跳到内容
现在

灾害 · 公寓火灾

丰特奈苏布瓦公寓楼火灾致1人死亡、约30人受伤

临时伤亡统计显示,约有15名居民和15名消防员受伤。火势已得到控制,但尚未公布居民何时可以返回大楼。

文字 阅读需 5 分钟 · 51 个来源

原语言视频

译自英文原文。

11月19日星期四,丰特奈苏布瓦一栋公寓楼的11层发生火灾,一名居民死亡。大火迫使低层住户撤离,而高层住户则留在家中避险。市政府公布的最详细临时统计显示,约30人受伤,其中约15名居民和15名消防员。⁠6⁠4⁠25

根据市政府晚8点的通报,火势已得到控制,燃气危险也已排除。但这并不意味着警报解除:消防员仍在现场作业,尚未确认火势已完全扑灭,也没有公布居民何时能够返回大楼。附近一所学校设立了接待点,供人们聚集,但这并不代表已确认提供过夜住宿。⁠46⁠1

1居民遇难 14
约30居民和消防员受伤;临时统计 423
10低层已疏散 125

这栋18层高的建筑位于巴黎以东、瓦勒德马恩省丰特奈苏布瓦市拉里斯街区的马丁·路德·金街。根据TF1 Info转述的巴黎消防队说法,11层有两套公寓受影响,火焰蔓延至12层。遇难居民被发现于起火楼层。⁠23⁠6

各方说法都确认火灾在傍晚发生,但没有给出一个确切的起火时间。ICI报道称,消防员约在下午4点接到通知;巴黎警察局局长帕特里斯·法尔则称,火灾约在下午5点发生。这是对不断发展的紧急事件的不同描述,两者都没有提供明确的起火时间。⁠25⁠6

消防员称,一套公寓内堆积的家具、物品和杂物助长了火势蔓延。这说明了什么加剧了火灾,而非起火原因。现有报道中,起火原因仍不明。⁠6

救援人员在浓烟中疏散了低层的10层住户。消防部门要求12层至18层的居民在救援期间留在公寓内。这一区别很重要:尽管救援规模很大,但并未确认整栋楼都已疏散。⁠3⁠25

一名居民讲述了自己试图让其他人撤离的经过:她穿过楼梯间,大喊:“所有人都出去”——“Sortez tous”。她的讲述由法国2台晚间节目在franceinfo播出,展现了楼内的混乱;这与消防部门要求高层居民留在原地的指示是两回事。⁠3⁠25

TF1 Info报道称,现场出动了137名消防员和32辆消防车。警察和市政工作人员也在现场。现场设立了安全警戒线,市政府呼吁民众遵守警戒线规定,不要妨碍救援人员工作。⁠23⁠46⁠1

受伤人数变化意味着什么

市政府公布的较完整统计显示,约15名居民和约15名消防员受伤,取代了早期较不完整的数据。CNEWS报道称,市长最初统计至少有8人受伤,其中包括3名消防员。BFM报道的市政府数据则显示,总计约15人受伤。这些是对同一场紧急事件不同阶段的统计,不是需要相加的不同人群。没有任何一项被确定为最终伤亡数字。⁠4⁠7⁠1

瓦勒德马恩省省长斯坦尼斯拉斯·布隆在法国2台的报道中明确指出这一限制:由于救援行动仍在持续,伤员人数只是临时统计;他预计当晚晚些时候会有最终评估。现有资料无法证实之后是否公布了最终汇总数字。⁠3

消防部门另行确认,5名居民受轻伤,主要因吸入烟雾接受治疗。这项较窄的临床统计并非市政府公布的受伤居民总数。Actu.fr还报道称,消防部门临时统计有4人属于最高紧急程度类别,但未说明他们是居民还是消防员,因此无法据此安全地作出更详细分类。⁠25⁠4

医院转运数据也需要谨慎解读。BFM报道,消防部门最初称有3名消防员被紧急送往军方医院;而法尔后来表示,有2名消防员被转送,两人均无生命危险。法国2台早期报道称,两名住院消防员伤势轻微。⁠1⁠3

ICI报道的消防部门较详细说明称,两名消防员伤势严重但没有生命危险,被送往珀西军医院。另有一名伤势较轻的消防员被送往当地医院,救援期间还有约10人感到不适。TF1 Info也报道称,两名伤员被紧急送往珀西。较详细的说法取代了早期关于轻伤的描述,但并不能证明有人伤势恶化。⁠25⁠23

