紛争 · ウクライナへの一斉攻撃継続報道 · 全2件中2件目のレポート
ポーランドでミサイルエンジンを回収、NATOのパイロットが発砲しなかった理由
捜査当局はポーランドでロシアの巡航ミサイルのエンジンを回収した。司令官の説明からNATOのパイロットが発砲を控えた理由はわかるが、ミサイルの行き先は依然として不明だ。
執筆 9分で読めます · 148件の情報源
原語の動画
英語の原文から翻訳されています。
前回のレポートからの変化
27時間後
今回
捜査当局はポーランドでロシアの巡航ミサイルのエンジンを回収した。司令官の説明からNATOのパイロットが発砲を控えた理由はわかるが、ミサイルの行き先は依然として不明だ。
ノヴィ・リポヴィエツ近郊で回収されたミサイルエンジンは、ポーランドが領空内で爆発したロシアの巡航ミサイルから確保した、最も重要な証拠の一つだ。爆発で破片が広範囲に飛散し、一部の電子機器が破壊された。捜査当局はウクライナへの11月19日から20日にかけての一斉攻撃に関する物的証拠を得たが、ミサイルの行き先は公表された情報からは特定されていない。8
読者投票
ポーランド領空への侵入を受け、NATOは何を優先すべきですか?
今回の調査結果は、重大な別の局面についての説明とともに示された。NATOの指揮下で活動していたスウェーデンの戦闘機パイロットが、巡航ミサイルの疑いがある物体に接近しながら発砲しなかったのはなぜか。ポーランドの作戦司令官によると、悪天候のため交戦前に必要な識別ができなかった。回収されたミサイルと戦闘機が接触した物体が同一だとは、まだ公表情報からは結び付けられていない。3
残骸から何がわかるのか
兵器の識別と任務の説明を区別することが重要だ。捜査当局は飛行経路をおおよそ再構成できる情報を持っているが、一部の電子部品は破壊されていた。製造時期に関する評価から、予定されていた行き先や、なぜポーランドに侵入したのかはわからない。8
回収作業は、識別作業よりも進んでいる。ノヴィ・リポヴィエツの現場検証は完了した。11月21日夕方までに、検察官はルドニクで確認された痕跡と破片をすべて回収・保全し、残るのは空の標識杭の撤去だけだと述べた。モウォディチは夜間に確保され、現場検証は11月22日朝に再開される予定だった。残骸の現場での作業が終わっても、捜査全体が終わるわけではない。8
パイロットが発砲を控えた理由
ポーランドの作戦司令官、イレネウシュ・ノヴァク中将は、Kh-101とみられる物体の迎撃を試みたスウェーデンのJAS 39グリペンのパイロットについて説明した。キーウ・インディペンデントが、ノヴァク氏の『ジェチュポスポリタ』紙への発言を伝えたところによると、極めて厳しい気象条件のため、目視でも戦闘機搭載の光電子システムでも識別できなかった。3
ドイツのユーデムにあるNATO統合航空作戦センターは、識別要件が満たされた場合に交戦する条件付きの許可を出していた。要件は満たされず、パイロットは発砲を控えた。これは兵器の故障や、発砲許可を無条件に拒否したという説明ではない。また、問題のミサイルがノヴィ・リポヴィエツ近郊で回収されたものだったと立証するものでもない。3
攻撃中、ポーランド軍は脅威となり得る物体11件を追跡し、そのうち3件がポーランド領空に侵入した。スウェーデンのグリペンとポーランドのF-16が出動し、サーブ340早期警戒機、オランダの空中給油機、地上防空部隊が支援した。ウクライナはヴィラジュ監視システムを通じて追跡情報を共有した。スウェーデンの戦闘機はポーランド領空を守るため2カ月間展開されており、主にスウェーデンを拠点としつつ、ポーランドの前方基地も利用できる態勢だった。3
したがって、作戦上の問題は単に戦闘機を飛び立たせることではなかった。航空機、監視機能、指揮権限はそろっていたが、パイロットは発砲に必要な識別を確立できなかった。これは防衛の検証で対処すべき具体的な制約であり、対応のすべてが失敗した証拠ではない。
ウクライナの復旧は未完了
ハルキウの救急病院では、ドローンがMRI室に直撃した。院長のエフゲニー・ブラゴヴェシチェンスキー氏によると、屋根と家具が損傷し、窓約100枚が割れた。職員はOSBパネルで窓をふさいでいた。古いスキャナーは無事に見えたものの、専門家による検査が必要だった。今年、保健省から受け取った2台目のスキャナーは損傷を免れ、MRI検査が必要な患者に使われる予定だった。これは代替の診療体制であり、直撃を受けた機器が作動するとの確認ではない。114
NATOの次の対応
ポーランドのドナルド・トゥスク首相は、領空侵犯を意図的な挑発と呼び、そのタイミングを近隣での軍事演習と結び付けた。これは意図に関する政府の評価であり、法医学的な調査結果が確定したわけではない。英国とフランスが主導する演習には11カ国から2,800人が参加し、11月22日まで続く予定だった。捜査当局は、演習がミサイルの標的だったとは立証していない。9
NATOがポーランド領土の隅々まで防衛することを保証します。
次に予定されている捜査上の措置は、11月22日にモウォディチで行われる現場検証だ。見慣れない残骸を見つけた人への軍警察の助言は、すぐに実行できるものだ。触れたり動かしたりせず、その場を離れ、周囲に知らせ、112番に電話してください。8
タイムライン
5日目 · 2 件のレポート
最初に報道
2 日後
当社の放送 · 第1報
ロシアの攻撃で少なくとも9人死亡、不可欠なサービスの復旧に苦しむウクライナ当社の放送 · 第2報現在地
ポーランドでミサイルエンジンを回収、NATOのパイロットが発砲しなかった理由
情報源82
媒体別の全情報源
82媒体の148件の情報源· 引用の多い順
Google News Україна (UA:uk)pravda.com.ua7
- 最初の報道
- У Києві через ранкову атаку РФ виникли пожежі у житлових будинках - Українська правда
- Russian missile likely crosses into Poland during mass attack on Ukraine | Ukrainska Pravda
