司法 · 图森车祸调查
图森车祸车速估计为100–150英里/小时,记录仪数据能否恢复仍存疑
路面测量显示,在造成三名萨尔波因特学生死亡的车祸中,车速可能为100–150英里/小时;但这项估算仍属初步判断,受火灾损坏的记录仪数据也可能已经丢失。
文字 阅读需 4 分钟 · 20 个来源
原语言视频
译自英文原文。
如果汽车自身的电子记录丢失,调查人员能对致命车祸查明多少情况?在图森地区造成三名高中生死亡的碰撞事故中,路面测量结果如今显示,躲避者挑战者的车速可能在100至150英里/小时之间,误差可达15英里/小时。皮马县警长克里斯·纳诺斯告诉《亚利桑那每日星报》。这项初步估算支持车速极快的说法,但无法确定撞击瞬间的精确速度,而且火灾可能毁掉了有助于缩小估算范围的数据。1
读者投票
你认为手机应用的驾驶记录对车祸调查有多大用处?
在这里,估算与恢复出的测量值之间的区别至关重要。纳诺斯的说法由《亚利桑那每日星报》于11月21日刊出,依据的是事故调查人员对路面进行的人工测量,而非从车辆事件数据记录仪成功下载的数据。150英里/小时也不是经确认的读数,而是警长所述速度范围的上限;这一估算本身也有误差。1
物证描绘出一连串猛烈撞击。纳诺斯说,挑战者车底触地并撞上两个路缘,导致发动机从发动机舱脱落。他告诉《星报》:「整台发动机都被甩出了车外。」他称发动机脱落可能是随后起火的主要原因之一——这是带有保留的调查判断,并非对起火原因的定论。1
两种车速说法,各有局限
路面重建得出的车速范围,与Life360显示的单次行程最高车速134英里/小时大致相同。麦迪的父亲大卫·雷亚提供了《星报》报道中提到的截图。纳诺斯明确表示,这两种说法相互印证。1
我们看到的情况支持Life360的说法。
警长办公室的立场更为审慎,并未把截图当作定论。发言人安杰莉卡·卡里略告诉《星报》,应用程序的信息有助于描绘可能发生的情况,但调查人员不会据此确定究竟发生了什么。他们还会检查轮胎痕迹、车辆损坏情况以及现场各处之间的距离。应用程序只是事故重建的一部分,不能取而代之。1
时间仍需厘清
现有证据无法解释这一差异。警方最初公布的响应时间是约数,而截图显示的是应用程序上的时间;不应悄悄调整其中任何一项,让时间线看起来整齐。应用程序显示的四分钟行程还不是一条完全同步的官方时间线,也不能证明汽车在这四分钟里始终以其报告的最高车速行驶。
最关键的缺失证据或许就在受损的记录仪里。事件数据记录仪会记录与碰撞或突然撞击相关的技术信息。纳诺斯告诉《星报》,设备遭火灾严重损坏后,调查人员已取出芯片并对其进行处理。谈到芯片时,他说「看起来没问题」,但也提醒数据可能已经损坏,「我们可能什么都得不到」。1
芯片看似完好,并不能证明其中的信息仍然可读。现有更新并未说明是否已成功恢复可用数据,也未给出完成日期。如果能取回数据,或许有助于缩小车速估算范围或厘清事件顺序;但即使处理成功,也不能自动保证得出撞击瞬间的精确车速,或解决时间不一致的问题。1
目前,这项新的事故重建让人们对挑战者的车速有了更具体的认识,但还没有完整解释事故经过。如果芯片里什么也恢复不出来,调查人员仍可依据路面、残骸和其他证据开展工作。负责任的结论既不是应用程序证实了每个细节,也不是没有记录仪就一无所知。现有证据支持车速极快;车辆最后的行驶过程仍在调查中。
来源9
按媒体查看所有来源
来自 9 家媒体的 20 个来源· 引用最多的优先
life360.com最先10
- 首次报道于
- Driving Speed & Accuracy – Life360
- Individual Driver Reports – Life360
- Drive Detection & Analysis – Life360
- Crash Detection Troubleshooting – Life360
- In-App Driving Events – Life360
- Introducing: Driving by Life360
- How Accurate Is Life360? | Life360 Location Tracking Accuracy
- Can Life360 Help You Avoid a Speeding Ticket?
