司法 · White House press accessJudge Blocks Trump’s Press Ban During CNN, MS NOW and Politico Lawsuit文字 2026年10月14日 下午4:05 [UTC]觀看逐字稿0:07On October 12th, we reported restored press passes.0:10Now a judge has strengthened that protection.0:13CNN, MS Now, and Politico can keep working on press-accessible White House grounds0:17while their lawsuit proceeds.0:19The administration cannot revive the challenged credential ban while that protection0:23holds.0:23The unresolved fight is how far those credentials actually get journalists.0:27Judge Timothy Kelly issued the preliminary injunction on October 13th.0:31It protects the journalists' hard passes, the credentials that let them work on0:35White House grounds.0:36Access to the Oval Office, Air Force One, and rotating press pool assignments0:41remains unsettled.0:42The protection reaches the people doing the work, including reporters, producers,0:46and other credentialed staff.0:48Their employers challenged both the reason for excluding them and the way officials0:52revoked their passes.0:54Kelly has now found they're likely to win on both constitutional fronts.0:57Trump announced the ban on September 18th, saying he was proud to announce it took1:01effect immediately.1:02Journalists from the three organizations appeared the next day with their hard1:06passes and were denied entry.1:07Their credentials had been formally deactivated.1:10More than 70 journalists were reportedly affected across the three organizations.1:14That gives the scale of the exclusion rather than an exact count of everyone1:18protected by the new injunction.1:20The outlets sued to regain the access they'd held before Trump's announcement.1:24Kelly first restored credential access on September 24th with a temporary1:28restraining order described as lasting 14 days.1:30On October 8th, he extended protection through October 13th.1:34That day, he issued the preliminary injunction that now protects access during the1:38lawsuit.1:38The earlier order rested on the outlets' likely success on due process without1:42deciding their First Amendment claims.1:44The new decision reaches retaliation and viewpoint discrimination as well.1:48Kelly's assessment remains preliminary.1:50The lawsuit still has to resolve the claims, and further court orders can change the1:54protection.1:55Kelly found that Trump's public statements and social media posts pointed toward1:59pressure for more favorable reporting.2:01The organizations had been selected because Trump regarded their coverage as2:05inaccurate and biased.2:06That motive supports the outlets' claims that officials punish protected journalism.2:10Retaliation means punishing journalists for protected reporting.2:14Viewpoint discrimination means excluding them because of the perspectives their2:17coverage expresses.2:18Kelly found likely success on both claims, alongside due process.2:22Those findings give the outlets a stronger basis for keeping their credentials while2:26the case proceeds.2:27The administration invoked national security to defend the restrictions.2:30Kelly rejected that justification as insufficient to justify this ban at this stage.2:34The due process problem was separate.2:36Journalists lacked appropriate notice and clear standards, fair warning before2:40losing their passes, and a meaningful opportunity to challenge the accusations and2:43appeal.2:44Trump also cited negative coverage figures of 96% and 93% in connection with the2:50ban.2:50It's still unclear how those figures were calculated.2:53His dissatisfaction with coverage is central to the dispute over whether officials2:57used the credential system to pressure the outlets.2:59Restored credentials didn't settle event access in September.3:03CNN and MS Now journalists were refused entry to a September 24 evening event at the3:08North Portico.3:10CNN also remained excluded from an Air Force One assignment.3:13Those incidents preceded the new injunction.3:16The October ruling leaves those narrower reporting opportunities unresolved.3:20A hard pass allows work on press accessible grounds, while a pool assignment3:24determines who enters a smaller setting or travels with the president.3:27The court hasn't settled those assignments, so the credential victory only partly3:31closes the access gap.3:32Five television networks face a separate Justice Department investigation, ABC, CBS,3:37CNN, NBC, and Fox News.3:39They rotate shared presidential TV coverage.3:41That inquiry concerns their response to CNN's exclusion from pool shifts, and the3:45access injunction doesn't resolve it.3:47When CNN was scheduled to cover a pool shift but couldn't enter, the other networks3:51agreed not to replace it.3:53They made those decisions day by day.3:55Shared TV pool coverage stopped temporarily for several days in