跳到内容
现在

灾害 · 比斯坎湾坠机事故持续报道 · 第 5 篇,共 5 篇

比斯坎岛直升机坠机事故:NTSB 认定旋翼撞水前没有机械故障

联邦初步报告称,11月4日坠入比斯坎湾的罗宾逊 R44 II 直升机,其发动机或飞行操纵系统均无问题。报告描述称,直升机在一艘竞速动力艇旁飞行,贴近水面,以45度倾斜转弯。

文字 阅读需 5 分钟 · 13 个来源

原语言视频

译自英文原文。

自上次报道以来的变化

14 天后

现在

联邦初步报告称,11月4日坠入比斯坎湾的罗宾逊 R44 II 直升机,其发动机或飞行操纵系统均无问题。报告描述称,直升机在一艘竞速动力艇旁飞行,贴近水面,以45度倾斜转弯。

新的进展

  • NTSB 发布初步报告,称没有证据表明撞击前操纵系统或发动机发生故障。

45度。目击者和两名幸存者告诉调查人员,罗宾逊 R44 II 直升机在最后时刻向一艘高速行驶的动力艇倾斜了这么多。直升机当时已经飞得很低,掠过比斯坎湾。在如此陡的转弯中,较低一侧的旋翼盘会向下倾向水面,而直升机已几乎没有高度可供下降。机上的摄像师看着桨叶撞上水面。片刻之后,直升机在约 10 英尺深的水中倒扣,飞行员丧生。⁠2⁠4

美国国家运输安全委员会(NTSB)于周三,即11月18日,发布了初步报告。报告最重要的发现,是调查人员没有发现什么。他们检查了残骸,没有发现飞行操纵系统或发动机在撞击前发生故障的迹象。除非最终报告另有结论,否则这是一架性能正常的直升机,被驾驶着飞入水中。悬而未决的问题已不再是哪里出了故障,而是飞行员当时是如何操纵这架直升机的。⁠2⁠4

45°据目击者和乘客称,向船只方向倾斜 2
~10 英尺直升机倾覆处的水深 2
6 英尺一片主旋翼桨叶缺失的外端部分 2
1遇难者:飞行员托马斯·彭达斯 24

我们此前的报道,以及后来有哪些变化

我们于11月4日首次报道这起坠机事故,并于11月5日两次跟进报道。我们最后一篇报道指出,飞行员是63岁的托马斯·彭达斯,幸存者是52岁的瑞安·麦科伊和27岁的瑞安·费拉罗。报道还称,两人均已出院,当时他们的伤势被描述为轻伤。这与最初关于两名伤者伤势危重、由直升机转运的说法相比,情况要轻得多。此后,事故原因已变得清晰得多,但有关伤势的说法却更加混乱。⁠9⁠10

飞行经过

直升机在比尔·巴格斯州立公园附近坠落,该公园位于比斯坎岛南端。据迈阿密-戴德县警长办公室称,直升机当时正前往海上拍摄一场动力艇活动。CBS Miami 对报告的解读称,这项活动是高性能船艇「Poker Run」。直升机的部分舱门已被拆除,以便摄影师和摄像师开展工作。事故发生后,当地媒体报道称,彭达斯拥有一家航空媒体和摄影公司,基地位于彭布罗克派恩斯的北佩里机场。⁠4⁠2⁠9

摄影师向调查人员提供了最清晰的事发经过。直升机低空平行飞在一艘船的右侧,随后转向以赶到船的前方,在船从下方经过时拍摄一张「好照片」。两艘附近船只上的目击者告诉调查人员,直升机转弯时离水面「极其」近。美联社的报道由 ABC 新闻刊载,其中将这一说法作为安全委员会对低空转弯的描述。就在其中一次转弯时,主旋翼桨叶撞上了海湾水面。⁠4⁠2

紧急浮筒已经展开,但没能让直升机保持正立。电视画面显示,直升机倒扣在水下,起落橇下方仍连着两个黄色浮筒。附近船只上的人员发出了求救呼叫。警长罗茜·科尔德罗-斯图茨称,一名热心路人曾试图帮助其中一名伤者。多个当地机构、美国海岸警卫队以及美国海关与边境保护局的人员赶赴现场。⁠4⁠1

