رفتن به محتوا
اکنون

سلامت · Rabies in Israel

Rabies in central Israel: the dog suspected in the case was never tested

A woman in her thirties is critical with rabies, Israel's first human case since 2024. The stray suspected of infecting her showed neurological signs before it died in September, and a vet sent its body to be destroyed without a test.

مکتوب 7 دقیقه مطالعه · ۲۵ منبع

به زبان انگلیسی در دسترس است

How will anyone know whether a stray dog gave a woman in her thirties rabies, when the dog's body was destroyed in September without a test? That question hangs over Israel's first human rabies case since 2024. Right now the answer is that they may never know. The woman is in critical condition in the general intensive care unit at Shamir Medical Center, also known as Assaf Harofeh, in Be'er Ya'akov. The suspected source was a stray female American Bully. Before it died, the Agriculture Ministry says, it showed neurological signs.⁠1⁠6

The hospital said on Thursday morning, November 19, that she was still critical. By that afternoon the Times of Israel reported that her condition had got worse and that she was fighting for her life. She lives on a moshav, a farming village, in the Shephelah lowlands. She came to the hospital about two weeks ago feeling unwell and was moved to intensive care as she deteriorated. The lab result confirming rabies arrived only on Wednesday evening. Once symptoms begin, rabies is almost always fatal.⁠6⁠3

The Health Ministry called the case highly unusual, because no Israeli had been diagnosed with rabies for a long time. Haaretz described her as the first person in Israel to catch the disease since 2024. The ministry says she was infected this summer. Its epidemiological investigation names the dog as a possible source of exposure, not a confirmed one.⁠5⁠7⁠1

What the paper trail shows

Most of what is known about the dog comes from the Agriculture Ministry's preliminary investigation, which it summarized in a letter to veterinarians. The dog roamed the Kfar Ruth area, a moshav near Modi'in, for more than a month. Then a local woman active in animal rights took it in. She passed it on to a home in Kfar Shmuel, and a vet clinic in the area treated it. About two weeks after it was picked up, the dog was spayed and vaccinated against rabies at the same time. It got worse the next day, September 9, and died. The vet sent the body to be destroyed.⁠6

From roadside stray to confirmed diagnosis

  1. From Aug 17

    Start of the window in which health officials want anyone who had contact with a dog around Kfar Ruth to come forward.

    2
  2. Aug 26–27

    The dog is in the playground next to the Gan Keshet kindergarten in Kfar Ruth.

    8
  3. Aug 27

    The stray American Bully is found near Kfar Ruth.

    1
  4. Early September

    Spayed and vaccinated against rabies, about two weeks after it was taken off the streets.

    6
  5. Sep 9

    The dog deteriorates and dies. The vet sends the body to be destroyed, untested.

    6
  6. Wed Nov 18, evening

    Lab results confirm rabies in the woman, who has been in hospital for about two weeks.

    6
  7. Thu Nov 19

    Her condition is reported to have worsened. The regional council runs a dog vaccination drive in Kfar Ruth.

    3

The ministry says its investigation turned up "serious findings" about how the dog was handled. It published a photo of the dog and warned the public not to take stray animals into their homes. Officials have not said whether the patient is the woman who picked the dog up or the friend in Kfar Shmuel who took it in. The Modi'in Regional Council, which covers Kfar Ruth, told residents that the woman who collected the dog did not know it was infected. It said she gave the dog to a friend in Kfar Shmuel with no further contact in Kfar Ruth, and that she has been vaccinated and is fine.⁠3⁠11⁠6

The rabies shot given at spaying does not settle anything either way. Officials have not explained why the dog was vaccinated then. A vaccine given to an animal that is already incubating the virus would not be expected to protect it, so the shot does not rule the dog out.

In the same letter, the ministry told vets the rule they are supposed to follow. Any dog or pet brought in with neurological signs, sudden decline or an unexplained death, especially from infected areas or with a history of being picked up as a stray, "requires immediate suspicion of rabies" and coordination with the district veterinary office. Set against its own account of September 9, that rule shows where the case went wrong. A stray, recently picked up, declined suddenly and died with neurological signs. It was still disposed of.⁠6

The question no one can now answer

Dr. Michael Ettinger, chairman of the Israel Veterinary Medical Association, has demanded "a deep, transparent and full professional investigation" rather than general lessons learned. His questions follow the timeline step by step. Did anyone suspect rabies at the time? Was the municipal vet or the district veterinary office told? Did anyone consider sending the body to the national veterinary institute for testing before it was destroyed? Was any biological material kept that would allow a molecular comparison with the virus found in the woman?⁠6

The last question decides the case. Without a sample from the dog, nobody can sequence its virus against hers and prove or rule out a link. Ettinger also wants to know whether the virus from the patient has been sequenced. He is calling for a joint investigation by the Health Ministry, the veterinary services, the national rabies laboratory and everyone who handled the animal.⁠6

The goal is not to look for someone to blame. The goal is to identify the point at which the chain of identification, reporting and treatment did not work as it should have, in order to prevent the next case.