September and later3:59resumed.4:00The interruption concerned that shared coverage while the networks broader reporting4:04continued.4:04The Justice Department sent civil investigative demands for pool-related4:08communications on October 9th and announced its formal investigation on October4:1210th.4:13Those are the same investigative steps described in the earlier update.4:16The department is examining whether cooperation among competing commercial networks4:20violated federal competition law.4:22The Justice Department says group boycotts among commercial competitors can violate4:26the Sherman Act, a federal competition law.4:29It says its antitrust division is investigating whether the networks broke those4:32laws.4:33The inquiry continues without an announced finding of wrongdoing.4:36That theory has drawn criticism from legal experts.4:39The dispute is whether the network's refusal to substitute for CNN amounted to4:43conduct restraining trade or a protected response to the exclusion of fellow4:47journalists.4:48A court hasn't resolved that question in this investigation.4:51Jessica Roth and Nancy Gertner assessed the inquiry as apparently meritless and4:55argued that the network's conduct was protected by the First Amendment.4:58Former U.S.4:59Attorney Joyce Vance argued that their response didn't restrain trade for commercial5:03impact.5:04Those are legal assessments.5:05The department hasn't announced charges or an enforcement action.5:08The evidence supporting its theory and the network's substantive responses to the5:12demands remain unclear.5:13Kelly's injunction protects White House credentials while that separate5:16investigation continues.5:17The administration is expected to appeal to the DC Circuit, but it isn't clear yet5:21whether it has filed.5:22For now, CNN, MSNOW, and Politico have stronger court protection against the5:26credential ban.5:28Their access to the Oval Office Air Force One and rotating press pool assignments5:32remains unsettled.閱讀文章事件時間軸HeyDex短片 ↗誰報導了什麼多家媒體報導的要點The Justice Department has launched a formal antitrust investigation into ABC, CBS, CNN, NBC and Fo…3 家媒體✓Joyce Vance said the networks’ pool-coverage response did not amount to an antitrust boycott becaus…已獨立證實 · 3 家媒體Donald Trump blocked CNN, MS Now and Politico from the White House in September 2026.2 家媒體✓The networks temporarily suspended the shared White House TV pool system for several days in Septem…已獨立證實 · 2 家媒體The injunction is limited to hard passes and access to press-accessible White House grounds; it doe…2 家媒體The Justice Department said group boycotts among commercial competitors can violate the Sherman Act.2 家媒體Oyer said First Amendment questions, including viewpoint discrimination and retaliation for protect…2 家媒體The Trump administration could appeal the preliminary injunction.2 家媒體僅一家媒體報導的要點16僅BBC News報導The US Department of Justice says it is investigating whether television networks violated federal …10月11日 上午12:49 UTC僅NPR報導Judge Timothy J. Kelly ruled late Tuesday that President Trump could not ban the news organizations…10月14日 上午7:16 UTCJudge Timothy J. Kelly ruled late yesterday that Trump cannot bar news organizations from covering …10月14日 上午11:38 UTCKelly found that the decision to bar more than 70 journalists from CNN, MS NOW and Politico violate…10月14日 上午7:16 UTCKelly found that the credential revocations violated the journalists’ due-process rights.10月14日 上午7:16 UTCThe Justice Department opened a formal antitrust investigation into ABC, CBS, CNN, NBC and Fox News.10月12日 上午11:29 UTCKelly found that Trump’s exclusion of more than 70 journalists from CNN, MS NOW and Politico violat…10月14日 上午11:38 UTCThe investigation concerns whether coordination among the five networks over White House television…10月11日 下午12:04 UTC僅MS NOW報導Judge Kelly issued a preliminary injunction restoring MS NOW, CNN and Politico’s access to the Whit…10月14日 上午10:04 UTCThe judge found the ban likely violated the First Amendment through retaliation against the outlets…10月14日 上午10:04 UTCThe judge rejected the administration’s national-security rationale, citing Trump’s public statemen…10月14日 上午10:04 UTC僅NBC News報導Judge Timothy Kelly reportedly issued a preliminary injunction late Tuesday, October 13, blocking t…10月14日 上午4:11 UTCFederal judge Timothy Kelly issued an order blocking the Trump administration from barring CNN, Pol…10月14日 下午12:43 UTCThe ruling reportedly restores White House complex access for 78 journalists holding hard passes.10月14日 上午4:11 UTC僅The Hill報導Judge Timothy Kelly extended the block on the pass revocations indefinitely while the lawsuit is pe…10月14日 下午1:07 UTCShfeld said Kelly found the revocations violated the reporters’ First Amendment rights.10月14日 下午1:07 UTC每一行都是我們從該媒體報導中記錄的說法。比較截至 2026年10月14日 下午5:36 [UTC]。