- Russian missiles hit Kyiv bridges and Kharkiv emergency hospital | Ukrainska Pravda
- Russian strike damages medical facility in Kharkiv, injuring four people | Ukrainska Pravda
- Ukraine downs 79 cruise missiles as Kyiv seeks US Patriot supplies | Ukrainska Pravda
- Russia strikes emergency hospital in Kharkiv, damaging MRI scan room – photos | Ukrainska Pravda
- Emergency power cuts introduced in three western Ukrainian oblasts following Russian attack | Ukrainska Pravda
The Kyiv Independentkyivindependent.com7
- 最初の報道
- Swedish Gripen pilot unable to shoot down suspected Russian missile over Poland due to poor weather, commander says
- Ukraine war latest: Russia strikes 3 Kyiv bridges in massive aerial assault on Ukraine, at least 9 dead
- 2 Russian Kh-101 missiles, drone, fall in Poland during Russian attack on Ukraine
- Russian attacks kill 12, injure 82 across Ukraine over past day as country reels from mass overnight strike
- Russian double-tap attack kills 7-year-old, paramedic in Kryvyi Rih; 42 others injured
- Russia targets Europe's largest substation in mass energy attack on Ukraine
- 3 Kyiv bridges struck in massive Russian aerial assault on Ukraine, at least 9 dead
RBC-Ukrainerbc.ua6
- 最初の報道
- Massive attack on Ukraine - Russia launches ballistic and cruise missiles
- Russia attacks Ukraine on November 20, using cluster missiles
- Russian attack on Ukraine - Air defense forces shoot down 462 aerial targets
- Russia Ukraine war news - latest updates
- Обстрел Харькова 20 ноября повредил медицинское учреждение, есть пострадавшие | РБК Украина
- Обстріл Харкова 20 листопада пошкодив медичний заклад, є постраждалі | РБК-Україна
Kyiv Postkyivpost.com5
- 最初の報道
- Russia Fires 84 Cruise Missiles, 404 Drones at Ukraine After Putin’s Retaliation Vow
- Ukraine Hits Back: 3 Russian Missile Launchers Targeted Overnight
- Russian Drone Strikes Kharkiv Hospital, Injures Four
- Russian Missiles Kill 7, Wound 17 in Kyiv, Disrupt Power, Water Supply
- Russian Ballistic Strikes Damage 3 Kyiv Bridges, Spark Fires
Deutsche Welledw.com4
Google News भारत (IN:hi)bbc.com4
- 最初の報道
- मणिपुर में जहरीली शराब पीने से कम से कम 11 लोगों की मौत, 150 से ज्यादा अस्पताल में भर्ती - BBC
- Un misil ruso impacta en Polonia mientras los aliados de Ucrania realizan ejercicios militares - BBC
- Росія атакувала Україну: у Києві та Львові восьмеро загиблих, пошкоджені мости через Дніпро - BBC News Україна
- Russia targets Kyiv crossings days after Ukraine hits Crimean Bridge
Interfax-Ukraineinterfax.com.ua3
放送時の内容
- A Russian cruise missile exploded above Polish soil, scattering fragments across a wide area.
