משפט · Marble Hill shootingICE Shooting: Deportation Blocked, but Wounded Father Remains Detainedנכתב 12 באוקטובר 2026 בשעה 10:25 UTCצפייהתמליל0:09On October 9th, we reported the man shot in Marble Hill was conscious in hospital.0:13His lawyers now say he's awaiting surgery in federal detention.0:16A judge has temporarily blocked his deportation, but he hasn't been released.0:20Federal officials defend the shooting while withholding the camera footage they say0:24explains it.0:25What happened immediately before agents fired at a car carrying a father and his0:29five-year-old son?0:30The shooting wounded 28-year-old Oscar Belgal near West 225th Street and Marble Hill0:34Avenue.0:35It happened around 4 Thursday afternoon, October 8th.0:39Marble Hill is the consistent location, although descriptions differ over whether to0:43call it Manhattan or the Bronx.0:44Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said preliminary evidence showed at least one ICE0:48agent fired seven rounds.0:50Belgal was struck in the neck below his left ear.0:53The police figure counts rounds fired.0:55It doesn't tell us how many struck him.0:57Belgall's five-year-old son was in the back seat.0:59Police later found him safe with a family member after a wellness check, and he was1:04reported physically unharmed.1:06Federal officials say the agents didn't know he was there when they fired.1:09The boy's relationship to the driver and his immediate safety are now clear.1:13Belgall reached New York Presbyterian Allen Hospital conscious and in stable1:17condition.1:18The NYPD received two emergency calls reporting the shooting at 4.04 p.m.1:23Its officers responded afterward, gave aid, and secured the scene.1:27They hadn't participated in the federal operation.1:30The released police body camera footage shows Belgall handcuffed on the ground, with1:34pressure being applied to his neck.1:36Officers then helped or carried him into a police SUV.1:39The hospital journey took about a minute, and he was conscious and breathing.1:42Those recordings document the rescue after the gunfire.1:45Belgall's attorneys said on October 11th that a bullet was still lodged in his neck1:50and surgery was pending.1:52They placed him at Brooklyn's Metropolitan Detention Center.1:55That remains the latest substantive medical account, and it comes from his lawyers.1:59Federal officials earlier called the neck wound superficial and said a bullet or2:03fragment could have caused it.2:04Later descriptions called his injuries non-life-threatening.2:07His lawyer's account of a retained bullet and pending surgery is more recent.2:11The hospital arrival condition shouldn't be taken as a description of his treatment2:15now.2:15Belgal was taken into federal custody after hospital treatment.2:18He was initially transferred to New Jersey.2:20A government lawyer placed him in Brooklyn at the October 9th hearing, and the2:24subsequent attorney's statement also placed him there.2:27U.S.2:27District Judge J.2:28Paul O.2:28Ken temporarily blocked Belgal's deportation on October 9th while reviewing his2:32challenge to detention.2:34That challenge asks the court to examine whether holding him is lawful.2:37Belgal remains detained, and ICE says it will keep pursuing deportation.2:41The order also reportedly restricts transfers beyond nearby federal jurisdictions.2:45Its exact boundaries and duration aren't clear yet.2:48The court's temporary protection hasn't settled Belgall's immigration case or the2:52legality of the shooting.2:53Whether the released video shows gunfire has been described differently.2:57Tish said the shooting wasn't captured in the video she described.3:00The surveillance sequence shows the approach, while the NYPD body cameras show the3:05wounded man afterward.3:06Plainclothes agents approach Belgall's car with guns drawn as it begins reversing or3:10moving away.3:11An agent runs to the driver's side window and strikes it as the car starts pulling3:15away.3:16The vehicle then leaves the camera's view.3:18Aftermath footage shows Belgall wounded beside a car with blown-out windows.3:22The public NYPD footage shows the approach and emergency response.3:26Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen says unreleased federal footage shows orders to exit a3:30collision and acceleration toward officers.3:33Those are his descriptions of recordings the public still can't