Skip to content
Now

Politics · Data center approvals

San José wants its data-center rules in force before projects slip through

Google’s planned 250-megawatt Alviso facility could win approval before new standards take effect. A proposed pause would close that gap—not settle residents’ larger concerns.

Written 6 min read · 18 sources

Google’s planned research facility in Alviso could draw 250 megawatts of electricity at capacity. City officials say it is one of two projects that could win San José’s approval before new environmental and labor standards take effect—the opening the mayor and four councilmembers now want to close.⁠2

Mayor Matt Mahan and Councilmembers Pamela Campos, David Cohen, Peter Ortiz and Domingo Candelas proposed on November 12 temporarily withholding new land-use approvals for data centers and other large-energy-use projects until the city’s rules are approved and implemented. Neither that pause nor a companion urgency ordinance has been adopted. This is a proposal to stop approvals from outrunning regulation, not an existing ban on construction or operation.⁠1

The full council is scheduled to consider the pause on November 17. Its immediate purpose is narrow: make projects face the same standards, rather than let timing determine which developers escape them. Whether those standards are strong enough is a separate question—and residents and environmental groups are not prepared to treat a few weeks’ delay as an answer.⁠2⁠3

We will not consider any project until we have the strongest possible regulations not just approved, but implemented.

Mahan and the four councilmembers 1

The gap between approval and enforcement

That last word matters. Voting for an ordinance does not ordinarily make it effective immediately. In its October 15 report, CBS Bay Area described an anticipated December council decision, a tentative December 15 second reading and another 30 days before the law would take effect. That was the earlier implementation plan, not a settled timetable for the new proposal. Mahan and his colleagues now want an urgency ordinance to make the standards effective immediately after the scheduled December 8 vote.⁠18⁠1

San José’s scheduled decisions

  1. November 17, 2026

    The full council considers the proposed approval pause.

    2
  2. November 18, 2026

    The Planning Commission reviews the proposed development standards.

    23
  3. December 8, 2026

    The council is scheduled to vote on the standards; immediate implementation would also require approval of the proposed urgency measure.

    12

Google’s project, at 5087 Disk Drive in the city’s northern Alviso neighborhood, gives the procedural argument a concrete target. San José Spotlight reported that it could secure approval ahead of the standards; KQED subsequently reported officials’ identification of it as one of two potentially early projects. The second project was not named in that reporting.⁠3⁠2

The research-and-development label would not necessarily exempt Google. Deputy City Manager Manuel Pineda told CBS Bay Area in October that the standards would apply equally to data centers and research-and-development facilities drawing more than 20 megawatts. The final legal scope remains to be established.⁠18

The scale also needs careful labeling. Google’s 250 megawatts is proposed capacity, not electricity already being consumed. Several planned data centers and other large-energy-use projects in historically underserved northern San José could collectively draw more than 800 megawatts. That is potential future demand, not today’s measured load. An approval secured during a short regulatory gap could nevertheless shape a large facility’s obligations for years.⁠2

Nor is there a clean month-to-month application count. Officials counted 11 data-center applications under review in October, a figure repeated in CBS Bay Area’s November announcement coverage. San José Spotlight’s November 12 report described 16 projects in the broader development pipeline. Different dates and development stages do not establish that five new applications arrived. They do establish that the city is writing rules with substantial development already in view.⁠18⁠1⁠3

What developers would have to meet

The announced package would require 100% carbon-neutral electricity, restrictions on cooling and backup generators, continuing monitoring, and skilled-and-trained workforce and prevailing-wage requirements. These remain proposed obligations, not requirements already imposed by the November announcement.⁠1

Officials have described prohibiting open-loop cooling, with particular concern about systems consuming drinking water. Alternatives include recycled water and closed-loop systems that circulate water through pipes to absorb equipment heat. Neither approach should be mistaken for a promise of zero water use. Similarly, “carbon-neutral electricity” does not by itself establish carbon-free power matched to a facility’s consumption every hour. The final requirements and accounting rules will determine what the promise delivers.⁠1⁠3

For backup generators, officials have identified EPA Tier 4, which they describe as the strictest emissions standard. November reporting also describes limiting diesel operation to power outages. The final treatment of testing, maintenance and other exceptions is not established by those accounts—a consequential detail for neighbors concerned about how often engines would actually run.⁠18⁠3