两人被送往珀西、另有一人被送往其他医院,这有助于解释为何报道中会出现转送医院人数为2人和3人的不同说法。但这并不能证实最初所称的3人都被送往军方医院。医院转运人数也不应与约15名受伤消防员这一更广泛的统计混为一谈。⁠1⁠25⁠4

火势受控,不等于可以回家

晚上7点前不久,市政府宣布在朗格万学校的有顶操场设立接待点,供受公寓楼火灾影响的居民及其家属使用。市政府还向遇难居民家属表示哀悼,并向伤者及其亲友表达慰问。⁠46⁠4

这一接待安排解决了眼前的需求:为大楼居民提供一个去处。但它没有说明有多少户需要床位、他们当晚会在哪里过夜,也没有说明他们可能多久无法回家。相关报道没有提供经确认的过夜住宿方案、检查结果或允许居民返家的通知。⁠1⁠25⁠46

因此,市政府宣布火势受控是重要的救援进展,但对住在楼里的居民而言,紧急状况并未结束。仍有几个问题亟待明确答复:火灾是否已完全扑灭,哪些住所可以安全入住,以及无法返家的居民将获得何种住宿安排。

如需咨询火灾相关事宜,市政府公布的联系电话为 01 49 74 74 74。⁠25

来源34

在此处引用的来源中,X (formerly Twitter)最先发布,比本报道播出早4天。 随后还有24家媒体发布。

10篇早期文章作为背景资料参阅。7家媒体未注明日期:fontenay.frleparisien.frgouv.frici.frlepoint.frSaper Vedere

按媒体查看所有来源

来自 34 家媒体的 51 个来源· 引用最多的优先

播出原貌
  1. A fire on the eleventh floor of an apartment tower killed a resident.
  2. The city’s latest tally puts the number injured at about thirty, roughly fifteen residents and fifteen firefighters. Crews evacuated ten floors of the tower. When will the people who live there be able to go home?
  3. Firefighters found the resident who died on the same floor where the fire began late Thursday afternoon. The eighteen-storey tower stands in the Larris neighborhood of Fontenay-sous-Bois, just east of Paris, in Val-de-Marne.
  4. Two apartments on the eleventh floor were hit, and the flames reached the twelfth. Firefighters say a buildup of furniture, belongings and debris in one apartment helped the fire spread. They still don’t know what started it.
  5. Firefighters evacuated the ten lower floors through thick smoke. From the twelfth floor up to the eighteenth, the brigade told residents to stay in their apartments while crews worked.
  6. One resident said she tried to get people out. She went through the stairwell and shouted, “Everybody out.”
  7. A hundred and thirty-seven firefighters and thirty-two vehicles were deployed. Police and municipal workers were there too, and a safety cordon went up around the scene. The city asked people to keep clear so emergency crews could do their work.
  8. Subscribe to this channel for updates on when residents can return home.
  9. The mayor’s first count was at least eight injured, including three firefighters. The city also gave an early figure of about fifteen injured overall. Val-de-Marne prefect Stanislas Bourron said crews were still working and he expected a final tally later that evening.
  10. The brigade identified five residents with minor injuries, most treated for breathing in smoke. It also listed four people in its highest emergency category without saying who they were. The broader city tally counts residents and responders together, and it’s still provisional.
  11. The Paris Fire Brigade initially said three firefighters were rushed to a military hospital. Paris police prefect Patrice Faure later put the number evacuated at two. Both said the injuries in those counts weren’t life-threatening.
  12. The brigade later described two firefighters with serious injuries rushed to Percy military hospital. An earlier account had described the injuries of the two hospitalized firefighters as minor. The brigade also said a third, less seriously injured firefighter went to a local hospital. That could explain the different counts. About ten other firefighters felt unwell after the response.
  13. The city opened the covered schoolyard at Langevin school for residents and families from the tower. By eight that evening, the city said crews had contained the fire and ruled out a gas hazard. Crews were still working, and it’s not yet confirmed that the fire’s fully out.
  14. The city offered condolences to the resident’s family and support to the injured and their loved ones. For inquiries, the city’s number is oh one, forty-nine, seventy-four, seventy-four, seventy-four. The school gave families a place to go. The city hasn’t announced an overnight housing plan or said when residents can go back into the tower.

译文更新于

近期播出