Vai al contenuto
Ora

Catastrofi · Biscayne Bay crashStoria in evoluzione · servizio 5 di 5

Key Biscayne helicopter crash: NTSB finds no mechanical failure before rotor hit the water

The federal preliminary report found no problem with the engine or flight controls of the Robinson R44 II that went into Biscayne Bay on Nov. 4. It describes a 45-degree bank, very close to the water, beside a racing powerboat.

Scritto 6 min di lettura · 13 fonti

Disponibile in inglese

Cosa è cambiato dal nostro ultimo servizio

14 giorni dopo

Ora

The federal preliminary report found no problem with the engine or flight controls of the Robinson R44 II that went into Biscayne Bay on Nov. 4. It describes a 45-degree bank, very close to the water, beside a racing powerboat.

Cosa è cambiato

  • The NTSB releases its preliminary report, finding no evidence of pre-impact control or engine malfunction.

Forty-five degrees. Witnesses and the two survivors told investigators that this was how far the Robinson R44 II rolled toward a speeding powerboat in its last moments. The helicopter was already low over Biscayne Bay. In a turn that steep, the rotor disc on the low side tilts down toward the water, and there was very little height left to give up. The videographer on board watched the blades hit the surface. Moments later the helicopter was upside down in about 10 feet of water, and its pilot had been killed.⁠2⁠4

The National Transportation Safety Board released its preliminary report on Wednesday, November 18. Its most important finding is what investigators did not find. They examined the wreckage and saw no evidence that the flight controls or the engine had failed before impact. Unless the final report says otherwise, this was a working helicopter flown into the water. The open question is no longer what broke. It is how the flight was being flown.⁠2⁠4

45°Bank toward the boat, per witnesses and passengers 2
~10 ftWater depth where the helicopter overturned 2
6 ftOuter section missing from one main rotor blade 2
1Dead: the pilot, Tomas Pendas 24

What we reported before, and what changed

We first covered this crash on November 4 and reported on it twice on November 5. Our last report named the pilot as Tomas Pendas, 63, and the survivors as Ryan McCoy, 52, and Ryan Ferraro, 27. It also said both men had left the hospital, with injuries then described as minor. That was a much milder picture than the first accounts of two critically injured men being airlifted. Since then, the cause of the crash has become much clearer, but the picture of the injuries has become more confused.⁠9⁠10

The flight

The helicopter went down near Bill Baggs State Park, at the southern tip of Key Biscayne. According to the Miami-Dade Sheriff's Office, it was on a trip to film a powerboating event offshore. CBS Miami's reading of the report describes the event as a high-performance "Poker Run." Some of the helicopter's doors had been removed so the photographer and videographer could work. Local reporting after the crash said Pendas owned an aerial media and photography company based at North Perry Airport in Pembroke Pines.⁠4⁠2⁠9

The photographer gave investigators the clearest account of what happened. The helicopter flew low and parallel to a boat's right side, then turned to get ahead of it for a "good shot" as the boat passed underneath. Witnesses on two nearby boats told investigators the helicopter had been turning "extremely" close to the surface. The Associated Press account, carried by ABC News, presents that wording as part of the safety board's own description of the low-altitude turns. On one of those turns, the main rotor blades struck the bay.⁠4⁠2

The emergency floats deployed, but they did not keep the helicopter upright. Television footage showed it inverted underwater, with two yellow floats still attached beneath the landing skids. People on nearby boats made distress calls. Sheriff Rosie Cordero-Stutz said a good Samaritan tried to help one of the victims. Crews from several local agencies, the U.S. Coast Guard and U.S. Customs and Border Protection responded.⁠4⁠1

From inspection to preliminary report

  1. Aug. 5, 2026

    The helicopter passes a 100-hour inspection, with about 2,500 airframe hours and about 400 engine hours since overhaul.

    2
  2. Wed., Nov. 4

    While filming a Poker Run powerboat event, the rotor strikes the water in a low turn off Key Biscayne. The pilot is killed.

    42
  3. Nov. 5

    The pilot is identified. Both survivors are reported released from the hospital with minor injuries.

    10
  4. Wed., Nov. 18

    The NTSB releases its preliminary report, finding no evidence of pre-impact control or engine malfunction.

    42

What the wreckage showed

The mechanical findings are detailed, and they all point the same way. Investigators confirmed flight-control continuity through the controls, servos, actuators, linkages and pushrods. One of the three main rotor hydraulic servos broke free in the crash, and all three had minor impact damage, but each still worked properly when moved by hand. The blades moved freely on the teetering hinge, and there was no sign of mast bumping. Mast bumping is a known failure mode of two-bladed teetering rotors like the Robinson's, and it would have been an obvious alternative explanation.⁠2

The engine passed the same checks. When investigators turned the crankshaft by hand, it showed continuity through the crankshaft and valvetrain, with normal compression and suction on all six cylinders. All 12 spark plugs showed normal wear. Investigators drained about 3 gallons of saltwater and oil from the engine after it had sat in the bay. Maintenance records show the August 5 inspection.⁠2

The damage is consistent with a high-energy impact on the water. One main rotor blade had lost its outer 6 feet, and the opposite blade was heavily damaged. The main rotor gearbox case had cracked open, exposing the gears. The tail rotor shaft had torn away from the main transmission, although the sealed tail rotor gearbox still turned normally. The fuselage had split and peeled backward, exposing the cockpit and seats. The camera and video equipment on board was thrown out and has not been recovered. That footage could have shown the final seconds from inside the cabin. Aviation-tracking sites give the helicopter's registration as N272JW and the NTSB case number as ERA27FA034.⁠2⁠7⁠12

How badly were the survivors hurt?

