跳到内容
现在

健康 · 以色列的狂犬病

以色列中部出现狂犬病:涉事疑似狗从未接受检测

一名30多岁的女性因狂犬病病情危重,这是以色列自2024年以来首例人类病例。9月死亡前,疑似传染源的流浪狗出现了神经系统症状,兽医却未经检测便将其尸体送去销毁。

文字 阅读需 7 分钟 · 25 个来源

原语言视频

译自英文原文。

一只流浪狗在9月未经检测、尸体就被销毁了,那么现在还有谁能知道它是否让一名30多岁的女性感染了狂犬病?这个问题笼罩着以色列自2024年以来首例人类狂犬病病例。目前的答案是:他们可能永远也不会知道。这名女性病情危重,在贝尔雅科夫的沙米尔医疗中心(又称阿萨夫·哈罗费医院)综合重症监护病房接受治疗。疑似传染源是一只流浪的雌性美国恶霸犬。以色列农业部称,这只狗死亡前出现了神经系统症状。⁠1⁠6

医院于11月19日周四上午表示,她的病情仍然危重。当天稍晚,《以色列时报》报道称,她的病情已经恶化,正在为生命而战。她住在谢费拉低地的一座莫沙夫(农业村)。大约两周前,她因身体不适来到医院,病情恶化后转入重症监护病房。确认她感染狂犬病的实验室结果直到周三晚间才出具。症状一旦出现,狂犬病几乎总是致命的。⁠6⁠3

卫生部称这起病例极不寻常,因为以色列人已有很长时间未被确诊感染狂犬病。《国土报》称,她是自2024年以来以色列首位感染这种疾病的人。卫生部表示,她是在今年夏天感染的。卫生部的流行病学调查将这只狗列为「可能的」暴露源,而非已确认的传染源。⁠5⁠7⁠1

文件记录显示了什么

关于这只狗的大部分已知信息,都来自农业部的初步调查。农业部在致兽医的一封信中概述了调查情况。这只狗在克法尔鲁斯一带游荡了一个多月。克法尔鲁斯是一座靠近莫迪因的莫沙夫。后来,一名参与动物权益活动的当地女性收留了它。她随后将狗交给克法尔什穆埃尔的一户人家,当地一家兽医诊所为它治疗。狗被捡走约两周后,接受了绝育手术,并同时接种了狂犬病疫苗。第二天,也就是9月9日,它的状况恶化并死亡。兽医将尸体送去销毁。⁠6

从路边流浪狗到确诊病例

  1. 从8月17日起

    卫生官员希望曾在克法尔鲁斯附近接触过狗的人主动联系当局;这是相关时间段的起始日期。

    2
  2. 8月26日至27日

    这只狗出现在克法尔鲁斯甘凯舍特幼儿园旁的游乐场。

    8
  3. 8月27日

    在克法尔鲁斯附近发现这只流浪美国恶霸犬。

    1
  4. 9月初

    被带离街头约两周后接受绝育手术,并接种狂犬病疫苗。

    6
  5. 9月9日

    这只狗病情恶化并死亡。兽医将尸体送去销毁,未经检测。

    6
  6. 11月18日周三晚间

    实验室结果确认这名女性感染狂犬病;她已住院约两周。

    6
  7. 11月19日周四

    据报道,她的病情恶化。地区委员会在克法尔鲁斯开展了狗疫苗接种行动。

    3

卫生部表示,其调查发现狗的处置方式存在「严重问题」。卫生部公布了这只狗的照片,并警告公众不要把流浪动物带回家。官员尚未说明患者究竟是捡到狗的女性,还是收留它的克法尔什穆埃尔居民、也就是她的朋友。负责克法尔鲁斯的莫迪因地区委员会告知居民,捡到这只狗的女性当时不知道它已感染。委员会称,她把狗交给了克法尔什穆埃尔的一位朋友,此后在克法尔鲁斯没有再接触这只狗;她已经接种疫苗,身体状况良好。⁠3⁠11⁠6

在绝育手术时接种的狂犬病疫苗,既不能证明什么,也不能排除什么。官员尚未解释为什么当时给狗接种疫苗。如果动物已经处于病毒潜伏期,接种疫苗本就不能指望保护它,因此这针疫苗并不能排除这只狗是传染源的可能。

卫生部在同一封信中告诉兽医,他们应遵循的规定是:任何因神经系统症状、突然恶化或不明原因死亡而被送来的狗或宠物,尤其是来自感染地区或有被作为流浪动物捡回经历的动物,「都必须立即怀疑为狂犬病」,并与地区兽医办公室协调。将这条规定与卫生部对9月9日事件的描述对照,就能看出这起案件在哪一步出了问题。一只流浪狗刚被捡回不久,病情突然恶化,出现神经系统症状后死亡,却仍被处置销毁。⁠6

