رفتن به محتوا

درگیری · SEAL selection

Two women reach reported SEAL training milestone, but not qualification

CBS reports that two women advanced farther into BUD/S than any before them. Their different departures—and the Navy’s limited public response—define what that milestone means.

مکتوب 5 دقیقه مطالعه

به زبان انگلیسی در دسترس است

What counts as a breakthrough in Navy SEAL selection when neither candidate finishes the course?

For two women training at Naval Amphibious Base Coronado in California, the answer is progress through an early, punishing stage—not qualification. Both reached the third week of Basic Underwater Demolition/SEAL training, known as BUD/S, according to CBS News. Its reporters, James LaPorta and Eleanor Watson, described that as farther than any woman had advanced since the course opened to women in 2016. One subsequently entered Hell Week. Neither completed BUD/S.⁠1

That is a meaningful reported milestone, but the historical claim has a limit: it has not been independently established through public, candidate-by-candidate Navy records. Naval Special Warfare Command has declined to discuss the women’s individual progress. The account therefore rests on CBS’s reporting, citing multiple sources, rather than an official announcement of a record.⁠1

The report became public on November 4, 2026. That dates the disclosure, not the achievement or either departure. The women had entered training several weeks earlier; exact dates for their progression and exits have not been disclosed. CBS is withholding their names for security and privacy.⁠1

Two candidates, two different exits

The distinction between the women’s experiences matters as much as their shared progress. The naval officer was first “rolled back” to the next class—a reassignment that allows a candidate to continue with a later group. She subsequently asked to leave before Hell Week. The enlisted sailor entered Hell Week and was medically removed during it.⁠1

Those are not interchangeable outcomes. The officer’s rollback was not itself her voluntary departure; that decision came afterward. The enlisted sailor’s removal was medical, not a reported decision to quit. No diagnosis, reason for the officer’s rollback or subsequent training disposition has been disclosed. Nor has the Navy said whether either woman will return.⁠1

The command’s response explains why the public record remains spare. A spokesperson told CBS:

To protect the integrity of NSW Center courses and the privacy of its candidates, we don't discuss the details of any individual selection or non-selection status or where they are in the training pipeline.

Naval Special Warfare Command spokesperson 1

That statement neither confirms the reported record nor contradicts it. It also leaves no basis for reconstructing the women’s medical or personal circumstances. The defensible account is narrower: two reported advances to week three, followed by different exits, with only the enlisted sailor described as entering Hell Week.

Hell Week begins in the fourth week and lasts five and a half days, according to both CBS’s account and an official Naval Special Warfare photo caption. The Navy caption describes about four hours of sleep in total, more than 200 miles of running and more than 20 hours of physical training a day. Candidates carry logs, launch boats into breaking waves and lie in cold ocean water.⁠1⁠39

Reaching that test means surviving substantial selection beforehand. But reaching week three, entering Hell Week and completing Hell Week are three separate achievements. The reporting establishes neither woman as a Hell Week finisher.⁠1

What the attrition figures actually show

The useful context is not simply that SEAL training is hard. It is that many candidates leave—or move to another class—before its most famous ordeal begins. CBS cited Navy figures covering 1998–2023, released through the Freedom of Information Act, showing about 45% of candidates removed or rolled back during the three weeks preceding Hell Week. Its summary also put voluntary withdrawal before Hell Week at about 29%. These are historical figures for the broader candidate population, not rates specific to women.⁠1

The underlying FOIA tables were not available for independent examination for this article. That limits how precisely their denominators and counting rules can be assessed. One distinction is clear in the reported figures, however: removal and rollback are grouped together in some measures. A candidate reassigned to another class has not necessarily permanently left the qualification route.

CBS’s summary put overall attrition across the training route at about 68%. It described the seven-week first phase, which includes Hell Week, as the stage with the greatest losses: 66% were removed or rolled into another class. Around 21% left during Hell Week for voluntary, medical or performance reasons; CBS interpreted that figure as nearly four in five entrants finishing the test.⁠1

Later-stage figures were much lower: 5% in combat diving, 3% in land warfare and under 1% in SEAL Qualification Training. Those percentages concern different stages and groups. They cannot be added together, treated uniformly as permanent departures or converted into either woman’s personal odds of qualifying. What they do show, in the reported historical summary, is how heavily selection falls on the opening weeks.⁠1

There was still a long route ahead. BUD/S lasts roughly six months, followed by roughly another six months of SEAL Qualification Training. The Navy’s personnel guidance distinguishes the two courses and identifies the Trident insignia awarded to SQT graduates as signifying SEAL qualification. Week three is early progress, not a near-graduation result.⁠1⁠30

