司法 · ICE车辆调查

休斯敦地方检察官寻求取得ICE SUV及检验争议性碰撞事件的证据

肖恩·蒂尔称，一名探员在调查人员来得及检查SUV前就把车开走了。车辆驾驶数据和两名被拘留证人的接触问题仍未解决。

播出 文字 阅读需 8 分钟38 个来源HeyDay News Desk · About usWatch report
与 HeyDex 一起探索

通过 RSS 关注

原语言视频

文字实录 · 正在加载

译自英文原文。

新闻追踪第 4 天

1 篇报道22 家媒体38 个来源6 个视频

  • 暂无标注日期的事件
  1. 第 1 次更新休斯敦地方检察官寻求取得ICE SUV及检验争议性碰撞事件的证据当前位置

如果调查人员无法检查ICE的SUV，也无法取得车内人员的陈述，他们如何检验ICE对碰撞事件的说法？这已成为哈里斯县当前的核心问题。地方检察官肖恩·蒂尔称，一名联邦探员在当地调查人员来得及处理一宗碰撞事故的证据前，就开车离开了现场；该事故导致米格尔·帕拉-埃尔南德斯重伤。2

蒂尔称，探员拒绝允许进行法证检查；检察官起草搜查令期间，一名探员开着SUV冲过警戒线离开了现场。这些是检察官提出的指控，并非经独立证实的现场调查结论。但这些说法描述了一个具体的调查障碍：那辆可能有助于解释碰撞经过的车辆已无法立即检查。2

2026年10月10日星期六上午，帕拉-埃尔南德斯在哈里斯县休斯敦地区一处购物中心停车场被撞。具体商家或街道地址尚未确定。ICE称他并非此次行动的目标。最新一份已确认的住院情况报道来自10月14日，当时他仍在ICE拘押之下，其律师称他需要进一步手术。24 4 22

眼下的争议并不只是SUV是否撞了他，而是碰撞如何发生、驾驶员当时意图为何，以及调查人员能否取得足以检验相互对立说法的证据。

录像能够证实什么

Scripps新闻描述的监控录像显示，帕拉-埃尔南德斯跑进停车场时，一辆黑色无标识SUV朝他转向。停放的皮卡挡住了撞击发生的瞬间。片刻之后，他倒在地上，探员们正从车里出来。这一遮挡很重要：可见的车辆接近过程是证据，但这个视角没有拍到车辆实际撞上他的瞬间。4

蒂尔称，他的办公室已收集多段视频。在NBC新闻10月15日刊发的一次采访中，他称ICE车辆“开向了当事人”，这与联邦方面关于帕拉-埃尔南德斯跑到车前的解释相矛盾。他认为这次碰撞显然是故意的。ICE否认其探员故意撞了他；国土安全部称这次接触发生在一次针对性行动中。检察官的判断和机构的否认都不能确定当事人的意图。7 2 1

Scripps称，此次行动要寻找另一辆车的驾驶员。帕拉-埃尔南德斯的家人称，他因担心生命安全而逃跑。当地报道提到，他的律师金·布鲁诺称，他从未见过ICE据称正在追捕的那个人。这些说法没有回答执法人员为何追踪他的行动，也没有解释SUV为何改变方向。4 29 18

哈里斯县警长办公室已展开调查。蒂尔称，如果调查证实他的判断，现有证据可能足以支持以持致命武器加重袭击罪提出指控。这只是可能提出的指控，并非已经认定的犯罪，也不是已核实的已提起指控。1 2

摄像头之外的证据

SUV可能提供视频无法提供的测量数据。蒂尔称，车载事故数据记录器会记录车速、转向操作和制动情况。他警告说，开走车辆可能会覆盖相关信息；此前当地媒体报道援引他的话称，数据“很可能已经不在了”。目前没有已完成的法证检查能够证实某段特定记录已被删除、还剩下什么数据，或进一步驾驶是否必然覆盖了这次事故的记录。可能丢失不等于已确认遭到破坏。2 25

