מ־21 כלי תקשורת· המצוטטים ביותר תחילה

כפי ששודר
  1. Joe Biden recounts refusing Trump's team written permission to negotiate directly with Putin.
  2. He says he feared Ukraine would pay the price for a settlement. His memoir puts that decision alongside blunt criticism of Ukraine's president, whose war effort he supported. How did Biden's private frustration with Volodymyr Zelenskyy fit with his refusal to authorize those talks?
  3. Biden says members of Donald Trump's incoming team wanted him to sign a letter authorizing direct negotiations with Russian President Vladimir Putin. He places the request after Trump's 2024 election victory and before Trump returned to office in January 2025.
  4. Biden was still president during that transition. In his forthcoming book, Promise Me, America, he says he declined to give the incoming team that authorization. He explains the refusal through his concern about what those negotiations might produce for Ukraine. His language makes clear how deeply he distrusted the outcome he expected.
  5. Biden writes that he was “unwilling to give them carte blanche for what I expected would be a kind of surrender, at Ukraine's expense.” He was describing his fear of where the talks would lead when he refused to sign.
  6. That concern coexisted with irritation at Zelenskyy. Biden writes that the Ukrainian president “could be moody and stubborn in our private conversations, and not as grateful as I would have expected.” The complaint concerns Biden's expectations and their private exchanges. He also credits Zelenskyy's earlier career as an actor with helping him lead during war.
  7. Zelenskyy's acting background “turned out to be very good training,” Biden writes. His description of Putin focuses on meeting-room behavior. Putin “liked to slouch during a meeting, feigning indifference, like a teenager.” Biden also describes an irritable, petulant manner.
  8. Zelenskyy publicly thanked America and its partners at the White House in December 2023. His requests included stronger air defenses, expanded weapons production and help disrupting Russian military logistics. Those public thanks can sit alongside Biden's account of difficult private conversations. They don't tell us what either man said behind closed doors.
  9. Subscribe to this channel as we follow the book's release and the questions about that letter.
  10. Zelenskyy thanked American leaders again after his February 2025 Oval Office confrontation with Trump and Vice President JD Vance. He said, “I'm thankful to President Trump and to Congress, bipartisan support, and I was always very thankful from all our people.” Biden's complaint was about how much gratitude he expected in their own conversations.
  11. Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, while Biden was president. Ukraine's ability to keep resisting depended in part on American weapons and air defenses. Those were the material stakes behind Biden's concern about concessions to Putin.
  12. Biden announced a further assistance commitment on September 26, 2024, before the election and the transition dispute. He directed the Pentagon to allocate its remaining congressionally approved security assistance funding for Ukraine by the end of his term. The announcement used separate funding mechanisms, each with a different purpose.
  13. Biden announced $2.4 billion through the Ukraine Security Assistance Initiative. Separately, he authorized $5.5 billion in presidential drawdown authority before it expired. Drawdown allows equipment to come from American stocks, with funding to replace it. These figures describe commitments and authority.
  14. The $2.4 billion commitment covered additional air defenses, drones and air-to-ground munitions. It also supported Ukraine's defense industry and the maintenance needed to keep equipment working. Biden separately directed provision of the Joint Standoff Weapon, a long-range munition. Air defense and pilot training were further parts of the same announcement.
  15. Biden directed refurbishment and provision of one additional Patriot air-defense battery, plus more Patriot missiles. He also ordered expanded F-16 training, including support for 18 additional Ukrainian pilots in 2025. Those commitments alone don't tell us what was ultimately delivered or completed.
  16. An earlier decision to redirect American air-defense exports was intended to provide hundreds of additional Patriot and AMRAAM missiles over the following year. Biden's stated goal was explicit. “The United States will provide Ukraine with the support it needs to win this war.” His memoir presents the refused authorization as protecting Ukraine's position, despite his frustrations with its president.
  17. Promise Me, America is scheduled for publication on November 17, 2026. Little, Brown announced that date in July. John Murray will publish simultaneously in the United Kingdom and Commonwealth. The release offers the next opportunity to read these passages in full.
  18. Biden's stated reason for refusing was his fear of a settlement at Ukraine's expense. The people who requested the letter haven't been identified, and its wording hasn't been made public. Whether documents or other participants support his account is still an open question.

שודר לאחרונה