- Location & Drive History – Life360
- Movement Icons – Life360
Google News last hour 2tucson.com2
Accident Newsaccidentnews.com1
Breaking Accident News - CrashDaily.comcrashdaily.com1
Cedar Newscedarnews.net1
People.compeople.com1
pimasheriff.org1
播出原貌
- The Challenger hit two curbs so hard its engine tore free.
- Three Tucson high school students died in the crash, and fire severely damaged the car's electronic recorder. Investigators now have a preliminary speed estimate, but recovering the car's own data could prove impossible.
- Can the surviving chip help investigators work out the car's final movements?
- The 2014 Dodge Challenger crashed late on November 14, 2026, near East Skyline and North Foothills drives. Pima County investigators have been measuring the roadway to reconstruct what happened before the vehicle caught fire.
- Sheriff Chris Nanos says those measurements suggest the Challenger was traveling between 100 and 150 miles an hour. He puts the uncertainty at up to 15 miles an hour. Investigators calculated that range from the crash scene.
- The upper end of that estimate is 150 miles an hour. Nanos hasn't given a precise impact speed. His investigators are working from physical evidence while they try to recover electronic information from the badly damaged car.
- Driver Alex Schneider was 18. His passengers were Joel Slavin, 16, and Madison, known as Maddy, Rea, 17. All three attended Salpointe Catholic High School. Their deaths on November 14 are the reason for this continuing crash investigation.
- Nanos says the Challenger bottomed out and struck two curbs, dislodging the entire engine from its compartment. He thinks that engine separation was probably one of the biggest causes of the fire. Investigators are still working through how the fire began.
- The roadway estimate of 100 to 150 miles an hour overlaps with a Life360 trip maximum of 134 miles an hour. Maddy's father, David Rea, supplied the screenshot. Nanos says the physical reconstruction supports what the app is showing.
- Life360 records a maximum for a drive. Investigators still have to work out how fast the Challenger was moving when it struck the curbs. Agreement between the app and roadway measurements helps them build the reconstruction without settling that final speed.
- Subscribe to this channel to follow the recorder recovery and the continuing crash investigation.
- The sheriff's department initially placed the deputies' response at about 11:05 p.m. But the screenshot displays departure from the Rea home at 11:06 p.m., and the trip ending near the crash four minutes later, at 11:10 p.m.
- Those times don't line up, and nobody has explained the difference. The screenshot provides the family's view of the trip, while investigators still need to reconcile its clock with the initial response time.
- Life360 uses phone location and activity to detect driving. GPS and phone sensors help it analyze the journey. Families can share their locations in groups and receive safety alerts, with driving information available through the service.
- Life360 warns that device quality and service quality affect speed accuracy. Some trip points can be missed, and captured speeds can be inaccurate. Its separate speeding alert requires more than 80 miles an hour for at least 30 seconds. That rule doesn't tell us how long this trip's maximum lasted.
- The sheriff's department treats app information as one piece of the investigation. Spokesperson Angelica Carrillo says it can help investigators piece together what possibly happened, but they don't use it to determine exactly what happened.
- Life360 also uses phone sensors to detect significant impacts when a vehicle is moving at least 25 miles an hour. That threshold describes when crash detection works. Investigators combine app information with tire marks, vehicle damage and distances across the scene to reconstruct a collision.
- Fire severely damaged the Challenger's event data recorder, which captures technical information around a crash. Nanos says investigators removed its chip and are processing it. He says the chip looks okay, but warns that its data may have been destroyed.
- Investigators haven't announced a completion date for that work. Usable recorder data could help narrow the speed estimate or clarify the sequence. If the chip yields nothing, they'll have to keep reconstructing the final movements from the roadway, wreckage and other evidence.
译文更新于
讨论
此处的帖子属于“The fatal Tucson Dodge Challenger crash”,会显示在该新闻事件的每篇报道下。





