عدالت · Cockpit attackFlydubai Co-Pilot Assault Finding: Case Moves to UAE, Iran Link Unprovenمکتوب ۱۰ مهر ۱۴۰۵ ساعت ۱۰:۰۸ (UTC)تماشامتن پیادهشده0:09On September 30th, we reported FC-1073 landed safely, with its cause unresolved.0:15Now investigators identify a cockpit assault.0:17Both injured pilots have been moved to the United Arab Emirates, and the flight0:21suspension leaves 1,800 other travelers awaiting repatriation.0:24What does the assault finding establish and what remains unproven about a crash0:28attempt or an Iran connection?0:30Assault is now a preliminary investigative finding, not merely an allegation0:34surrounding an unexplained diversion.0:36The co-pilot assaulted the captain during the flight, and both were injured.0:40That finding is not a court judgment.0:41It does not establish a formally filed criminal charge, a terrorist motive, or a0:46final determination that the attacker deliberately tried to destroy the aircraft.0:50The suspect was sent from Saudi Arabia to the UAE late Thursday, October 1st.0:54Both pilots returned with an Emirati security team.0:57Earlier descriptions of questioning in Saudi Arabia or an expected transfer are now1:01outdated.1:02Security accompanied transfer does not establish a particular extradition procedure,1:06remand order or charging decision.1:08UAE Attorney General Hamad Saif al-Shamsi ordered specialized public prosecutors to1:14investigate on October 1, coordinating with the Civil Aviation Authority and other1:18relevant bodies.1:19The inquiry covers the circumstances, motive, possible terrorist activity, prior1:24planning, and outside direction.1:25Saudi and Emirati officials participated in the initial investigation.1:29Israeli officials are also investigating or seeking involvement, including1:33questioning after the transfer.1:35No completed Israeli interview or scheduled questioning date is established.1:39Smit Makchar was the injured captain, not the attacking co-pilot.1:42Some early accounts reversed those roles and inconsistent spellings made the same1:46Indian captain appear under several names.1:48The newer preliminary finding resolves that central distinction, but not every1:52action either man took inside the cockpit.1:54The suspect's public name and specified criminal charges remain unestablished.1:58Makchar is now reported stable and recovering in an Abu Dhabi hospital.2:02He initially received treatment in Tobuk for reported head and hand wounds and2:06underwent surgery.2:07Severe early descriptions were followed by updates that he was stable, out of2:11danger, and recovering well.2:12India's ambassador to the UAE, Deepak Mittal, visited him.2:16An earlier destination account placed him in Dubai.2:19Whether that described an intermediate movement or an error remains unresolved, Abu2:23Dhabi is the current location account.2:24The injured suspect has no comparable final recovery update.2:28The badly injured captain reportedly unlocked or opened the cockpit door, allowing2:32help to enter passengers and crew restrained the attacker and pulled him out.2:35The reported restraint included headphone cables.2:38Two pilots traveling off duty, also described as reserve pilots, reportedly helped2:43regain control, stabilize the aircraft, and land it.2:46A passenger, Yaniv Hayun, reportedly used a chokehold to remove the attacker, then2:51returned to the cockpit and pulled back the controls before another pilot took over.2:55That remains a recollection, not an independently verified reconstruction of the2:58aircraft's movements.3:00Who first restrained the attacker, who first moved the controls, and which pilots3:04handled the subsequent flight and landing remain unsettled.3:06A dentist traveling as a passenger reportedly treated the captain's heavy bleeding3:10from his head and hands.3:12His name appears as Shoda Musaev, Shoda Musaev and Musaev Shoda.3:16An authoritative spelling and the precise treatment method are not established.3:20The restrained suspect reportedly asked to be killed.3:23That recollection does not establish a clinical diagnosis, a settled suicidal state,3:27or a motive.3:28Passenger Miriam Okean also rendered Ion, experienced shaking, a rapid descent, and3:34blood aboard, and feared the aircraft would crash.3:36Another account describes her reassuring fellow passengers.3:39One count identifies four Israeli passengers entering the cockpit.3:43A promised special award for five Israeli passengers recognizes assistance more3:47broadly.3:48It does not establish that five entered the cockpit or operated the controls.3:52The award's name, presentation date, and complete recipient list remain3:55unestablished.3:56Narendra Modi and Benjamin Netanyahu praised the captain's actions, and Netanyahu4:01also praised the assisting passengers.4:03The aircraft lost thousands of feet rapidly, but its exact