• Broadcast publishedHurricane Utah flooding forces Gould Wash and WillowWind evacuations
  • New storyEcuador opposition leader Luisa Gonzalez arrested in campaign-finance probe
  • DevelopingBlizzard warning forecasts up to 15 inches of snow on Interior Seward Peninsula — 2 sources
  • DevelopingBlizzard warning forecasts up to 60 mph gusts for Shishmaref coast — 2 sources
  • DevelopingFlood watch issued for Santa Barbara County as heavy rain is forecast — 4 sources
  • New storyBlizzard warning forecasts 65 mph gusts for Western Arctic Coast
  • Broadcast publishedSouth Vienna shooting: Two drivers injured near school; campus stays open
  • DevelopingBlizzard warning forecasts up to 7 inches of snow and 60 mph gusts on Seward Peninsula coast — 2 sources
  • New storyHigh wind warning forecasts gusts up to 65 mph on Yukon Delta Coast
  • New storyLakeville police seek help locating missing 15-year-old Sophia Herrera

Continuing story · 2 reports

The Marble Hill federal-agent shooting

First aired Latest aired

Developing

Where it stands

A man shot in the neck during an ICE operation in Marble Hill on Oct. 8 was reported by his attorneys to still have a bullet lodged in his neck and to be awaiting surgery as of Oct. 11. He remains detained while a judge has temporarily blocked his deportation; decisive federal camera footage has not been released.

Explore with HeyDex

Follow via RSS

Continuing storyDay 4

2 reports63 outlets114 sources50 videos

  • No dated events yet
  1. Update 1ICE shooting in Marble Hill leaves a child unhurt—and key answers missing
  2. Update 2Deportation blocked, freedom denied: What changed after the Marble Hill ICE shooting

The story so far

  1. Update 23 days later

    Deportation blocked, freedom denied: What changed after the Marble Hill ICE shooting

    Oscar Belgal’s lawyers say he is awaiting surgery in Brooklyn federal detention. A judge has temporarily barred deportation, while the footage officials say justifies the shooting remains unreleased.

  2. Update 1

    ICE shooting in Marble Hill leaves a child unhurt—and key answers missing

    A hospitalized man, a reportedly unharmed five-year-old and conflicting target accounts leave the central question unanswered: why did an ICE officer fire?

    Still open after this report

    • No complete account establishes the threat the officer perceived, the intended target, shots through the windshield or injuries to federal agents.

History

  1. Opened1 report

Who's involved

People

  • Kathy Hochul57th governor of state New York since 20212 reports
  • Zohran MamdaniMayor of New York City since 20262 reports
  • J. Paul OetkenAmerican district Judge1 report
  • Jessica TischAmerican public administrator and New York City Police Commissioner (born 1981)1 report
  • Markwayne MullinAmerican politician (born 1977)1 report
  • Tom HomanAmerican law enforcement officer and immigration official (born 1961)1 report

Organizations

  • United States Immigration and Customs EnforcementUnited States federal law enforcement agency2 reports
  • Federal Bureau of InvestigationU.S. federal law enforcement agency1 report
  • Homeland Security Investigationsdirectorate of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)1 report
  • New York City Police Departmentmunicipal police force in the United States1 report
  • United States Department of Homeland SecurityUnited States federal executive department1 report

Places

  • Marble HillMarble Hill, New York, NY, USA2 reports
  • MDC Brooklyn80 29th St, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA1 report
  • Marble Hill Avenue & West 225th StreetMarble Hill Ave & W 225th St, New York, NY 10034, USA1 report
  • NewYork-Presbyterian Allen Hospital5141 Broadway, New York, NY 10034, USA1 report

Every outlet we read on this story

114 sources63 outlets50 videos3 wire copies

Who reported what

8 points3 confirmed by two or more outlets0 from a single outlet0 disputed

What 16 outlets reported about this story, point by point, and who reported each point first.

Points more than one outlet reported

Each column is an outlet, in the order they first reported. Select a mark to read that outlet's wording.

  • Reported it first
  • Reported it
  • Repeated another outlet
  • Did not report it
PointNYPD on XNBC NewsThe GuardianCNNABC NewsFox NewsCBS NewsBBC NewsAssociated PressSBS NewsThe IndependentFRANCE 24 EnglishReutersNPRCBC NewsScripps NewsOutlets
Man's condition and hospital careIndependently confirmed14
Child in the vehicle during the shootingIndependently confirmed13
Federal agents shot a man in New YorkIndependently confirmed12
Officers' stated reason for firingNot independently confirmed11
ICE said it was seeking to arrest a Dominican Republic national with a prior grand-larceny convicti…Not independently confirmed11
Neck injury from the gunfireNot independently confirmed8
Number of rounds ICE agents firedNot independently confirmed8
Name and age of the man shotNot independently confirmed3

Each line is the claim as we recorded it from that outlet's report. Compared as of .