从检查到初步报告

  1. 2026年8月5日

    直升机通过100小时检查;机体累计约2,500小时,发动机自大修以来累计约400小时。

    2
  2. 11月4日,周三

    在拍摄 Poker Run 动力艇活动时,直升机在比斯坎岛外海低空转弯,旋翼撞上水面。飞行员丧生。

    42
  3. 11月5日

    飞行员身份得到确认。报道指两名幸存者均已出院,伤势轻微。

    10
  4. 11月18日,周三

    NTSB 发布初步报告,称没有证据表明撞击前操纵系统或发动机发生故障。

    42

残骸所显示的情况

机械检查结果十分详尽,而且都指向同一结论。调查人员确认,飞行操纵系统从操纵装置、伺服机构、作动器、连杆到推杆均保持连续连接。三个主旋翼液压伺服机构中的一个在撞击中脱落,三个伺服机构都受到轻微撞击损坏,但用手移动时仍都能正常工作。桨叶在跷跷板式铰链上可以自由移动,没有桅杆碰撞的迹象。桅杆碰撞是罗宾逊直升机这类双桨叶跷跷板式旋翼的一种已知故障模式,也本可以是一个明显的替代解释。⁠2

发动机也通过了同样的检查。调查人员用手转动曲轴时,发现曲轴和气门机构保持连续运转,六个气缸的压缩和吸力均正常。12个火花塞的磨损情况都正常。直升机在海湾中停留一段时间后,调查人员从发动机中排出了约3加仑的盐水和机油。维护记录显示,该机于8月5日接受了检查。⁠2

损坏情况符合高速撞击水面的特征。一片主旋翼桨叶外端缺失了6英尺,另一片桨叶则严重受损。主旋翼减速箱壳体裂开,齿轮暴露在外。尾旋翼轴从主传动装置上撕脱,但密封的尾旋翼减速箱仍能正常转动。机身裂开并向后剥离,驾驶舱和座椅暴露出来。机上的摄影机和视频设备被抛出,至今仍未找到。这段影像或许能显示机舱内最后几秒发生的情况。航空追踪网站显示,这架直升机的注册号为 N272JW,NTSB 案件编号为 ERA27FA034。⁠2⁠7⁠12

幸存者伤得有多重?

关于两名男子伤势的报道说法不一。美联社供稿、由 ABC 新闻刊载的报道称,摄影师和摄像师伤势「危重」。CBS Miami 称两名乘客伤势「严重」,这与《迈阿密先驱报》的说法一致。NTSB 案件档案的已发布摘要将两人列为重伤。NBC 6 于11月5日报道称,两人受的是轻伤,且已出院。⁠4⁠5⁠2⁠9⁠12⁠10

这些说法并不一定相互矛盾。「重伤」是联邦事故记录中的一个分类,并不一定意味着要长期住院。然而,「危重」这一说法,与两人约一天内就回家这一情况并不相符。我们看到的来源中,没有任何一家称两人后来又回了医院。截至最近一份明确的报道,两人都已出院,也没有更新的消息与此相矛盾。

已知

  • 直升机在低空倾斜转弯时,旋翼撞上了水面。调查人员没有发现撞击前操纵系统或发动机发生故障的证据。 24
  • NTSB 已保留残骸,以便进一步检查。 2

未知

  • 事故发生时间、飞行员的飞行经验,以及 Poker Run 活动的全名和组织方。
  • 活动是否为航空器设定了最低飞行高度,以及由谁决定飞行时要靠多近。
  • 幸存者伤势的真实程度。