descent profile remains4:08unsettled.4:09One account describes 33,000 to 17,000 feet in about a minute.4:13a 16,000 foot difference.4:15Another describes 34,000 to about 16,600 feet in roughly 90 to 100 seconds, about4:2117,400 feet.4:23A shorter interval is described as 14,000 feet in about 30 seconds.4:27These are different endpoints and intervals, not interchangeable measurements.4:31Other estimates include more than 14,000 feet in 29 seconds, specifically4:3614,125 feet in one account, and 14,300 or 15,0754:42feet in 37 seconds.4:43Longer estimates include roughly 17,000 feet in under 2 minutes, 16,000 feet in 24:49minutes, and 4,000 meters in about a minute.4:51Another pairs an initial altitude near 34,000 feet with about 15,600 feet later.4:56Broader descriptions range from about 13,000 to 20,000 feet.5:00One account contains a factor of 10 discrepancy, more than 1,1400 feet in seconds,5:05then around 14,000 feet later.5:07Another describes a drop, a brief climb, and a second descent.5:11A separate estimate puts stabilization at about five minutes.5:14Matching time stamped altitude samples and altitude definitions are unavailable.5:18The figures must not be averaged, added together or turned into a definitive flight5:23profile.5:23The descent alone does not prove an intent to crash.5:26The aircraft transmitted an unlawful interference alert between two general5:29emergency codes, 7700, then 7500, then 7,700 again.5:36The first change is placed about seven minutes after the initial alert.5:39Exact switch times and who selected each code remain unknown.5:42The codes are not a recording of everything said over the radio and they do not5:45establish motive.5:46Israel scrambled fighter aircraft as a precaution.5:49A particular interception, escort, or aircraft type is not established.5:53FC one zero seven three landed safely at Prince Sultan bin Abdul Aziz International5:58Airport in Tabuk, northern Saudi Arabia.6:01It had been flying from Dubai International Airport to Ben-Gurion on September 30th.6:06The more specific aircraft identification is a Boeing 737 MAX 8, Registration A six6:12FKF, manufacturer serial number six one oh one three and construction number eight6:16four two two.6:17That identification has not been independently confirmed through a complete airline6:20aircraft statement.6:22The reported departure was 7.05 a.m.6:24Dubai time, or 0305 UTC.6:27A conflicting account gives 6.05 AM local.6:30Reported landing was 9.45 AM Saudi time, or 0645 UTC.6:36These clocks have not been independently reconciled.6:39The emergency is placed roughly 2 to 2.5 hours into the flight.6:42An approximate 0525 UTC event time is not a departure time and cannot settle the6:47entire chronology.6:48The Israeli destination does not mean the assault happened over Israel.6:52Tracking descriptions place the incident above Saudi Arabia, south-southeast of6:56Tabor Jahal.6:57Other route accounts describe the Saudi-Jordanian transition, entry into Jordanian7:01airspace and a turn back toward Tabuk.7:03A claim placing the stabbing as the aircraft entered Israeli airspace conflicts with7:07that route description and remains unestablished.7:10Without time-stamped positions for individual cockpit actions, their precise7:14locations cannot be assigned.7:15A safe landing does not mean an undamaged aircraft.7:18Photographs and reports describe tail or rudder damage, including an allegation that7:22part of the rudder was missing.7:23The damage classification is substantial, but no supplied technical inspection7:27establishes its extent, timing, or cause.7:30Neither the images nor the classification justify a claim about how close the7:34structure came to failure.7:36The most explicit breakdown is 174 passengers and 8 crew, implying 182 people7:42by arithmetic, not an independently verified manifest.7:45Another total is 180.7:47An earlier approximation is nearly 200.7:50Other counts use 174 as everyone aboard, or describe more than 170, more than 150,7:56160 to 180, and even 127.7:59They cannot all be treated as the same count.8:02No death is reported.8:03Passengers were described as safe and accounted for, but the complete injury8:07inventory remains open.8:08Three passengers reportedly had minor injuries.8:11That can coexist with no serious injuries.8:14It cannot be reconciled with an unqualified claim of no injuries.8:17Both operating pilots were injured.8:19Descriptions of more than 20 or about 30 children, 4 Americans, and at least one8:23U.S.8:24Citizen likewise lack a complete roster to reconcile them.8:28The passengers subsequently reached Israel on a rescue or replacement flight.8:32Their reported Ben-Gurion arrival was around 1840 local or 1540 UTC on September8:3730th, but the exact clock time and flight details are not independently established.8:42Fly Dubai reportedly sent two aircraft