Adalet · Marble Hill shootingICE Shooting: Deportation Blocked, but Wounded Father Remains DetainedYazıldı 12 Ekim 2026 10:25 UTCİzleYayın dökümü0:09On October 9th, we reported the man shot in Marble Hill was conscious in hospital.0:13His lawyers now say he's awaiting surgery in federal detention.0:16A judge has temporarily blocked his deportation, but he hasn't been released.0:20Federal officials defend the shooting while withholding the camera footage they say0:24explains it.0:25What happened immediately before agents fired at a car carrying a father and his0:29five-year-old son?0:30The shooting wounded 28-year-old Oscar Belgal near West 225th Street and Marble Hill0:34Avenue.0:35It happened around 4 Thursday afternoon, October 8th.0:39Marble Hill is the consistent location, although descriptions differ over whether to0:43call it Manhattan or the Bronx.0:44Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said preliminary evidence showed at least one ICE0:48agent fired seven rounds.0:50Belgal was struck in the neck below his left ear.0:53The police figure counts rounds fired.0:55It doesn't tell us how many struck him.0:57Belgall's five-year-old son was in the back seat.0:59Police later found him safe with a family member after a wellness check, and he was1:04reported physically unharmed.1:06Federal officials say the agents didn't know he was there when they fired.1:09The boy's relationship to the driver and his immediate safety are now clear.1:13Belgall reached New York Presbyterian Allen Hospital conscious and in stable1:17condition.1:18The NYPD received two emergency calls reporting the shooting at 4.04 p.m.1:23Its officers responded afterward, gave aid, and secured the scene.1:27They hadn't participated in the federal operation.1:30The released police body camera footage shows Belgall handcuffed on the ground, with1:34pressure being applied to his neck.1:36Officers then helped or carried him into a police SUV.1:39The hospital journey took about a minute, and he was conscious and breathing.1:42Those recordings document the rescue after the gunfire.1:45Belgall's attorneys said on October 11th that a bullet was still lodged in his neck1:50and surgery was pending.1:52They placed him at Brooklyn's Metropolitan Detention Center.1:55That remains the latest substantive medical account, and it comes from his lawyers.1:59Federal officials earlier called the neck wound superficial and said a bullet or2:03fragment could have caused it.2:04Later descriptions called his injuries non-life-threatening.2:07His lawyer's account of a retained bullet and pending surgery is more recent.2:11The hospital arrival condition shouldn't be taken as a description of his treatment2:15now.2:15Belgal was taken into federal custody after hospital treatment.2:18He was initially transferred to New Jersey.2:20A government lawyer placed him in Brooklyn at the October 9th hearing, and the2:24subsequent attorney's statement also placed him there.2:27U.S.2:27District Judge J.2:28Paul O.2:28Ken temporarily blocked Belgal's deportation on October 9th while reviewing his2:32challenge to detention.2:34That challenge asks the court to examine whether holding him is lawful.2:37Belgal remains detained, and ICE says it will keep pursuing deportation.2:41The order also reportedly restricts transfers beyond nearby federal jurisdictions.2:45Its exact boundaries and duration aren't clear yet.2:48The court's temporary protection hasn't settled Belgall's immigration case or the2:52legality of the shooting.2:53Whether the released video shows gunfire has been described differently.2:57Tish said the shooting wasn't captured in the video she described.3:00The surveillance sequence shows the approach, while the NYPD body cameras show the3:05wounded man afterward.3:06Plainclothes agents approach Belgall's car with guns drawn as it begins reversing or3:10moving away.3:11An agent runs to the driver's side window and strikes it as the car starts pulling3:15away.3:16The vehicle then leaves the camera's view.3:18Aftermath footage shows Belgall wounded beside a car with blown-out windows.3:22The public NYPD footage shows the approach and emergency response.3:26Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen says unreleased federal footage shows orders to exit a3:30collision and acceleration toward officers.3:33Those are his descriptions of recordings the public still can't examine in full.3:36DHS and ICE say