Dr. Michael Ettinger, Israel Veterinary Medical Association 6

The last human case had a similar gap in reporting. A 77-year-old shepherd from the Nazareth area was bitten by a dog. He sought care only about a month later, once symptoms had started, and died on November 2, 2024, at HaEmek Medical Center. Israel Hayom reported then that the dog died around its observation quarantine and that the municipal vet did not report the death. The paper's own headline and subheadline disagreed on whether the shepherd was offered preventive shots and refused them or never received them. That point was never settled.⁠21⁠23

What people near Kfar Ruth should do

The Health Ministry asks anyone who thinks they had contact with a dog in or around Kfar Ruth from August 17 onward to contact their nearest health bureau soon, so officials can decide whether they need preventive treatment. The Agriculture Ministry goes further and says any person or animal that may have touched the stray near Modi'in in August should be vaccinated. The urgency is real even three months on, because preventive shots work only before symptoms begin. No figure has been released for how many people have come forward.⁠2⁠3

The Health Ministry stresses that rabies very rarely passes between people, mainly through organ transplants. It is not airborne and does not spread through contact with unbroken skin. The regional council ran a vaccination drive for dogs in Kfar Ruth on Thursday afternoon.⁠10⁠6

A record animal outbreak

102Animal rabies cases in 2025, a record 12
115Animal cases in 2026 by November 12 13
55Animal cases in 2024 12

The woman fell ill in the middle of an animal outbreak that has set records two years running. Israel recorded 29 animal rabies cases in 2022 and 55 in 2024. In 2025 it recorded 102, well past the previous record of 74 set in 2017. Agriculture Ministry data showed 115 diagnosed cases by November 12 this year, more than any full year before it, with about seven weeks still to go. Yael Arkin, CEO of the animal-welfare group Let the Animals Live, puts this year's count at 117, 61 of them in dogs. The two figures differ by two cases, and they may be counted differently and cover slightly different dates.⁠12⁠14⁠13⁠6

Reports describe the disease spreading from the north into the Sharon and central regions, and most infected animals are now dogs. The reasons given include the war disrupting drops of oral vaccine bait for wildlife, wild animals crossing from Lebanon and Syria through gaps in the border fence, and defense budget cuts that halted cooperation between military and civilian vets. Arkin adds infected dogs crossing from Palestinian Authority areas. About two weeks ago, a four-year-old Palestinian child died of rabies in Qaffin, a West Bank village north of Tulkarm.⁠18⁠14⁠16⁠19⁠6⁠5

Arkin puts the blame on local government. "Unfortunately, many local authorities across the country do not deal with stray dogs," she said. She said strays are not being caught and quarantined as the rules require, and that the danger is being understood only now that "a young woman has reached a serious condition."⁠6

دانسته‌ها

  • The woman is critical in intensive care and reported to be worsening. The suspected dog showed neurological signs and was destroyed untested on or after September 9. 63
  • The Health Ministry calls the dog only a possible source and says the infection happened this summer. 17

نادانسته‌ها

  • Whether any sample from the dog survives that could be compared genetically with the patient's virus.
  • Whether the patient is the woman who collected the dog or the friend who took it in, and how many people have sought preventive shots.

در ادامه

  • The next hospital update on her condition, and whether the Agriculture Ministry names where reporting broke down.

منابع14

از میان منابع ذکرشده، Google News ישראל (IL:he) نخستین منبعی بود که مطلب خود را منتشر کرد؛ ۲۶ ساعت پیش از پخش این گزارش. ۴ رسانه دیگر پس از آن منتشر کردند.

۱۱ مطلب قدیمی‌تر برای بررسی پیشینه مطالعه شد.۵ رسانه بدون تاریخ:timesofisrael.comFrontiershaipo.co.ilIsrael National Newsisraelhayom.co.il

