Naar inhoud
Nu

Justitie · Susan Smith parole

Susan Smith denied parole again, unanimously, 32 years after drowning her sons

Her former husband asked South Carolina's parole board in person to keep the killer of their two sons in prison, and no member voted to free her. The board gave no reasons, and the state hasn't said when she can apply again.

Geschreven 5 min leestijd · 18 bronnen

Beschikbaar in het Engels

David Smith went to Columbia on Thursday for the second time in two years. He sat in the same room as the prosecutors who convicted his former wife, and in tears he asked South Carolina's parole board to keep her in prison. Thirty-two years after Susan Smith drowned their sons, Michael, who was 3, and Alex, who was 14 months old, the board did what he asked. None of the members who voted chose to release her.⁠2⁠3⁠10

She stays in prison on a life sentence. The board also turned her down unanimously in 2024, the first year she could seek parole. So across two hearings, she has not won a single vote.⁠1⁠6

A hearing held over a video link

Susan Smith did not come to Columbia. The hearing was held virtually, and she joined by video from Leath Correctional Institution, where she is serving her sentence. To be released, she needed the backing of two-thirds of the seven-member board. One member recused herself, and every member who took part voted no.⁠4⁠7⁠8

The board has not given its reasons. Nothing in the available reporting explains its thinking, so any account of why it ruled as it did is a guess. All the public record shows is the vote.⁠6⁠7

Over the video link, Smith and her attorney told the board about her struggles with mental illness and depression. Video of her remarks was published the same day under the headline "I'm not the same person." No full transcript has been made public, so it isn't possible to confirm her exact words or what came before and after that line.⁠5⁠8⁠11

0Votes to release her at the hearing 167
7Board seats; two-thirds needed to release 13
32Years since the 1994 killings 1
4%Reported parole grant rate; scope unclear 4

The father, and the prosecutor's warning

David Smith, the boys' father, came with the prosecutors from the original trial, testified and asked the board to deny parole. The Independent described his appeal as tearful. Video pages from The State and WBAY confirm that he spoke, but no verbatim record of his testimony has been released.⁠2⁠3⁠10⁠12

Before the hearing, Tommy Pope, who prosecuted Smith, told Fox News Digital that he feared her release would put her "in her ex-husband's face every day." He said that in an interview. Nothing in the reporting confirms that he made the same argument to the board, and it should not be read as part of the hearing record.⁠9

in her ex-husband's face every day

Tommy Pope, original trial prosecutor, in a pre-hearing interview 9

The hearing put the two sides of this case on either side of a screen. On one side was a woman talking about her mental illness and saying she has changed. On the other was a father who has now had to relive the deaths of his sons in front of a state board twice in two years. The board's vote does not explain how it weighed the two, but the result was clear.

How she got here

From the lake to the second denial

  1. 1994

    Susan Smith drowns her sons Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months, in a South Carolina lake. She is later sentenced to life in prison.

    13
  2. 2024, weeks before her first hearing

    The prison disciplines her for "communicating with a victim and/or witness" after she spoke with a filmmaker about the killings.

    1715
  3. November 2024

    In her first year of eligibility, the parole board unanimously denies her release.

    13
  4. April 2026

    The State reports that she can reapply the following November.

    13
  5. Thu Nov 19, 2026

    With one member recused, the board again votes unanimously against parole. David Smith testifies in Columbia.