examine in full.3:36DHS and ICE say Belgall was their intended arrest target, refused instructions to3:42leave the car and rammed two government vehicles.3:45They say he moved toward officers who feared for their lives, their partners, and3:48the public.3:49Mullen also says Belgall knew who the agents were and chose to flee.3:53That federal account conflicts with an earlier description that he wasn't the3:57operations target.3:58The released sequence doesn't settle the alleged vehicle collisions or the threat4:02when shots were fired.4:03It also leaves the officers' positions at that moment unclear.4:07Mullen says the FBI and Homeland Security Investigations are investigating.4:11He says footage will be released after their work is complete.4:14White House Border Czar Tom Homan also expects eventual release and supports4:18transparency.4:20Neither has given a release date.4:21Homan described the officer's self-defense claim as his understanding of what4:25happened.4:26The Bronx District Attorney's Office has separately opened an investigation.4:30Federal officials say the involved officers were placed on administrative leave.4:34No final finding or charging decision has been announced.4:37DHS also alleges Belgal was in the country unlawfully, had a grand larceny4:41conviction and prior arrests, and had gang ties.4:45It alleges an association with an earlier shooting of a customs and border4:48protection officer.4:49His lawyer and local critics disputed parts of those claims.4:52Those allegations haven't been backed here by court or immigration records.4:56A prior arrest alone doesn't prove guilt, and an alleged association doesn't show5:00Belgal committed the earlier shooting.5:02Mullen called him a threat to the community.5:04President Donald Trump praised the officers.5:06Mayor Zoran Kwame Mumdani demanded that ICE stop operating in New York City and be5:10abolished.5:11Mullen rejected that demand and said enforcement would continue.5:14Mamdani says hours of discussions with Trump and Mullen failed to secure Belgall's5:18release.5:19Mamdani's preliminary description said agents surrounded the car and wore5:22construction vests and face-concealing masks.5:25He condemned shooting at a moving vehicle in broad daylight.5:28Mullen gives a different account of the talks.5:29Trump offered a transfer to NYPD custody, but Mamdani wouldn't agree to detain5:34Belgal.5:34Governor Kathy Hochle also spoke with Trump and demanded additional footage.5:38She says he assured her the government wouldn't go after Belgol's family, including5:42his son.5:43The competing accounts of the release talks ended with Belgal still in federal5:46custody.5:47Protests and marches followed near the shooting scene and outside a hospital.5:51Demonstrators demanded justice.5:53Some demonstrations involved scuffles with police and arrests.5:56A Democratic congressional nominee said an NYPD officer pushed her to the ground6:00during a protest.6:01Rep.6:02Grace Meng called for an independent investigation and all-body camera footage.6:06She says she introduced legislation to put ICE's handbook and guidelines into law.6:11Senator Chuck Schumer also called on DHS to release the footage.6:14Whether Belgol's car threatened officers when they fired is still unresolved.6:18The public footage leaves that moment unseen.6:21The federal agencies defending the shooting hold the recordings they say explain it,6:25while both federal investigators and Bronx prosecutors continue their work.6:29Belgal has temporary protection against deportation.6:32His attorney's October 11th statement places him in Brooklyn federal detention, with6:35a bullet lodged in his neck and surgery still pending.קריאת הכתבהציר הזמן של הסיפורHeyDexהסרטון הקצר ↗מי דיווח על מהנקודות שדיווח עליהן יותר מכלי תקשורת אחד✓Man's condition and hospital careאושר באופן עצמאי · 14 כלי תקשורת✓Child in the vehicle during the shootingאושר באופן עצמאי · 13 כלי תקשורת✓Federal agents shot a man in New Yorkאושר באופן עצמאי · 12 כלי תקשורתOfficers' stated reason for firing11 כלי תקשורתICE said it was seeking to arrest a Dominican Republic national with a prior grand-larceny convicti…11 כלי תקשורתNeck injury from the gunfire8 כלי תקשורתNumber of rounds ICE agents fired8 כלי תקשורתName and age of the man shot3 כלי תקשורתכל שורה היא הטענה כפי שתיעדנו אותה מהדיווח של אותו כלי תקשורת. הושווה נכון ל-14 באוקטובר 2026 בשעה 18:06 UTC.