- The barrage killed at least nine people in Kyiv and Lviv and brought NATO fighters into the air. Investigators have recovered a missile engine, while Ukraine is still repairing bridges and electricity networks.
- What stopped the interception, and what can investigators now prove about the objects that crossed the border?
- Three objects entered Poland during Russia's November 19–20 attack on Ukraine. The strikes began overnight and continued into November 20. The discoveries in Poland now give investigators physical evidence to examine.
- Earlier on November 21, we reported at least eight deaths and 30 injuries. The death toll now stands at least nine. Emergency services also raised the Kharkiv hospital injury count from four to five.
- The earlier injury figures covered different places and stages of the emergency. They haven't been combined into a final national total.
- Investigators recovered the missile engine near Nowy Lipowiec, about 60 kilometres from Ukraine's border. They also secured debris at Rudnik nad Sanem and Mołodycz. Those three sites are the focus of the Polish investigation.
- Prosecutors say the missile exploded above ground. That scattered fragments widely and destroyed some electronics, making information harder to recover. Investigators secured the engine and parts of its maneuvering system.
- Prosecutor Andrzej Boroń says the missile was made in the fourth quarter of 2026. Its more specific identification is reported as a Kh-101. Investigators can roughly reconstruct its flight, but haven't publicly identified its intended destination.
- Poland's initial assessment described two Russian missiles and a jet-powered drone. Investigators have since identified one cruise missile. The other two objects are still awaiting published identifications, even where crews have finished collecting debris.
- No injuries were reported in Poland, and early checks found no destruction. The Military Gendarmerie also found no chemical or radiological threat at the sites.
- A Swedish Gripen pilot tried to intercept an object believed to be a Kh-101. Polish operational commander Lieutenant General Ireneusz Nowak says severe weather prevented identification, both by sight and through the fighter's electronic optical sensors.
- NATO had authorized the pilot to fire once identification requirements were met. The weather prevented that identification, so the pilot withheld fire. Investigators haven't linked that particular encounter to the missile fragments recovered near Nowy Lipowiec.
- Polish forces tracked 11 potentially threatening objects during the attack. Three entered Polish airspace. Two Swedish Gripens and two Polish F-16s deployed.
- A Saab 340 early-warning aircraft, a Dutch refueling aircraft and ground-based defenses supported the fighters. Ukraine also shared tracking information through its Virazh surveillance system. NATO's air operations centre in Uedem, Germany, commanded the Swedish jets.
- The Gripens were on a two-month deployment protecting Polish airspace. They were mainly based in Sweden, with access to a forward base in Poland.
- Seven people died in Kyiv and two at Lviv's Skniliv station. The men killed at the station were 59 and 82. Police counted ten injured across Lviv city and region, a wider area than the station.
- Mayor Vitali Klitschko's November 20 afternoon update counted 17 injured in Kyiv, with 16 still hospitalized then. Three of the city's initially reported dead were provisionally identified as Kyivvodokanal water-utility employees.
- Some casualty counts still put the minimum at eight, including six in Kyiv. Klitschko's afternoon assessment had already raised Kyiv's toll to seven. The differing figures don't show a later fall in the number killed.
- Subscribe to this channel as we follow the missile investigation and the repairs to Ukraine's essential services.
- President Volodymyr Zelenskyy says Russia launched more than 110 missiles and over 400 attack drones. His November 20 assessment includes 27 ballistic missiles within that missile total.
- Zelenskyy says air defenses shot down 79 cruise missiles. He also described missiles carrying cluster warheads and groups arriving after pauses of 20 to 30 minutes. Renewed strikes complicated firefighting, inspections and repairs.
- He says some people were killed while specialists were already examining the first damage. Russia's Defense Ministry acknowledged strikes on energy and transport infrastructure.
- Three Dnipro crossings were damaged: Podilskyi-Voskresenskyi, Darnytskyi and Pivdennyi, the Southern Bridge. Podilskyi's right-bank-to-left-bank traffic stopped after ballistic-strike damage, then resumed during the afternoon of November 20. Specialists continued examining the structures.