Belgall was their intended arrest target, refused instructions to3:42leave the car and rammed two government vehicles.3:45They say he moved toward officers who feared for their lives, their partners, and3:48the public.3:49Mullen also says Belgall knew who the agents were and chose to flee.3:53That federal account conflicts with an earlier description that he wasn't the3:57operations target.3:58The released sequence doesn't settle the alleged vehicle collisions or the threat4:02when shots were fired.4:03It also leaves the officers' positions at that moment unclear.4:07Mullen says the FBI and Homeland Security Investigations are investigating.4:11He says footage will be released after their work is complete.4:14White House Border Czar Tom Homan also expects eventual release and supports4:18transparency.4:20Neither has given a release date.4:21Homan described the officer's self-defense claim as his understanding of what4:25happened.4:26The Bronx District Attorney's Office has separately opened an investigation.4:30Federal officials say the involved officers were placed on administrative leave.4:34No final finding or charging decision has been announced.4:37DHS also alleges Belgal was in the country unlawfully, had a grand larceny4:41conviction and prior arrests, and had gang ties.4:45It alleges an association with an earlier shooting of a customs and border4:48protection officer.4:49His lawyer and local critics disputed parts of those claims.4:52Those allegations haven't been backed here by court or immigration records.4:56A prior arrest alone doesn't prove guilt, and an alleged association doesn't show5:00Belgal committed the earlier shooting.5:02Mullen called him a threat to the community.5:04President Donald Trump praised the officers.5:06Mayor Zoran Kwame Mumdani demanded that ICE stop operating in New York City and be5:10abolished.5:11Mullen rejected that demand and said enforcement would continue.5:14Mamdani says hours of discussions with Trump and Mullen failed to secure Belgall's5:18release.5:19Mamdani's preliminary description said agents surrounded the car and wore5:22construction vests and face-concealing masks.5:25He condemned shooting at a moving vehicle in broad daylight.5:28Mullen gives a different account of the talks.5:29Trump offered a transfer to NYPD custody, but Mamdani wouldn't agree to detain5:34Belgal.5:34Governor Kathy Hochle also spoke with Trump and demanded additional footage.5:38She says he assured her the government wouldn't go after Belgol's family, including5:42his son.5:43The competing accounts of the release talks ended with Belgal still in federal5:46custody.5:47Protests and marches followed near the shooting scene and outside a hospital.5:51Demonstrators demanded justice.5:53Some demonstrations involved scuffles with police and arrests.5:56A Democratic congressional nominee said an NYPD officer pushed her to the ground6:00during a protest.6:01Rep.6:02Grace Meng called for an independent investigation and all-body camera footage.6:06She says she introduced legislation to put ICE's handbook and guidelines into law.6:11Senator Chuck Schumer also called on DHS to release the footage.6:14Whether Belgol's car threatened officers when they fired is still unresolved.6:18The public footage leaves that moment unseen.6:21The federal agencies defending the shooting hold the recordings they say explain it,6:25while both federal investigators and Bronx prosecutors continue their work.6:29Belgal has temporary protection against deportation.6:32His attorney's October 11th statement places him in Brooklyn federal detention, with6:35a bullet lodged in his neck and surgery still pending.Makaleyi okuHaberin zaman çizelgesiHeyDexKısa video ↗Kim neyi bildirdiBirden fazla yayın organının bildirdiği maddeler✓Man's condition and hospital careBağımsız olarak doğrulandı · 14 yayın organı✓Child in the vehicle during the shootingBağımsız olarak doğrulandı · 13 yayın organı✓Federal agents shot a man in New YorkBağımsız olarak doğrulandı · 12 yayın organıOfficers' stated reason for firing11 yayın organıICE said it was seeking to arrest a Dominican Republic national with a prior grand-larceny convicti…11 yayın organıNeck injury from the gunfire8 yayın organıNumber of rounds ICE agents fired8 yayın organıName and age of the man shot3 yayın organıHer satır, o yayın organının haberinden kaydettiğimiz iddiadır. 14 Ekim 2026 18:06 UTC itibarıyla karşılaştırıldı.
