Continuing story · 1 report
KPMG California rail contract billing dispute
CBS California found a roughly $2 million gap between KPMG’s winning proposal and four months of rail-contract billing. A promised independent review has not yet been confirmed as open.
DevelopingNext check Oct 25: A formal board-chair request, Inspector General acknowledgment or opening of the specific KPMG billing review, and any substantive KPMG or authority response.
Story trackerDay 1
1 report23 outlets44 sources
The story so far
Update 1
KPMG billed $425 for rail work assigned to $35 roles, report finds
CBS California found a roughly $2 million gap between KPMG’s winning proposal and four months of rail-contract billing. A promised independent review has not yet been confirmed as open.
History
Opened1 report
Who's involved
People
- Ian ChoudriCEO - California High Speed Rail Authority1 report
Organizations
- California Department of General Servicesdepartment of the California Government Operations Agency1 report
- California High-Speed Rail Authorityagency of the California State Transportation Agency1 report
KPMGprovider of audit, legal, tax advisory, financial, and business advisory services1 report
Places
- CaliforniaCalifornia, USA1 report
Every outlet we read on this story
44 sources23 outlets2 wire copies
Who reported what
18 points0 confirmed by two or more outlets8 from a single outlet0 disputed
What 3 outlets reported about this story, point by point, and who reported each point first.
Points more than one outlet reported
Each column is an outlet, in the order they first reported. Select a mark to read that outlet's wording.
- Reported it first
- Reported it
- Repeated another outlet
- Did not report it
| Point | CBS Bay Area | CBS Los Angeles | CBS News | Outlets |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Billing difference over the reviewed periodNot independently confirmed | 3 | |||
| Billing senior staff hours at Associate ratesNot independently confirmed | 3 | |||
| Hours assigned to senior staff across task ordersNot independently confirmed | 3 | |||
| Hearing officer guidance on classification and ratesNot independently confirmed | 3 | |||
| KPMG contract value and durationNot independently confirmed | 3 | |||
| Decision on CohnReznick’s protestNot independently confirmed | 3 | |||
| CohnReznick’s technical score and price resultNot independently confirmed | 2 | |||
| Contract rate for manager classificationsNot independently confirmed | 2 | |||
| Allegations in CohnReznick’s protestNot independently confirmed | 2 | |||
| Authority’s knowledge of KPMG’s staffing planNot independently confirmed | 2 |
Points only one outlet reported
Only reported by CBS Bay Area
Only reported by CBS Los Angeles
Only reported by CBS News
Each line is the claim as we recorded it from that outlet's report. Compared as of .
