政治 · 緑の党内の分裂緑の党の下院議員5人中4人がシオニズム動議に反対。今度はポランスキーが文面を否定執筆 2026年10月9日 11:58 UTC視聴文字起こし0:09On October 6th, we reported the Greens' Zionism vote.0:12Now Polanski rejects its unamended wording.0:15Four of five Green MPs opposed it, and senior members have left.0:19Will the party change the policy?0:20Zach Polanski now says he wouldn't have voted for the motion as passed.0:24On the morning of October 9th, he called it imperfect and said he would have0:28supported an amended version.0:29His explanation follows days of unanswered questions.0:32His reservations leave the adopted policy in place.0:35They also come after a by-election defeat and criticism from former Green leader0:39Caroline Lucas.0:40The dispute now reaches beyond his personal position to how the party will treat0:43members who identify as Zionist.0:45Conference members adopted a policy defining Zionism as a form of racism, proposed0:51by Lubna Spatin.0:52It describes the ideology through support for an ethno-nationalist Jewish state.0:57It backs a single democratic Palestinian state throughout historic Palestine,1:02including modern-day Israel.1:03The motion passed by 1,022 votes to 813 on October 4th.1:08Its previously published wording envisaged equal rights for everyone, Jerusalem as1:13the capital and a Palestinian right of return.1:15Supporters distinguish opposition to a political ideology from hostility toward1:19Jewish people.1:20Critics question what that distinction means for Jewish members who consider1:24themselves Zionist.1:25Polanski left Brighton before the final vote to campaign in Holborn and St.1:29Pancras.1:30He backed an amendment that was rejected, then took no part in the vote that adopted1:34the policy.1:35His morning remarks explain how he would have voted.1:37Four of the party's five MPs opposed the motion.1:40Members also rejected an amendment intended to protect Jewish people who identify as1:44Zionist from repercussions.1:46That proposed protection covered pressure or discipline connected to Zionist1:50identifying synagogues and Jewish organizations.1:52On Election Day, October 8th, Polanski repeatedly declined questions about whether1:57Zionism is racism and why he hadn't voted.1:59He said he was talking to residents and would speak later.2:02His eventual clarification changes that unanswered position, although the full2:06wording of the amendments he wanted still isn't clear.2:09Caroline Lucas said Polanski had failed to show leadership.2:12She criticized his handling of the dispute and his absence from the debate.2:16Asked about him continuing as leader.2:18She declined to endorse him, but also declined to say whether he should stand down.2:22Andy Burnham urged Green leaders to reverse the motion and ensure it didn't remain2:26party policy.2:27Speaking in Berlin on October 8th, he argued that its single-state position ruled2:31out a two-state solution.2:33The prime minister also called for reversal.2:35Polanski insisted he could remain leader after losing the by-election.2:39Asked whether he could continue, he said, of course I can carry on.2:43In those post-result remarks, he hadn't yet explicitly rejected the motion.2:47That clarification came later in the morning.2:49He also spoke of an ongoing genocide and the displacement of the Palestinian people.2:54Israel denies that its actions in Gaza amount to genocide.2:57South Africa's case against Israel is before the International Court of Justice,3:01where the accusation awaits a final judicial determination.3:04Labors, Sagal, Abdi Wali won Holborn and St.3:08Pancras with 12,292 votes.3:12Polanski received 8,928, giving Labor a majority of3:163,364.3:19Voting took place on October 8th, and the results were published on October 9th.3:24The Greens finished second.3:25Turnout was 38.76%.3:28The Greens' showing was reportedly their second best ever in a Westminster3:32by-election.3:33That strong placing supports Polanski's defense of his leadership, but voters3:37elected Labor's candidate.3:39Nobody has measured how much this motion helped or hurt him.3:42The Conservatives finished