همه منابع، به تفکیک رسانه

۲۵ منبع از ۱۴ رسانه· پراستنادترین‌ها نخست

مطابق پخش
  1. A woman in her thirties has rabies, a disease that almost always kills once symptoms start.
  2. She's in critical condition in intensive care, and on Thursday she got worse. Health officials want anyone who touched a stray dog around Kfar Ruth since mid-August to come forward for preventive shots.
  3. The dog suspected of infecting her died in September, and its body was destroyed without a rabies test, so the link may never be proven.
  4. She's being treated at Shamir Medical Center, also known as Assaf Harofeh, in Be'er Ya'akov. She lives on a moshav, a farming village, in the Shephelah lowlands of central Israel. The suspected source was a stray dog found by the roadside in Kfar Ruth, near Modi'in.
  5. She came to the hospital about two weeks ago feeling unwell. As she got worse, doctors moved her to the general intensive care unit. The lab result confirming rabies only came back on Wednesday evening. The Health Ministry called the case highly unusual, because no Israeli had been diagnosed with rabies in a long time.
  6. She's the first person in Israel to catch the disease since 2024. That patient was a seventy-seven-year-old shepherd from the Nazareth area who was bitten by a dog. He sought care about a month later, once symptoms had begun, and died on November 2, 2024. It's still unclear whether he was offered preventive shots and refused them, or never got them.
  7. This time the Health Ministry says the woman was infected this summer, and it calls the dog only a possible source. The dog was a stray female American Bully. The Agriculture Ministry's preliminary investigation says it roamed around Kfar Ruth for more than a month before a local animal-rights volunteer took it in. It was later moved to a home in Kfar Shmuel, and a vet clinic in the area treated it.
  8. The dog was in the playground beside the Gan Keshet kindergarten in Kfar Ruth on August 26 and 27, and it was found on August 27. In September it was spayed and vaccinated against rabies at the same time. The next day, September 9, it got worse and died, and a vet sent the body to be destroyed. The woman's rabies was confirmed November 18, and by Thursday she'd got worse.
  9. The Agriculture Ministry says the dog showed neurological signs before it died. Because the body was destroyed, it was never tested for rabies. Officials haven't said whether the patient is the woman who picked the dog up or the friend who took it in. The regional council says the resident who collected it has been vaccinated and is fine.
  10. The Agriculture Ministry says its investigation turned up "serious findings" about how the dog was handled. It published a photo of the dog and warned people not to take stray animals into their homes.
  11. In a letter to vets, the ministry spelled out the rule. Any dog brought in with neurological signs, sudden decline or an unexplained death, especially a stray or one from an infected area, has to be treated at once as a suspected rabies case and reported to the district veterinary office.
  12. Whether she pulls through, and whether that dog is ever tied to her case, are still open. Subscribe to this channel and we'll keep following it, and at heyday dot news.
  13. The head of Israel's veterinary association is demanding a full investigation. Dr. Michael Ettinger, who chairs the Israel Veterinary Medical Association, wants a deep, transparent and full professional inquiry. He's asking whether anyone suspected rabies at the time, whether the veterinary office was told, and whether anyone thought to send the body for testing before it was destroyed.
  14. His sharpest question is whether any sample from the dog was kept. Without one, nobody can compare its virus with the woman's to prove or rule out a link. "The goal is not to look for someone to blame," he said. He wants to find where the chain of reporting and treatment broke, to prevent the next case.
  15. Anyone who thinks they had contact with a dog in or around Kfar Ruth from August 17 on should call their nearest health bureau soon, so officials can decide who needs preventive treatment. The Agriculture Ministry says any person or animal that may have touched the stray near Modi'in in August should be vaccinated.
  16. The Health Ministry stresses that rabies very rarely passes between people, mainly through organ transplants. It doesn't spread through the air or through unbroken skin. The regional council ran a vaccination drive for dogs in Kfar Ruth on Thursday afternoon. Nobody has said how many people have come forward for shots so far.
  17. This human case lands in a record animal outbreak. Israel counted 29 animal rabies cases in 2022 and 55 in 2024. Then came 102 in 2025, well past the old record of 74. By November 12 this year, the count had already reached 115.
  18. Yael Arkin, who runs the animal-welfare group Let the Animals Live, puts this year's count at 117, with 61 of them in dogs. The disease has spread from the north into the Sharon and central regions, and most infected animals are now dogs.
  19. The reasons given start with the war, which disrupted drops of oral vaccine bait for wildlife. Wild animals are crossing from Lebanon and Syria through gaps in the border fence. Defense budget cuts halted cooperation between military and civilian vets. And infected dogs are crossing from Palestinian Authority areas.
  20. Arkin blames local authorities. "Unfortunately, many local authorities across the country do not deal with stray dogs," she said. She says strays aren't being caught and quarantined as the rules require, and that the danger is only being understood now that "a young woman has reached a serious condition."
  21. About two weeks ago, a four-year-old Palestinian child died of rabies in Qaffin, a West Bank village north of Tulkarm.
  22. In central Israel, the woman remains in critical condition. With the dog's body gone, the link to her case may never be proven either way.

تازه پخش‌شده