Pineda outlined sound barriers around equipment, a noise-monitoring program and annual reporting for noise, sewage, electricity and water use. He said enforcement could include penalties or additional work to bring projects into compliance. Those continuing obligations matter: a permit condition is only as useful as the city’s ability to check it after a facility opens.⁠18

A draft zoning ordinance would make the planning director the initial decision-maker on large-energy project permits, with appeals going to the council. Mahan has also described proposed bans on nondisclosure agreements and public subsidies, while developers would be encouraged to enroll with San José Clean Energy. Community benefits are part of the package, but no final payment formula or allocation has been announced. Supporting affordable housing and keeping new costs off residents remain stated goals, not demonstrated financial outcomes.⁠5⁠3⁠2

A short pause, a larger argument

The mayor is trying to regulate an industry he has actively recruited. For more than a year, Mahan has promoted a PG&E deal intended to guarantee power availability and city staff offering developers what he calls “concierge-style support.” The proposed pause is not a reversal of that strategy. It is an acknowledgment that recruitment and regulation have been moving on different clocks.⁠2

Mahan told KQED he would accept losing projects unwilling to meet a high bar. His description of the standards as among the nation’s strictest is a political assessment, however, not an established comparison across jurisdictions.⁠2

In Alviso, the stakes are less abstract. CBS Bay Area’s October account described a neighborhood of roughly 2,000 residents, with a Microsoft data center already under construction and neighbors worried about noise, air pollution and development near homes, a library and waterways. Those concerns are not proof that a named facility has caused illness or a pollution violation. They are reasons residents want protections settled before more approvals, not reassurances afterward.⁠18

Green Foothills supports stopping projects from slipping through. But its policy and advocacy director, Alice Kaufman, told KQED the proposed standards remain too weak, particularly on air and noise pollution from backup generators and cooling equipment. Supporting equal treatment does not mean endorsing the rules everyone would face.⁠2

Linda Hutchins-Knowles, co-founder of Mothers Out Front Silicon Valley, likewise welcomed the pause while seeking a longer moratorium. She called the community engagement rushed and insufficient. City leaders, by contrast, describe months of extensive outreach and dozens of meetings with residents, neighborhood associations, environmental advocates, labor and businesses. The dispute is not whether meetings occurred; it is whether they provided enough time and influence to assess the development contemplated.⁠3⁠1

Eight environmental and advocacy groups, including Green Foothills, the Sierra Club Loma Prieta Chapter and Alviso in Action, have requested studies of long-term cumulative impacts. Their concerns include heat accumulation and low-frequency sound. Their projection that the contemplated development could triple city energy use remains the groups’ estimate, not an independently established outcome.⁠3

Planning Director Chris Burton acknowledged the limits in a November 6 memorandum quoted by San José Spotlight: “While the proposed standards do not address every concern raised through the community engagement process, they represent that balance.” That is the choice the council faces—not a framework that satisfies everyone, but one officials consider sufficient to let development proceed.⁠3

November 17 is the first test: whether the council will withhold approvals while it finishes the rules. December brings the harder test of adopting standards and making them effective before affected projects receive permission. Closing that gap would prevent unequal treatment. It would not, by itself, answer what several large facilities together would mean for the community around them.

Sources12

Of the sources cited here, CaliforniaTimesOnline published first, 28 hours before this report aired. 7 more outlets followed.

2 older pieces read for background.4 outlets with no date:sanjoseca.govGovTechilovesanjose.orgOffice of Mayor Matt Mahan