如今无人能回答的问题

以色列兽医协会主席迈克尔·埃廷格医生要求进行「深入、透明、全面的专业调查」,而不是泛泛总结经验教训。他提出的问题逐一追问事件经过:当时是否有人怀疑是狂犬病?是否通知了市政兽医或地区兽医办公室?狗被销毁前,有没有人考虑将尸体送往国家兽医研究所检测?是否留存了任何生物材料,以便与在这名女性身上发现的病毒进行分子比对?⁠6

最后一个问题决定了这起案件能否查明。没有狗的样本,就没人能对其病毒进行测序并与她的病毒比对,从而证实或排除两者之间的关联。埃廷格还想知道,是否已经对患者体内的病毒进行了测序。他呼吁卫生部、兽医服务部门、国家狂犬病实验室以及所有接触过这只动物的人联合展开调查。⁠6

目标不是找人问责,而是查明识别、报告和治疗环节中究竟在哪一步没有按应有的方式运转,以防止下一起病例发生。

迈克尔·埃廷格医生,以色列兽医协会 6

上一起人类病例在报告环节也存在类似的缺口。一名来自拿撒勒地区的77岁牧羊人被狗咬伤。他直到大约一个月后、症状已经出现时才就医,并于2024年11月2日在哈埃梅克医疗中心去世。《以色列今日报》当时报道称,那只狗在观察隔离期前后死亡,而市政兽医没有报告这起死亡。该报的主标题和副标题对于牧羊人是否曾获提供预防性注射后拒绝,还是根本没有接受注射,说法并不一致。这个问题始终没有得到澄清。⁠21⁠23

克法尔鲁斯附近居民该怎么做

卫生部要求所有认为自己从8月17日起曾在克法尔鲁斯或附近接触过狗的人尽快联系最近的卫生局,以便官员判断他们是否需要接受预防性治疗。农业部的说法更进一步,称任何可能在8月接触过莫迪因附近那只流浪狗的人或动物都应接种疫苗。即使已经过去三个月,情况仍然紧急,因为预防性注射只有在症状出现前才有效。目前尚未公布有多少人主动联系当局。⁠2⁠3

卫生部强调,狂犬病在人与人之间传播的情况极为罕见,主要通过器官移植传播。病毒不会通过空气传播,也不会经由接触完好无损的皮肤传播。地区委员会周四下午在克法尔鲁斯为狗开展了疫苗接种行动。⁠10⁠6

动物疫情创纪录

1022025年动物狂犬病病例数,创纪录 12
115截至2026年11月12日的动物病例 13
552024年动物病例 12

这名女性发病之际,动物疫情已连续两年打破纪录。以色列2022年记录到29起动物狂犬病病例,2024年为55起。2025年病例数达到102起,大幅超过2017年创下的74起此前纪录。农业部数据显示,截至今年11月12日,已确诊115起病例,超过此前任何一个完整年份的总数,而距离年底还有约七周。动物福利组织「让动物活下去」首席执行官雅埃尔·阿尔金称,今年的病例数为117起,其中61起发生在狗身上。两组数字相差两起,统计口径可能不同,涵盖的日期也可能略有差异。⁠12⁠14⁠13⁠6

报道称,疫情正从北部向沙龙地区和中部蔓延,目前感染的动物大多是狗。报道列出的原因包括:战争扰乱了针对野生动物投放口服疫苗诱饵的工作;野生动物经边境围栏的缺口从黎巴嫩和叙利亚进入;国防预算削减导致军方与民间兽医之间的合作中止。阿尔金还提到,有感染的狗从巴勒斯坦权力机构管辖区进入以色列。大约两周前,一名4岁的巴勒斯坦儿童在西岸图勒凯尔姆以北的村庄卡芬死于狂犬病。⁠18⁠14⁠16⁠19⁠6⁠5

阿尔金将责任归咎于地方政府。她说:「遗憾的是,全国许多地方当局都没有处理流浪狗。」她表示,相关部门没有按照规定捕捉并隔离流浪狗,直到「一名年轻女性病情危重」,人们现在才意识到危险。⁠6

已知

  • 这名女性在重症监护病房病情危重,据报道正在恶化。疑似传染源的狗出现了神经系统症状,并在9月9日或之后未经检测便被销毁。 63
  • 卫生部只称这只狗是可能的传染源,并表示感染发生在今年夏天。 17

未知

  • 狗身上是否还留有任何样本,可以与患者体内的病毒进行基因比对。
  • 患者究竟是捡到这只狗的女性,还是收留它的朋友;以及有多少人寻求了预防性注射。

后续

  • 医院下一次公布她的病情,以及农业部是否会指出报告环节在哪一步出了问题。

来源14

在此处引用的来源中,Google News ישראל (IL:he)最先发布,比本报道播出早26小时。 随后还有4家媒体发布。

11篇早期文章作为背景资料参阅。5家媒体未注明日期:timesofisrael.comFrontiershaipo.co.ilIsrael National Newsisraelhayom.co.il