Women gained access following Defense Secretary Ash Carter’s December 3, 2015 decision to open all military occupations and positions to women beginning in January 2016. That policy opened the opportunity to attempt selection; it did not confer selection or qualification.⁠28

Nor should this reported BUD/S milestone erase earlier service. Women had worked alongside special operations forces for decades. In 2021, a woman graduated from the Navy’s separate special warfare boat-crew training route. Those crews operate heavily armed, high-speed craft that transport SEALs, but they undergo their own selection and training. That graduation was not a SEAL qualification.⁠1

The fairest reading avoids both inflation and dismissal. Neither woman earned a Trident through this attempt. Yet leaving a course does not make the distance reached meaningless, especially in a selection system that removes or reassigns so many candidates early. Their reported progress can mark a boundary moving without proving anything sweeping about women’s eventual success—or failure—as SEAL candidates. Whether week three truly was an unprecedented boundary remains a claim awaiting independent public confirmation.

مطابق پخش
  1. Two women reached week three of Navy SEAL training before leaving the course. Their progress is reportedly the furthest any female candidates have advanced since women gained access to it. One entered Hell Week. The Navy hasn't confirmed whether any woman before them reached the same point.
  2. The women trained at Naval Amphibious Base Coronado in California. They entered Basic Underwater Demolition/SEAL training, usually called BUD/S, several weeks before their progress became public. Both reached its third week, near the beginning of a much longer qualification process.
  3. The candidates were a naval officer and an enlisted sailor. Their paths through training then separated. The officer was moved into the next class, a step called being rolled back. That gives a candidate a later class to continue with. Her decision to leave came afterward.
  4. The officer ultimately asked to leave before Hell Week. The enlisted sailor entered Hell Week and was medically removed during it. So the officer's final departure was voluntary, while the sailor's was medical. Neither completed BUD/S.
  5. The women's names are being withheld for security and privacy. Their progress became public on November fourth, twenty twenty-six, after they had already entered training several weeks earlier. That date marks the disclosure. The training itself had already taken place, including both women's departures from the course.
  6. Candidates carry logs and launch boats into breaking waves during Hell Week. They also lie in cold ocean water. The test begins in the fourth week and lasts five and a half days, pushing physical endurance and the ability to keep working with a team.
  7. Candidates get about four hours of sleep in total across roughly five days. They run around two hundred miles. The Navy's own description puts that distance at more than two hundred miles, with more than twenty hours of physical training a day. Reaching that test means surviving substantial selection beforehand.
  8. About forty-five percent of candidates were removed or rolled back during the three weeks before Hell Week. Those historical Navy figures cover nineteen ninety-eight through twenty twenty-three. They describe the broader candidate population, with reassignment to a later class included in that percentage.
  9. The historical figures also put voluntary withdrawal before Hell Week at about twenty-nine percent. Across the training pipeline, attrition was about sixty-eight percent. The greatest losses came during the seven-week first phase, which includes Hell Week. There, sixty-six percent of candidates were removed or moved into another class.
  10. Around twenty-one percent left during Hell Week, through voluntary withdrawal, medical removal or performance problems. Later, five percent left during the combat-diving phase and three percent during land warfare. Under one percent left during the final SEAL Qualification Training course.
  11. Nearly four in five candidates who entered Hell Week finished it in that historical summary. More candidates left during the preceding weeks than during Hell Week itself. These percentages describe different stages and groups, so they can't be added together. They also don't predict either woman's individual chance of qualifying.
  12. BUD/S lasts roughly six months. SEAL Qualification Training follows and takes roughly another six months. Graduates receive the Trident insignia that signifies qualification as a SEAL. Both women left during the early part of that route, with substantial training still ahead.
  13. Women gained access after the December third, twenty fifteen decision to open all military occupations and positions to women, beginning in January twenty sixteen. Women had already served alongside special operations forces for decades. And in twenty twenty-one, a woman graduated from the Navy's separate special warfare boat-crew training pipeline.
  14. Those boat crews operate heavily armed, high-speed craft that transport SEALs into and out of hostile territory. They have their own selection and training. That earlier graduation marked progress in another naval special warfare occupation, with a different route to qualification.
  15. The week-three milestone for these two women remains a reported first. Naval Special Warfare Command says it won't discuss individual candidates' selection status or position in training, citing course integrity and privacy. The Navy hasn't said whether either woman will return to training.

منابع36

۴۷ منبع از ۳۶ رسانه· پراستنادترین‌ها نخست

کاوش در نقشه کامل تحریریه ↗

تازه پخش‌شده