蒂尔称，他的办公室已起草另一份搜查令，打算在调查人员认为SUV所在的ICE设施执行。起草搜查令不等于获得法官批准或实际执行。现有报道没有证实调查人员已找到车辆或下载其数据。2

已知

  • 蒂尔正在寻求取得SUV，并指出两名被拘留的后座乘客是重要证人。 213

未知

  • 法官是否签发了新搜查令、搜查令是否已执行，以及是否仍有可用的记录器数据。

后续

  • 调查人员能否在仍有可能接触车辆和人员时取得SUV，并获得两名乘客的陈述。

接触证人是另一个问题。蒂尔称，碰撞发生时SUV后座有两人被拘留，其中一人被转移至波特伊莎贝尔。此前一则报道提到，调查人员曾询问一名被拘留者，并要求ICE不要驱逐证人；后续报道则继续称，调查人员正努力接触两名乘客。目前尚未证实两人的询问是否都已完成，也不清楚他们各自目睹了什么。2 13

转移不等于驱逐。同样，担心失去接触机会也不能证明证人已经无法联系。但SUV内人员的第一手陈述，可能回答被遮挡的摄像头画面无法解答的问题。无论记录器能否提供任何信息，保留接触这些人员的机会都很重要。

伤势严重，医疗详情仍未解决

帕拉-埃尔南德斯已接受手术。美联社10月14日的报道说，他仍在ICE拘押期间住院，并援引其律师的话称，他还需要接受进一步手术。ICE此前称他情况稳定，国土安全部则称其伤势没有生命危险。这两种说法都不意味着伤势轻微，也都没有提供之后的医疗情况更新。没有证据证实他此后已出院或获释。22 4 1

他的家人最初称，他的一条腿有三处骨折；后续报道转述家人的说法称，他双腿均骨折。最初的描述并不排除另一条腿也受伤。这些是家属的说法，并非完整的临床伤情清单；报道也没有证实骨折的确切数量或康复预后。5 20

他的年龄也尚无定论。NBC新闻10月13日刊发的报道援引其律师称他48岁，这与《休斯敦纪事报》的报道一致。ABC新闻在10月13日晚些时候报道他30岁。没有明确的更正或身份证明文件能够解决这一冲突。另有报道转述其家人称他已在美国生活34年；不应不加辨别地将这一说法与彼此矛盾的30岁年龄说法结合起来。1 17 3 4

规定也是尚未解答的问题

有关ICE车辆拦停的新指引于碰撞事故发生前的10月1日至2日公开报道。NBC报道称，指引禁止高速追逐，并要求车辆拦停行动中的警员佩戴并开启随身摄像机。MS NOW报道称，只有完成规定培训的警员才能在拦停行动中驾驶车辆；未受训警员只能承担“支援职能”。Telemundo Houston还报道称，指示要求记录未停车车辆的信息，而不是追逐这些车辆。31 32 35

具体的正式生效日期以及该政策是否适用于此案，仍未得到核实。目前没有关于这名驾驶员是否接受过培训、是否使用摄像机或是否保存录像的合规认定。有人从SUV跑开的画面本身并不能证明发生了被禁止的高速车辆追逐。4 23

9月23日，我们报道过一起在奥斯汀发生的ICE人员开枪击中驾驶员的独立事件。如今，这起休斯敦案件提出了另一个问责问题，但尚无证据证实两起事件有关联。在本案中，接下来真正重要的是能否取得相关证据：接触SUV、获取可能留存的数据，以及接触车内人员。一个身受重伤的人的案件，理应由这些证据决定，而不是由哪家机构的说法更难核查来决定。