third with 1,922 votes, ahead of Reform UK.3:47Reform received 1,612 votes and Restore Britain 692, putting Reform ahead of3:53Restore in the published totals.3:55Phil Davies resigned as Welsh Green deputy leader and canceled his membership on3:59October 6th.4:00He'd belonged to the party for seven years and became deputy in 2024.4:04Kieran Dams, the 23-year-old Waterloo Ward Councillor in Sefton, also left to sit as4:10an independent.4:10The departures already included former councillor Andre Fries and Sandy Ruthven,4:15chair of Amnesty International UK.4:17Further councillors have left, but there's no complete count of members leaving over4:21the motion.4:21Jewish Greens chair Vivian Lichtenstein has belonged to the party for 29 years.4:26She said it was quite possible she would leave and that the motion crosses a line.4:30She also wanted scrutiny of recently joined members.4:32Her departure hasn't been confirmed.4:34Jewish members hold different views.4:36Some supported the motion, while others fear for their place in the party.4:40Polanski has said nobody should be made unwelcome because of their faith or where4:44they worship.4:44Members still need to know what safeguards would apply if the policy became a basis4:48for discipline.4:49Greens for Palestine says Palestinians and anti-Zionist Jews drafted the motion with4:54more than 40 Palestinian liberation organizations endorsing it.4:57Membership reportedly grew more than threefold in a year.5:00A separate figure of 230,000 members lacks an official date or confirmation.5:05Those figures can't give a reliable starting membership.5:08Internal critics say the influx included hard-left campaigners focused on the Middle5:13East.5:13Some allege organized infiltration.5:15Party growth alone doesn't show who newcomers are, how they voted, or whether they5:19coordinated their arrival.5:21Labor and Liberal Democrat MPs asked the Equality and Human Rights Commission to5:25consider whether the policy broke the law.5:27An investigation hasn't been announced.5:29The practical concern is whether members could face exclusion, pressure, or5:33discipline, and what protections the party would provide.5:36Israel's foreign minister Gideon Sa'ar announced Polanski's entry bar on October5:404th.5:41The decision was described as coordinated with the relevant authorities.5:45That announcement was part of the earlier dispute.5:47The bar's duration and appeal process still aren't clear.5:50It's also unclear whether the final policy retained calls to lift the Palestine5:55action ban and release people detained for non-violent direct action.5:58Polanski separately opposes that ban.6:00His position doesn't settle which clauses conference adopted.6:03The Greens haven't announced a date for another policy decision.6:06Polanski has clarified that he would have opposed the motion as written, and the6:10by-election has ended in defeat.6:12His personal reservations leave the conference policy in place, while its6:16application to Jewish and Zionist identifying members remains unresolved.記事を読むストーリーの時系列HeyDexショート動画 ↗誰が何を報じたか複数のメディアが報じた論点Alleged electoral effects of voter-list revisions8媒体Calls for the election chief to resign8媒体Protests over voter-list revisions7媒体✓Green Party conference vote on Zionism motion独立して確認 · 6媒体Names removed from voter lists6媒体Abdiwali elected for Holborn and St Pancras5媒体Protester detentions in New Delhi on Saturday5媒体Internet and mobile service shutdowns5媒体Cockroach movement leaders detained at Delhi airport4媒体✓Green Party MPs' positions on the motion独立して確認 · 4媒体✓Israel's entry ban on Polanski独立して確認 · 3媒体Rahul Gandhi detained on Wednesday3媒体Police preventing protesters from reaching the site3媒体✓Motion's proposed Palestinian state独立して確認 · 3媒体Lichtenstein's call for Polanski to resign3媒体Allegation about approval for voter-list deletions3媒体Polanski's position on an amended motion3媒体1社だけが報じた論点1The Hinduのみが報道FIRs filed over Wednesday's protest10月8日 0:23 UTC各行は、そのメディアの報道から私たちが記録した主張です。2026年10月15日 2:56 UTC時点で比較。関連報道その後の展開·10月15日 3:52 UTCインドの選挙権を訴える抗議指導者に拘禁5日間、裁判所の審査は待機
