跳到内容
现在

灾害 · 杜拉杜河倾覆事故

林斯杜拉杜河两船倾覆后,渔民被发现死亡

两艘小船在风暴中倾覆后,五人安全脱险。渔民遗体被发现,搜寻随之结束,但事故原因以及早先报道中的乘客人数差异仍未得到解释。

文字 阅读需 3 分钟 · 17 个来源

原语言视频

译自英文原文。

据最新报道,11月8日星期日上午,在巴西圣保罗州林斯市的杜拉杜河上,两艘小船倾覆后,一名据称约50岁的渔民被发现死亡。另有五人安全脱险。遗体打捞上岸,结束了持续一夜的搜寻,但两船为何同时倾覆仍未查明。⁠1⁠3

11月7日星期六晚间,一场风暴期间,两艘船在加尔萨斯旅馆附近倾覆。此处引用的报道没有提供这名渔民的姓名。RP10和PortalR3称他约50岁;G1报道他50岁。⁠1⁠2⁠3

1确认死亡的渔民 14
5最新报道中安全脱险的人数 13
2倾覆的小船 1

根据PortalR3最初的报道,消防员于晚上约7:22接到呼叫。这是报道中记录的紧急呼叫时间,并非已经精确确定的船只倾覆时间。区分两者很重要:这个时间标记了救援响应的开始,却没有给出事故或搜寻确切的起始时间。⁠11

当晚,救援人员乘坐机动船、配合专业潜水员开始在河上搜寻。G1报道,搜寻行动在星期日凌晨暂停,并于当天早上恢复,随后搜寻人员找到了遗体。报道没有给出遗体被发现的确切时间,因此无法据此确定搜寻持续了多久。⁠1

CNN Brasil也援引民防部门的说法,报道了星期日上午发现遗体一事。这一确认取代了早些时候将渔民描述为失踪的报道。到那时,其他乘客已确认安全;尚未解决的紧急情况,是搜寻这名沉入水中的男子。⁠1⁠4

乘客人数为何发生变化

最新报道显示,两艘船上共有六人:五名幸存者和一名遇难者。这比最初报道的人数多一人。PortalR3早先报道说船上有五人,其中四人安全、还有一人失踪;该媒体后续报道则称共有六人,五人幸存。⁠11⁠3

G1更新后的报道同样记载,五人安全离水,一人死亡。因此,较新的报道已取代了最初的五人总数,但人数变化的原因尚未得到解释。更新后的伤亡数字是目前最有依据的报道,但并未消除最初数字之间的矛盾。⁠1⁠11⁠3

PortalR3后续报道说,五名幸存者游到岸边,并接受了消防员的协助。这比笼统地说他们获救更具体:报道描述的是他们自行上岸,随后得到帮助。不应将其改述为消防员把五人全部从河里救了出来。⁠3

怀疑与天气有关,原因尚未定论

G1报道,消防员和民防部门怀疑恶劣天气导致了事故。CNN Brasil也援引民防部门的说法,将恶劣天气导致船只倾覆作为事故解释。这些说法表明,风暴是当局最初判断中的关键因素,但并不等于已经完成技术调查并还原事故经过。⁠1⁠4

现有报道没有提供船只所在位置的风力或降雨测量数据,没有记录浪况或水流情况,也没有关于船只状况或载荷的最终技术结论。报道确认船只是在恶劣天气期间倾覆,但具体的物理过程仍未得到证实。⁠1⁠2⁠4

证据上的这一缺口并不能作为归咎于任何一方的依据。引用的报道均未证实船只超载、乘客或操作人员存在过失,也未说明是否有人穿着救生衣。仅凭发生人员死亡,无法回答这些问题;关于天气的解释应继续注明来源,而不应被当作定论。

搜寻已经明确结束,但事故原因仍未明。接下来仍需查明两艘船如何倾覆,并解释报道中的乘客总人数为何发生变化。无论这些疑问是否解开,已经确认的人员伤亡不会因此改变:一名渔民没能在河上度过那一夜。

来源15

在此处引用的来源中,Folha de S.Paulo最先发布,比本报道播出早25小时。 随后还有8家媒体发布。

1篇早期文章作为背景资料参阅。5家媒体未注明日期:cnnbrasil.com.brBOM DIA SOROCABAjornaldebate.com.brradioproarte.com.brrp10.com.br

按媒体查看所有来源

来自 15 家媒体的 17 个来源· 引用最多的优先

播出原貌
  1. Two boats overturned on the Rio Dourado, leaving a fisherman dead.
  2. Five other people escaped safely. Firefighters found the missing man's body the following morning, ending an overnight search. What caused both boats to overturn is still unclear.
  3. The boats overturned near Pousada das Garças in Lins, in Brazil's São Paulo state. Both were small vessels. The accident happened during a storm on Saturday evening, November seventh.
  4. The fisherman was about fifty years old. He disappeared beneath the water after the boats overturned, and his body was recovered Sunday morning. The other passengers were safely out of the river.
  5. Firefighters were called around seven twenty-two that evening. That marks the emergency call. The boats' exact capsize time hasn't been pinned down.
  6. Firefighters sent motorboats and specialist divers into the nighttime search. Their teams searched the river for the missing man while the other passengers had already reached safety. Civil Defense also took part in the response.
  7. Crews suspended the search in the early hours of Sunday. They returned to the river that morning and located the body. The discovery changed the outcome from a search for a missing passenger to a confirmed death.
  8. The passenger total also changed as more details emerged. Five survivors reportedly swam to the bank and received firefighters' help. Earlier figures had counted one fewer person across the two boats.
  9. Early figures put five people aboard, with four safe and one missing. Later figures put six aboard, with five safe and one dead. Nobody has explained the extra person in the revised count.
  10. The storm also damaged communities elsewhere in the region. In Ourinhos, a road crater about five metres deep prompted the municipal guard to close the street to vehicles and pedestrians. Municipal crews were called to assess the damage and begin repairs.
  11. Bauru's winds brought down trees, damaged the Military History Museum and cut power to neighbourhoods. A house lost its roof, displacing four people. Municipal assistance workers arranged a hotel for the family.
  12. In São Manuel, winds stripped a home's roof and brought down branches and trees. A fallen tree blocked the Marechal Rondon highway before the road operator removed it and reopened traffic.
  13. Marília recorded roof damage and fallen trees in at least six neighbourhoods. In Taciba, eight rural homes suffered partial roof damage. The storm also brought down an urban wall and damaged the roof of the José Cardoso de Pádua exhibition grounds.
  14. In Botucatu, Civil Defense removed fallen trunks and preventively cut down a large tree threatening a house. Crews in Marília cleared streets and inspected damaged homes.
  15. Firefighters and Civil Defense suspect severe weather caused the river accident. The damage elsewhere shows the storm's wider reach, but doesn't settle exactly how the two boats overturned. The physical cause remains unconfirmed. The search ended Sunday morning with the fisherman's body recovered and five survivors safe.

译文更新于

近期播出