The coverage of the report splits on how badly the two men were hurt. ABC News, carrying the Associated Press, says the photographer and videographer were "critically" injured. CBS Miami says the two passengers were "seriously" injured, which matches the Miami Herald. Published summaries of the NTSB case file list two serious injuries. NBC 6 reported on November 5 that the men had suffered minor injuries and were no longer in the hospital.⁠4⁠5⁠2⁠9⁠12⁠10

These accounts do not have to contradict each other. "Serious injury" is a category in federal crash records, and it does not necessarily mean a long hospital stay. "Critical," however, sits badly beside two men who went home within about a day. No source we have seen says the men went back to the hospital. As of the last firm report, both were out, and nothing newer contradicts that.

Cosa sappiamo

  • The rotor struck the water during a low, banking turn. Investigators found no evidence of control or engine failure before impact. 24
  • The NTSB has kept the wreckage for further examination. 2

Cosa non sappiamo

  • The time of the crash, the pilot's flight experience, and the full name and organizer of the Poker Run.
  • Whether the event set any minimum altitude for aircraft, and who decided how close to fly.
  • The true extent of the survivors' injuries.

Prossimi sviluppi

  • The NTSB public docket and any further factual material on case ERA27FA034. A final report with a probable cause typically takes a year or more.

Cronologia

Giorno 16 · 5 servizi

Cronologia della storia
  1. The pilot is identified. Both survivors are reported released from the hospital with minor injuries.

  2. 5 giorni dopo

  3. The NTSB releases its preliminary report, finding no evidence of pre-impact control or engine malfunction.

Fonti10

Tra le fonti citate, BizJet Brief ha pubblicato per prima, 20 ore prima della diffusione di questo servizio. Hanno seguito 5 altre testate.

3 articoli precedenti consultati per approfondire.3 testate senza data:apnews.commiamiherald.comntsb.gov

Storia in evoluzione · servizio 5 di 5

Tutte le fonti, per testata

13 fonti da 10 testate· Prima le più citate

Come trasmesso
  1. A working helicopter dipped its rotor into Biscayne Bay during a low turn, and its pilot died.
  2. Federal investigators found no sign that the engine or flight controls failed. That puts the focus on how the flight was flown, low and banking hard beside a racing powerboat.
  3. Nobody has said yet who decided how close to the water to fly, or how badly the two survivors were really hurt.
  4. On November 5 we reported that the pilot, sixty-three-year-old Tomas Pendas, had died, and that the survivors, Ryan McCoy and Ryan Ferraro, had left the hospital with injuries then described as minor. On Wednesday the National Transportation Safety Board released its preliminary report.
  5. The helicopter went down near Bill Baggs State Park, at the southern tip of Key Biscayne. It was a chartered Robinson R44 II, there to photograph boats in a high-performance Poker Run powerboat event offshore. Pendas owned an aerial media and photography company based at North Perry Airport in Pembroke Pines.
  6. Several of the helicopter's doors had been taken off so the photographer and the videographer could shoot.
  7. The photographer told investigators the helicopter flew low and parallel to a boat's right side, then turned to get ahead of it for a good shot as the boat passed underneath. Witnesses on two nearby boats said it was turning extremely close to the surface.
  8. Then came the bank.
  9. Witnesses and the men aboard put the bank toward the boat at about forty-five degrees. The videographer saw the rotor blades strike the water. The helicopter hit the bay, its emergency floats deployed, and it rolled upside down in about ten feet of water.
  10. Television footage showed it inverted underwater, with two yellow floats still fixed beneath the landing skids. People on nearby boats made distress calls, and Miami-Dade Sheriff Rosie Cordero-Stutz said a good Samaritan tried to help one of the victims. Crews from several local agencies, the Coast Guard and Customs and Border Protection responded.
  11. The wreckage is still in federal hands, and we'll keep following this investigation. Subscribe to this channel, and find more at heyday dot news.
  12. Investigators took the wreckage apart and found the machine still connected end to end.
  13. The flight controls were connected through the servos, linkages and pushrods. All three rotor servos still worked by hand, though one broke loose in the crash. There was no sign of mast bumping, a known failure in two-bladed rotors like this one. The engine showed normal compression on all six cylinders. Probable cause hasn't been determined.
  14. All twelve spark plugs showed normal wear. Investigators drained about three gallons of saltwater and oil from the engine after it sat in the bay.
  15. The damage fits a hard, fast hit on the water. One main rotor blade lost its outer six feet, and the opposite blade was badly damaged. The main gearbox case cracked open, exposing the gears, and the tail rotor shaft tore away from the transmission.
  16. The fuselage split and peeled backward, exposing the cockpit and seats. The camera and video gear aboard was thrown out, and it hasn't been recovered.
  17. The helicopter passed a 100-hour inspection on August 5, when it had about 2,500 hours on the airframe and about 400 hours on the engine since its last overhaul.
  18. The survivors' injuries are now described in different ways.
  19. Some accounts of the report call the two men critically injured. Others say seriously, and published summaries of the federal case file list two serious injuries. Both labels sit awkwardly beside what we reported on November 5, that both men were home from hospital within about a day.
  20. Nothing newer has contradicted their release.
  21. Flying low with the doors off beside fast boats is routine work in event filming. The report doesn't say whether the Poker Run set any minimum altitude for aircraft, or who decided how close to fly.
  22. The safety board is keeping the wreckage for more examination, and a final report naming a probable cause typically takes a year or more.

In onda di recente