按媒体查看所有来源

来自 14 家媒体的 25 个来源· 引用最多的优先

播出原貌
  1. A woman in her thirties has rabies, a disease that almost always kills once symptoms start.
  2. She's in critical condition in intensive care, and on Thursday she got worse. Health officials want anyone who touched a stray dog around Kfar Ruth since mid-August to come forward for preventive shots.
  3. The dog suspected of infecting her died in September, and its body was destroyed without a rabies test, so the link may never be proven.
  4. She's being treated at Shamir Medical Center, also known as Assaf Harofeh, in Be'er Ya'akov. She lives on a moshav, a farming village, in the Shephelah lowlands of central Israel. The suspected source was a stray dog found by the roadside in Kfar Ruth, near Modi'in.
  5. She came to the hospital about two weeks ago feeling unwell. As she got worse, doctors moved her to the general intensive care unit. The lab result confirming rabies only came back on Wednesday evening. The Health Ministry called the case highly unusual, because no Israeli had been diagnosed with rabies in a long time.
  6. She's the first person in Israel to catch the disease since 2024. That patient was a seventy-seven-year-old shepherd from the Nazareth area who was bitten by a dog. He sought care about a month later, once symptoms had begun, and died on November 2, 2024. It's still unclear whether he was offered preventive shots and refused them, or never got them.
  7. This time the Health Ministry says the woman was infected this summer, and it calls the dog only a possible source. The dog was a stray female American Bully. The Agriculture Ministry's preliminary investigation says it roamed around Kfar Ruth for more than a month before a local animal-rights volunteer took it in. It was later moved to a home in Kfar Shmuel, and a vet clinic in the area treated it.
  8. The dog was in the playground beside the Gan Keshet kindergarten in Kfar Ruth on August 26 and 27, and it was found on August 27. In September it was spayed and vaccinated against rabies at the same time. The next day, September 9, it got worse and died, and a vet sent the body to be destroyed. The woman's rabies was confirmed November 18, and by Thursday she'd got worse.
  9. The Agriculture Ministry says the dog showed neurological signs before it died. Because the body was destroyed, it was never tested for rabies. Officials haven't said whether the patient is the woman who picked the dog up or the friend who took it in. The regional council says the resident who collected it has been vaccinated and is fine.
  10. The Agriculture Ministry says its investigation turned up "serious findings" about how the dog was handled. It published a photo of the dog and warned people not to take stray animals into their homes.
  11. In a letter to vets, the ministry spelled out the rule. Any dog brought in with neurological signs, sudden decline or an unexplained death, especially a stray or one from an infected area, has to be treated at once as a suspected rabies case and reported to the district veterinary office.
  12. Whether she pulls through, and whether that dog is ever tied to her case, are still open. Subscribe to this channel and we'll keep following it, and at heyday dot news.
  13. The head of Israel's veterinary association is demanding a full investigation. Dr. Michael Ettinger, who chairs the Israel Veterinary Medical Association, wants a deep, transparent and full professional inquiry. He's asking whether anyone suspected rabies at the time, whether the veterinary office was told, and whether anyone thought to send the body for testing before it was destroyed.
  14. His sharpest question is whether any sample from the dog was kept. Without one, nobody can compare its virus with the woman's to prove or rule out a link. "The goal is not to look for someone to blame," he said. He wants to find where the chain of reporting and treatment broke, to prevent the next case.
  15. Anyone who thinks they had contact with a dog in or around Kfar Ruth from August 17 on should call their nearest health bureau soon, so officials can decide who needs preventive treatment. The Agriculture Ministry says any person or animal that may have touched the stray near Modi'in in August should be vaccinated.
  16. The Health Ministry stresses that rabies very rarely passes between people, mainly through organ transplants. It doesn't spread through the air or through unbroken skin. The regional council ran a vaccination drive for dogs in Kfar Ruth on Thursday afternoon. Nobody has said how many people have come forward for shots so far.
  17. This human case lands in a record animal outbreak. Israel counted 29 animal rabies cases in 2022 and 55 in 2024. Then came 102 in 2025, well past the old record of 74. By November 12 this year, the count had already reached 115.
  18. Yael Arkin, who runs the animal-welfare group Let the Animals Live, puts this year's count at 117, with 61 of them in dogs. The disease has spread from the north into the Sharon and central regions, and most infected animals are now dogs.
  19. The reasons given start with the war, which disrupted drops of oral vaccine bait for wildlife. Wild animals are crossing from Lebanon and Syria through gaps in the border fence. Defense budget cuts halted cooperation between military and civilian vets. And infected dogs are crossing from Palestinian Authority areas.
  20. Arkin blames local authorities. "Unfortunately, many local authorities across the country do not deal with stray dogs," she said. She says strays aren't being caught and quarantined as the rules require, and that the danger is only being understood now that "a young woman has reached a serious condition."
  21. About two weeks ago, a four-year-old Palestinian child died of rabies in Qaffin, a West Bank village north of Tulkarm.
  22. In central Israel, the woman remains in critical condition. With the dog's body gone, the link to her case may never be proven either way.

译文更新于

近期播出