Every source, by outlet

18 sources from 12 outlets· Most cited first

As aired
  1. Google plans a 250-megawatt research facility.
  2. City officials say it could win approval before new environmental and labor rules take effect. San José's mayor and four councilmembers want to hold up approvals until those protections are in place.
  3. Will the city get enforceable rules into effect before these projects get permission to proceed?
  4. Google's planned facility is in Alviso, in northern San José. City officials identified it as one of two projects potentially headed for approval before the standards took effect. The proposed pause would cover data centers and other large-energy projects.
  5. Mayor Matt Mahan announced the proposal November 12 with Councilmembers Pamela Campos, David Cohen, Peter Ortiz and Domingo Candelas. The full council still has to decide. Both the approval pause and a companion measure to speed up the rules remain proposals.
  6. The council considers the pause November 17. The Planning Commission reviews the standards November 18, ahead of a scheduled December 8 council vote. The sponsors want projects held until those standards are approved and implemented.
  7. A vote alone wouldn't ordinarily put the rules into effect immediately. In October, officials anticipated a tentative December 15 second reading, followed by a 30-day wait. The sponsors now want an urgency ordinance to replace that delay with immediate implementation after the December vote.
  8. Google's 250 megawatts describes proposed capacity. Several planned data centers and other large-energy projects in the historically underserved northern part of the city could collectively draw more than 800 megawatts. Those figures describe potential future demand.
  9. The Google project is described as research and development. Deputy City Manager Manuel Pineda said in October that the proposed standards would apply equally to data centers and research facilities drawing more than 20 megawatts.
  10. Officials counted 11 data-center applications under review in October. A broader November count puts 16 projects in the development pipeline. Those numbers cover different dates and development stages, so they don't tell us that five new applications arrived.
  11. An approval before the standards take effect could shape a large facility's obligations for years. The proposed pause would withhold new land-use approvals while the city finishes its requirements. Existing facilities would continue operating.
  12. The proposed rules require 100% carbon-neutral electricity. They also set obligations for water and energy use, with continuing monitoring. Developers would be encouraged to enroll with San José Clean Energy, which supplies renewable power.
  13. City officials also propose banning open-loop cooling, particularly systems that consume drinking water. Alternatives they've described include recycled water and closed-loop systems, which circulate water through pipes to absorb heat from equipment.
  14. Backup generators would have to meet EPA Tier 4, the emissions standard officials describe as the strictest. Leaders also want diesel operation limited to power outages. The final treatment of testing and maintenance still needs to be settled.
  15. The noise proposals include sound barriers around equipment and a monitoring program. Officials have also described annual reporting for noise, sewage, electricity and water use, with penalties or additional work available to bring projects into compliance.
  16. A draft ordinance would make the planning director the initial decision-maker on large-energy project permits, with appeals going to the council. The proposed reporting requirements would continue after approval, giving officials information to check whether facilities meet their obligations.
  17. Subscribe to this channel as San José decides whether these protections will arrive before project approvals.
  18. Mahan has spent more than a year recruiting data centers. He has promoted a PG&E deal intended to guarantee power availability, and city staff have offered developers what he calls concierge-style support. He still wants development under stricter conditions.
  19. The package includes a skilled-and-trained workforce requirement and prevailing wages. Mahan also describes proposed bans on nondisclosure agreements and public subsidies. He wants community benefits to support affordable housing and keep new costs off residents, although a final benefit formula hasn't been announced.
  20. Mahan says he's willing to lose projects that won't meet a high bar. He calls the proposed standards among the nation's strictest. Residents and environmental groups dispute whether the protections go far enough.
  21. The city began drafting the standards in June. Officials describe dozens of meetings with residents, neighborhood associations, environmental advocates, labor and businesses. Some participants say the process was rushed and left too little time to assess the consequences of several facilities together.
  22. Alviso has roughly 2,000 residents. A Microsoft data center was already under construction there in October. Neighbors worry about noise, air pollution and water demand around an established community of homes, a library and waterways.
  23. Green Foothills supports making Google and other projects face the same rules. But its policy and advocacy director, Alice Kaufman, says the proposed standards remain too weak, especially on air and noise pollution from backup generators and cooling equipment.
  24. Linda Hutchins-Knowles, co-founder of Mothers Out Front Silicon Valley, also welcomes stopping approvals. She wants a longer moratorium to develop stronger standards and says the city's community engagement was rushed and insufficient.
  25. Green Foothills and other groups rallied before an October 15 community meeting for studies of the long-term public-health effects of data-center clusters. Eight groups, including the Sierra Club Loma Prieta Chapter and Alviso in Action, have called for studies of cumulative impacts.
  26. Those groups project that the contemplated development could triple the city's energy use. They also want heat accumulation and low-frequency sound examined. The People Over Data Centers San Jose Coalition has organized meetings and town halls across council districts.
  27. Planning Director Chris Burton acknowledged in a November 6 memorandum that the standards don't address every community concern. He described them as a balance. Ortiz says industries using the city's resources should help address challenges such as affordability.
  28. The proposed pause could make projects face the same rules if the council adopts it and gets the standards into effect first. The longer-term effects of several facilities together are what residents still want studied. A few weeks' delay wouldn't provide those studies.
  29. The council's first scheduled decision is November 17, on whether to withhold approvals. Its December 8 standards vote would also need an approved urgency ordinance to put the new requirements into effect immediately.

Aired recently