后续

  • NTSB 公开案卷以及 ERA27FA034 案件的任何进一步事实材料。最终报告通常需要一年或更长时间才会公布,并会说明可能原因。

时间线

第 16 天 · 5 篇报道

事件时间线
  1. 飞行员身份得到确认。报道指两名幸存者均已出院,伤势轻微。

  2. 5天后

  3. NTSB 发布初步报告,称没有证据表明撞击前操纵系统或发动机发生故障。

来源10

在此处引用的来源中,BizJet Brief最先发布,比本报道播出早20小时。 随后还有5家媒体发布。

3篇早期文章作为背景资料参阅。3家媒体未注明日期:apnews.commiamiherald.comntsb.gov

持续报道 · 第 5 篇,共 5 篇

按媒体查看所有来源

来自 10 家媒体的 13 个来源· 引用最多的优先

播出原貌
  1. A working helicopter dipped its rotor into Biscayne Bay during a low turn, and its pilot died.
  2. Federal investigators found no sign that the engine or flight controls failed. That puts the focus on how the flight was flown, low and banking hard beside a racing powerboat.
  3. Nobody has said yet who decided how close to the water to fly, or how badly the two survivors were really hurt.
  4. On November 5 we reported that the pilot, sixty-three-year-old Tomas Pendas, had died, and that the survivors, Ryan McCoy and Ryan Ferraro, had left the hospital with injuries then described as minor. On Wednesday the National Transportation Safety Board released its preliminary report.
  5. The helicopter went down near Bill Baggs State Park, at the southern tip of Key Biscayne. It was a chartered Robinson R44 II, there to photograph boats in a high-performance Poker Run powerboat event offshore. Pendas owned an aerial media and photography company based at North Perry Airport in Pembroke Pines.
  6. Several of the helicopter's doors had been taken off so the photographer and the videographer could shoot.
  7. The photographer told investigators the helicopter flew low and parallel to a boat's right side, then turned to get ahead of it for a good shot as the boat passed underneath. Witnesses on two nearby boats said it was turning extremely close to the surface.
  8. Then came the bank.
  9. Witnesses and the men aboard put the bank toward the boat at about forty-five degrees. The videographer saw the rotor blades strike the water. The helicopter hit the bay, its emergency floats deployed, and it rolled upside down in about ten feet of water.
  10. Television footage showed it inverted underwater, with two yellow floats still fixed beneath the landing skids. People on nearby boats made distress calls, and Miami-Dade Sheriff Rosie Cordero-Stutz said a good Samaritan tried to help one of the victims. Crews from several local agencies, the Coast Guard and Customs and Border Protection responded.
  11. The wreckage is still in federal hands, and we'll keep following this investigation. Subscribe to this channel, and find more at heyday dot news.
  12. Investigators took the wreckage apart and found the machine still connected end to end.
  13. The flight controls were connected through the servos, linkages and pushrods. All three rotor servos still worked by hand, though one broke loose in the crash. There was no sign of mast bumping, a known failure in two-bladed rotors like this one. The engine showed normal compression on all six cylinders. Probable cause hasn't been determined.
  14. All twelve spark plugs showed normal wear. Investigators drained about three gallons of saltwater and oil from the engine after it sat in the bay.
  15. The damage fits a hard, fast hit on the water. One main rotor blade lost its outer six feet, and the opposite blade was badly damaged. The main gearbox case cracked open, exposing the gears, and the tail rotor shaft tore away from the transmission.
  16. The fuselage split and peeled backward, exposing the cockpit and seats. The camera and video gear aboard was thrown out, and it hasn't been recovered.
  17. The helicopter passed a 100-hour inspection on August 5, when it had about 2,500 hours on the airframe and about 400 hours on the engine since its last overhaul.
  18. The survivors' injuries are now described in different ways.
  19. Some accounts of the report call the two men critically injured. Others say seriously, and published summaries of the federal case file list two serious injuries. Both labels sit awkwardly beside what we reported on November 5, that both men were home from hospital within about a day.
  20. Nothing newer has contradicted their release.
  21. Flying low with the doors off beside fast boats is routine work in event filming. The report doesn't say whether the Poker Run set any minimum altitude for aircraft, or who decided how close to fly.
  22. The safety board is keeping the wreckage for more examination, and a final report naming a probable cause typically takes a year or more.

译文更新于

近期播出