• Broadcast publishedHurricane Utah flooding forces Gould Wash and WillowWind evacuations
  • New storyEcuador opposition leader Luisa Gonzalez arrested in campaign-finance probe
  • DevelopingBlizzard warning forecasts up to 15 inches of snow on Interior Seward Peninsula — 2 sources
  • DevelopingBlizzard warning forecasts up to 60 mph gusts for Shishmaref coast — 2 sources
  • DevelopingFlood watch issued for Santa Barbara County as heavy rain is forecast — 4 sources
  • New storyBlizzard warning forecasts 65 mph gusts for Western Arctic Coast
  • Broadcast publishedSouth Vienna shooting: Two drivers injured near school; campus stays open
  • DevelopingBlizzard warning forecasts up to 7 inches of snow and 60 mph gusts on Seward Peninsula coast — 2 sources
  • New storyHigh wind warning forecasts gusts up to 65 mph on Yukon Delta Coast
  • New storyLakeville police seek help locating missing 15-year-old Sophia Herrera

Continuing story · 1 report

Todd Joseph Irving’s Byron Carr murder prosecution

First aired Latest aired

Developing

Where it stands

On October 13, 2026, the Crown withdrew all charges against Todd Joseph Irving, including first-degree murder and interfering with human remains, after crucial physical evidence could not be produced. The Crown says it will not bring the case back, so the prosecution has ended.

Explore with HeyDex

Follow via RSS

Story trackerDay 2

1 report13 outlets19 sources2 videos

  1. Update 1Police knew evidence was missing. How did the Byron Carr case reach court?

The story so far

  1. Update 1

    Police knew evidence was missing. How did the Byron Carr case reach court?

    The Crown withdrew all charges against Todd Joseph Irving over the 1988 killing. Police knew crucial exhibits were missing in 2007; how they managed those losses remains unexplained.

    What moved

    • The Crown withdraws every charge in P.E.I. Supreme Court.

History

  1. Opened1 report

Who's involved

Organizations

  • Supreme Court of Prince Edward Islandprovincial high court in Canada1 report

Places

  • CharlottetownCharlottetown, PE, Canada1 report
  • Lapthorne AvenueLapthorne Ave, Charlottetown, PE, Canada1 report

Every outlet we read on this story

19 sources12 outlets2 videos2 wire copies

Who reported what

24 points0 confirmed by two or more outlets19 from a single outlet0 disputed

What 2 outlets reported about this story, point by point, and who reported each point first.

Points more than one outlet reported

Each column is an outlet, in the order they first reported. Select a mark to read that outlet's wording.

  • Reported it first
  • Reported it
  • Repeated another outlet
  • Did not report it
PointCBC NewsCTV NewsOutlets
Charges withdrawn against the accusedNot independently confirmed2
Towel and knife missing from the caseNot independently confirmed2
Crown’s stated reason for withdrawing chargesNot independently confirmed2
Circumstances of Carr’s killingNot independently confirmed2
Accused was arrested and charged in 2024Not independently confirmed2

Points only one outlet reported

Only reported by CBC News

Only reported by CTV News

Each line is the claim as we recorded it from that outlet's report. Compared as of .