灾害 · 第比利斯楼房坍塌
第比利斯楼房坍塌:5人死亡、2人仍失踪,伤亡总数始终对不上
周四,疑似天然气爆炸导致波尼恰拉一栋五层公寓楼坍塌。救援人员救出一名3岁儿童,当时她仍有生命迹象。官方伤亡数字一整天都在变化,但没有官员解释数字为何对不上。
文字 阅读需 5 分钟 · 16 个来源
原语言视频
译自英文原文。
爆炸的确切时间尚未公布。Civil Georgia一篇标注为当地时间约12:36发布的报道已经提到救援行动,因此爆炸发生在那之前。当时,救援人员称正在搜寻7人。4
11月19日死亡人数的变化
数字无法吻合
数字发生变化本身并不意味着有任何可疑之处。楼房坍塌后的早期伤亡数字几乎总是根据当时可能在家的人员估算出来的,随着亲属前来确认、遗体被找到,数字也会得到修正。有关部门有义务向公众解释每一次数字变化,而截至周四晚间,这样的解释尚未出现。
一名儿童从废墟中获救
不止一栋倒塌的楼
这90户人家才是这场灾难不易察觉的规模。大多数住户似乎没有受到身体伤害。他们能否再回自己的公寓过夜,取决于工程师的评估结果。一栋五层楼体被炸塌一部分的建筑,不该有人急着返回。
刑事案件,以及责任归属问题
这正是格鲁吉亚公民社会所关注的空白。人权倡导者诺娜·库尔多瓦尼泽表示,查明波尼恰拉爆炸的原因和责任人十分重要。15
这起严重事件再次提醒我们,该国未能满足基本安全条件。
她的观点涉及的范围不止一栋楼,而周四夜间掌握的证据尚不能证实或反驳这一观点。但它指出了调查将受到何种问题检验。住宅天然气爆炸并非天灾。有人安装管道,有人负责检查,也有人理应在燃气泄漏充满楼梯间之前发现问题。刑法条款已经被援引。眼下重要的是,案件是否会追查到负责这栋楼燃气安全的人和机构,还是只会止步于离火花最近的人。
已知
未知
- 死者和失踪者总数为何从6人变成7人,以及目前的数字是否已是最终结果。
- 已确认的事故原因、供气方,以及爆炸发生前这栋楼的楼龄和状况。
- 住院人员目前的状况。
后续
- 废墟下仍有2人,他们是否能被找到并幸存。
- 结构勘查结果将如何影响波尼恰拉的居民家庭。
- 调查将认定谁对这栋楼的燃气安全负有责任。
周四夜间,波尼恰拉的救援人员仍在挖掘,寻找2人。死亡人数为5人,仍可能上升。
来源9
按媒体查看所有来源
来自 9 家媒体的 16 个来源· 引用最多的优先
Interpressnewsinterpressnews.ge最先5
- 首次报道于
- Teimuraz Mgebrishvili: At this time, the bodies of 1 child and 2 women have been recovered from the rubble - one of them is presumably the parent of 3-year-old Taia | IPN
- ფონიჭალაში მომხდარი აფეთქების ფაქტზე გამოძიება დაიწყო | IPN
- Kakha Kaladze: In the building where the explosion occurred, the municipal laboratory is conducting a structural stability assessment - we have mobilized hotels, and if necessary, we will accommodate all 90 families | IPN
- Nona Kurdovanidze: It is important to establish what caused the explosion in Ponichala and whose responsibility it is - this gravest incident reminds us once again that basic safety conditions are not met in the country | IPN
- Sulkhan Tamazashvili and Kakha Kaladze arrived at the explosion site in Ponichala | IPN
Civil Georgiacivil.ge1
Georgia Todaygeorgiatoday.ge1
İnter Pressinterpress.az1
South China Morning Postscmp.com1
播出原貌
- An apartment block collapsed in Tbilisi, killing five, and two people are still buried.
- A suspected gas explosion brought down the five-storey building in the city's Ponichala district on Thursday. Ninety families lived there, and the city says it's ready to put every one of them in hotels if it has to.
- Nobody can say yet whether the two missing will be found alive, or why the official count keeps shifting.
- The blast hit a residential block in Ponichala, a district of the Georgian capital. Nobody has said exactly when it went off, but rescuers were already working the site by about half past twelve local time.
- In the middle of the search, rescuers pulled a three-year-old girl named Taia alive from the wreckage and took her to hospital. Emergency chief Teimuraz Mgebrishvili said one of the women found dead was presumably her parent.
- Four other people were hospitalized, and one of them is in serious condition.
- The toll climbed all day. Early on, rescuers said they were searching for seven people. Mgebrishvili later reported three dead, two women and a child, with three missing. Then came four dead and two missing. By 20:25 local time, rescuers had recovered two more bodies, and the count stood at five dead, two missing.
- Those figures don't line up. Three dead and three missing makes six. Five dead and two missing makes seven, the number rescuers first said they were looking for. No official has explained the gap, so every figure stays provisional until the search ends.
- Two people are still under that rubble, and we'll keep following the search. Subscribe to this channel, and find more at heyday dot news.
- Officials suspect natural gas, but nobody has confirmed what caused the blast.
- The damage reaches past the building that fell. Mayor Kakha Kaladze said a municipal laboratory is checking the stability of the blast building and other apartment blocks in Ponichala. He said hotels are ready, and if needed, all 90 families from the building will get rooms.
- Most of those households escaped unhurt. Depending on what the engineers find, they could still lose their homes for a while.
- Authorities have opened a criminal investigation under Article 240 prime of Georgia's Criminal Code. Prosecutor Levan Vepkhvadze has been named as announcing the case. No gas company has spoken, and nothing's been said about the building's age or condition before the blast.
- That has drawn a sharp response from Georgia's civil society.
- Rights advocate Nona Kurdovanidze said it's important to find out what caused the explosion and who's responsible. She said this gravest incident reminds us once again that basic safety conditions are not met in the country.
- In Ponichala tonight, rescuers are still digging for two people, and the toll stands at five dead, a number that could still rise.
译文更新于