    127

The disciplinary citation from 2024 is documented. Court TV reported the internal conviction, and The State reported that it involved her talking with a filmmaker about the crimes. What isn't known is whether it came up on Thursday. Nothing published about this hearing says it did, and the citation shouldn't be treated as a factor in the vote when the board has given no reasons.⁠15⁠17

The odds were against her from the start. Officials cited a parole grant rate of about 4 percent around the time of the hearing, but the report cuts off before saying which cases that figure covers. It shouldn't be read as the rate for violent offenders. The state prison system does classify Smith's convictions as violent.⁠4⁠14

When she can try again

The state hasn't said. Her two hearings came two years apart, in November 2024 and November 2026, and her chance to reapply this year was reported months ahead. WSOC called Thursday's ruling her second denial in two years. That pattern points to a next attempt around November 2028. But that is an inference from the dates, not a rule any source confirms, and no official next date has been published.⁠8⁠13

The state's own record hasn't been updated either. Smith's entry in the South Carolina Department of Corrections inmate database still lists her projected parole eligibility date as November 19, 2026, the day she was denied. Until the state posts a new date, nobody can say for certain when she will next go before the board.⁠14

Bekend

  • The board unanimously denied Smith parole on November 19, 2026, with one member recused. It also denied her unanimously in 2024. 167
  • David Smith testified in person and asked the board to keep her in prison. 210
  • Smith joined by video from Leath Correctional Institution, and she and her attorney spoke about her mental illness and depression. 58

Onbekend

  • Why the board ruled as it did. It has given no reasons.
  • Smith's full statement, and the context of the line "I'm not the same person."
  • Whether the 2024 disciplinary citation was raised at the hearing.

Wat volgt

  • Whether the state posts a new parole eligibility date, possibly around November 2028.

Bronnen15

Van de hier aangehaalde bronnen publiceerde Fox News als eerste, 10 uur voordat dit bericht werd uitgezonden. 8 andere media volgden.

6 media zonder datum:thestate.comapnews.comCity of Senecacourttv.comsc.govwltx.com

Alle bronnen, per medium

18 bronnen van 15 media· Meest geciteerd eerst

Zoals uitgezonden
  1. Not a single parole board member voted to free Susan Smith, who drowned her two sons.
  2. It's the second time in two years the board has turned her down without one vote in her favor. She stays in prison, serving life, thirty-two years after she killed Michael, who was three, and Alex, who was fourteen months old.
  3. And the state hasn't said when she can ask again.
  4. South Carolina's parole board met Thursday in Columbia, but Smith never entered the room. The hearing was held virtually, and she joined by video call from Leath Correctional Institution, where she's serving her sentence.
  5. Under the board's rules, Smith needed two-thirds of the seven-member board behind her to walk out. One member recused herself, and every member who took part voted no. The board hasn't given its reasons for the decision.
  6. From that prison video link, Smith and her attorney spoke to the board. They talked about her struggles with mental illness and depression as the members weighed whether to let her go.
  7. Video of her remarks was published the same day under the line, I'm not the same person. Her full statement hasn't been made public, so her exact words, and what surrounded that line, aren't clear.
  8. On the other side of that screen sat the boys' father.
  9. David Smith, her former husband, came to Columbia with the prosecutors from her original trial. He testified, and in tears, he asked the board to keep her in prison.
  10. Tommy Pope, who prosecuted her, said before the hearing that he feared her release would put her in her ex-husband's face every day. He said that in an interview. It isn't clear he made the same case to the board.
  11. We'll keep following this case until the state sets Susan Smith's next parole date. Subscribe to this channel so you see it when it does.
  12. She drowned the boys in 1994. In 2024, weeks before her first parole hearing, the prison disciplined her for communicating with a victim or witness, after she talked with a filmmaker about the killings. In November 2024, the board voted unanimously against her. On Thursday, it did again.
  13. Whether that violation came up at Thursday's hearing hasn't been made public.
  14. The odds were long from the start. Officials cited a parole grant rate of about four percent around the hearing, though it isn't clear exactly which cases that figure covers. The state classifies Smith's convictions as violent.
  15. The state's own prison record still lists Thursday, November 19, as Smith's projected parole eligibility date.
  16. Her two hearings came two years apart, and her chance to reapply this November was known in advance. That points to a next try around November 2028. But the state hasn't posted a new date, and until it does, nobody can say when she'll face the board again.

Onlangs uitgezonden