to retrieve them.8:45An eight-hour wait is described in one account, not established as every passenger's8:50individual waiting time.8:51The suspension now affects 1,800 travelers stranded in Dubai, not 1,800 people from8:57FC-1073.8:59Repatriation flights were approved to begin Friday, October 2nd.9:02LL, Izrair, and Arkea planned rescue flights, and Israel's Transportation Ministry9:07asked Etihad to increase Abu Dhabi Tel Aviv service.9:10Approval and plans do not confirm particular departures or arrivals.9:14Fly Dubai's suspension has been described as temporary, lasting several days or a9:19week.9:19No verified fixed end date or confirmed resumption is established.9:23The co-pilots reported Omani's citizenship raises an eligibility question, not proof9:28of motive.9:29Israel is examining whether assigning him breached an aviation agreement described9:33as permitting pilots from countries with diplomatic relations with Israel to land9:37there.9:37Oman has no formal diplomatic relations with Israel.9:40The Israeli Civil Aviation Authority was asked to examine compliance, and increased9:44pilot checks were announced.9:46Neither a breach finding nor completed implementation of those checks is9:49established.9:50Omani in some accounts should not create a different nationality.9:53His employment history also remains unsettled, including an account placing his9:57fly-dubai service at less than a year.9:59The weapon remains unidentified forensically.10:01A knife, penknife, and possible acts have been discussed, but none is an established10:05identification.10:06How a weapon came aboard, what cockpit access and door controls allowed, and whether10:10hiring or screening missed a demonstrable warning remain unanswered.10:13Suggestions about repeated checks, door overrides, or a deliberately induced dive10:17are analysis, not findings of a specific security failure.10:21Terrorism, radicalization, sabotage, and an intended crash remain assessments under10:25examination.10:26Claims of Islamist indoctrination and social media discussion of killing Jews lack10:30independently established supporting evidence.10:33Mental illness, a politically motivated attack, and other possibilities remain under10:36investigation.10:38An initial suggestion that the suspect acted alone is not a final conclusion.10:42An early assessment against hijacking has been overtaken by a broader investigation10:46of assault and possible unlawful takeover, not by a final terrorism verdict.10:50The incident is already a political issue before an expected late October Israeli10:54election.10:55Supporters of Netanyahu frame it as vindicating security warnings.10:59Opponents accuse the government of exploiting it and cite earlier security failures.11:03Polling descriptions place his block slightly higher, but still short of a majority11:07in the 120-seat Knesset, without enough numerical detail to isolate an11:12incident-specific change.11:14No demonstrated electoral effect is established, and no specific intelligence11:18warning of an event like this has been identified in his public account.11:21A conditional threat to hit Iran very hard now hangs over an investigation that has11:25not established an Iranian connection.11:27The suggestion of involvement remains unsubstantiated.11:30No supporting details establish a link.11:32A separate preliminary assessment places Iranian involvement and outside connections11:36in the too early to determine category.11:38Preparations to send another 9,000 U.S.11:41Troops to the Middle East add a military backdrop, not evidence about this assault.11:45The answer to the central question is therefore narrower than the retaliation11:48rhetoric.11:49Investigators have preliminarily identified an assault by the co-pilot.11:52Both injured pilots have moved to the UAE.11:55The captain is recovering, and the passengers completed their onward journey.11:58The exact cockpit sequence, final intent and motive remain unresolved.12:02No investigating authority finding established through October to connects Iran to12:05the attack.مقاله را بخوانیدخط زمانی داستانHeyDexویدیوی کوتاه ↗چه کسی چه گزارش کردنکتههایی که بیش از یک رسانه گزارش کرد✓One pilot stabbed the other aboard the flightبهطور مستقل تأیید شده · ۱۳ رسانه✓Emergency landing of Dubai-to-Tel Aviv flight in Saudi Arabiaبهطور مستقل تأیید شده · ۱۳ رسانه✓Aircraft sent emergency distress signals including possible hijacking codeبهطور مستقل تأیید شده · ۱۳ رسانه✓Aircraft rapid descent altitude lossبهطور مستقل تأیید شده · ۱۲ رسانه✓Plane landed safely in Saudi Arabiaبهطور مستقل تأیید شده · ۱۱ رسانه✓Passengers and crew subdued the attackerبهطور مستقل تأیید شده · ۱۱ رسانه✓Attacker tried to crash the plane or sabotage controlsبهطور مستقل تأیید شده · ۷ رسانههر سطر ادعایی است که از گزارش آن رسانه ثبت کردهایم. مقایسه تا ۱۴ مهر ۱۴۰۵ ساعت ۱۹:۰۰ (UTC).