- Darnytskyi stayed open while repair work began. The Southern Bridge was hit again and continued operating under restrictions already in place before this attack.
- The Southern Bridge's detailed limits allowed left-bank-to-right-bank travel for vehicles up to ten tonnes and public transport up to 18 tonnes. Klitschko urged residents to avoid unnecessary car journeys and employers to allow remote work where possible.
- The strikes also damaged homes, medical premises and commercial buildings. Power cuts affected parts of five Kyiv districts, and some trolleybus services temporarily stopped.
- The strike at Skniliv hit the ticket terminal and destroyed the ticket office. Across Lviv city and region, homes, garages and vehicles were damaged. An energy installation was also damaged in Stryi district.
- Lviv switched water pumping to generators. Tram route three resumed after workers changed its electricity supply. Police opened a war-crimes investigation into the attack.
- A drone hit the MRI room at a Kharkiv emergency hospital. Emergency services now count five injured there. Five other people were injured in Lozova district, producing a combined regional figure of ten.
- Hospital director Yevhenii Blahoveshchenskyi described roof and furniture damage and around 100 shattered windows. Staff were boarding windows with OSB panels while work continued to protect the building.
- The older MRI scanner appeared intact, but specialists still needed to test it. A second scanner, received from the Health Ministry this year, was undamaged. The hospital planned to use that machine for patients needing MRI examinations.
- Blahoveshchenskyi described the hospital as entirely civilian, treating people from Kharkiv and the surrounding region. He said it had no connection to military facilities.
- Nuclear power plants also reduced electricity generation after the barrage. First Deputy Energy Minister Artem Nekrasov says damaged power networks forced the reduction.
- The strikes hit power stations and substations that move electricity through the grid. Nuclear plants then cut output. Nekrasov says normal operating arrangements will return gradually after repairs to those networks.
- The November 20 morning assessment identified consumers without supply in Kyiv and ten regions. Emergency cuts were imposed elsewhere too, while most regions had hourly outage schedules and industry faced restrictions.
- Two energy workers in Kharkiv region were injured and hospitalized. Repair crews began work where it was safe, but repeated attacks on restored facilities and recurring air-raid alerts slowed them down.
- A separate attack the following morning, November 21, set two private homes on fire in Kyiv's Podilskyi district. Klitschko later reported two injured, with one hospitalized. Those casualties belong to that later attack.
- The barrage followed Vladimir Putin's November 19 threat of retaliation after Ukraine attacked the Crimean Bridge. That sequence provides the context. It doesn't settle the purpose of each strike or the destination of the missile found in Poland.
- Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk convened a crisis team and called the incursions an intentional provocation. He said they didn't appear accidental.
- The British- and French-led Coalition of the Willing exercise involved 2,800 personnel from 11 countries and was due to continue until November 22. Tusk linked the timing to the drills; investigators haven't identified them as the missiles' target.
- Ukraine and Poland are cooperating on the investigation. Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha called for stronger air defenses and more pressure on Russia, saying the incursions threatened Europe's security.
- NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte pledged in Warsaw that the alliance would defend every inch of Polish territory. NATO's European commander, General Alexus Grynkewich, is to assess threats and make defense adjustments if necessary.
- Tusk says Poland will seek stronger detection and surveillance. Defense Minister Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz says Warsaw will request additional NATO forces and capabilities.
- France has requested a United Nations Security Council meeting. Zelenskyy has also asked for faster supplies of PAC-2 and PAC-3 Patriot air-defense missiles. A confirmed meeting time and delivery of a new shipment haven't been announced.
- The pilot's decision is now explained: required identification failed in severe weather. The forensic inquiry has identified one Russian-made cruise missile, with two objects still awaiting identification. Ukraine still has no verified completion timetable for permanent bridge repairs or normal nuclear generation.
- Crews have finished examining Nowy Lipowiec and collecting the identified fragments at Rudnik. At Rudnik, only empty marker stakes remained to be removed. Mołodycz was secured overnight, with inspection due to resume the next morning.
- The Military Gendarmerie warns people who find unfamiliar objects to leave them untouched, move away, warn others and call 112.
- Prosecutors plan to resume the Mołodycz inspection on November 22. NATO's North Atlantic Council is scheduled to discuss the Polish airspace violations in Brussels on November 23.
翻訳更新:
ディスカッション
ここでの投稿は「Russian overnight attacks across Ukraine」に属し、このニュースのすべてのレポートに表示されます。