本报道参考的来源

NBC新闻——最初的碰撞事故报道及警长办公室调查。1

NBC新闻——蒂尔谈车辆被开走、数据和证人的采访。2

ABC新闻——休斯敦碰撞事故、伤情说法及报道中的年龄。3

Scripps新闻——监控画面局限、家属说法及ICE回应。4

ABC新闻——10月11日广播报道中的休斯敦消息。5

ABC新闻——最初的审查及合作请求。6

NBC新闻——关于意图的争议及获取证据受阻的指控。7

ABC13 Houston——蒂尔称无法接触车辆。8

哈里斯县地方检察官办公室——肖恩·蒂尔官方简介。9

Click2Houston——关于车辆证据被移走的指控。10

FOX 26 Houston——蒂尔谈追逐战术的采访。11

《德克萨斯论坛报》——调查及可能提出的指控。12

ABC新闻——寻找两名后座证人。13

《休斯敦新闻报》——检察官对意图的判断。14

美联社——关于是否故意撞人的争议说法。15

《卫报》——可能提出的重罪指控。16

《休斯敦纪事报》——帕拉-埃尔南德斯的身份和背景。17

ABC13 Houston——律师关于预定目标的说法。18

Click2Houston——手术及家属近况。19

ABC13 Houston——家属关于双腿骨折的说法。20

《卫报》——目标身份及居住经历。21

美联社——10月14日住院及手术情况更新。22

FOX 26 Houston——碰撞事故事实摘要。23

《今日美国》——10月10日碰撞事故及警员调查。24

Click2Houston——10月13日关于事故数据的视频报道。25

Click2Houston——10月14日关于车辆被开走的视频报道。26

《休斯敦纪事报》——蒂尔对是否故意撞人的判断。27

NBC新闻——被拘留的证人及有关驱逐的担忧。28

Houston Stringer——律师金·布鲁诺及家属的说法。29

《休斯敦纪事报》——遭ICE拘押的证人。30

NBC新闻——车辆拦停备忘录及摄像机要求。31

MS NOW——培训和驾驶限制。32

CNN en Español——车辆拦停培训指引。33

WGME——培训和支援职责限制。34

Telemundo Houston——追逐限制。35

KGW——追逐及随身摄像机指引。36

ABC7 Chicago——车辆拦停政策的调整。37

《华盛顿时报》——备忘录中的车辆拦停限制。38

播出原貌 19 行
  1. On September 23 we reported an ICE officer shooting a driver in Austin. Now a Houston collision has left another man hospitalized in ICE custody.
  2. ICE says Miguel Parra-Hernandez wasn't the operation's target. The local prosecutor says an agent drove the SUV away before investigators could examine it, putting potentially crucial evidence at risk. Can investigators still get its driving data and the accounts of two people detained inside?
  3. The SUV struck Parra-Hernandez in a shopping-center parking lot in Harris County on Saturday morning, October 10. Surveillance footage shows him running into the lot as a black, unmarked SUV veers toward him. A parked pickup blocks the moment of impact.
  4. Moments later, Parra-Hernandez is on the ground and agents are getting out of the SUV. That sequence shows the vehicle's movement, but the pickup hides the contact itself. District Attorney Sean Teare says his office has collected multiple videos.
  5. Teare says the SUV “drove into the individual,” and describes the collision as apparently intentional. ICE denies its agent intentionally struck him. Homeland Security says Parra-Hernandez ran in front of the vehicle during a targeted operation.
  6. The operation sought another vehicle's driver. His family says Parra-Hernandez fled because he feared for his life. His lawyer, Kim Bruno, says he has never met the person agents were pursuing. She says the SUV veered into him and calls the incident a crime.
  7. The Harris County Sheriff's Office opened an investigation. Teare says agents at the scene refused permission to examine the SUV. While prosecutors were drafting a search warrant, he says, an agent drove it through police tape and away. His office lost immediate access to the vehicle.
  8. Teare says the SUV's crash recorder captures speed, steering input and braking. Those measurements could help test the competing explanations. He warns that driving the vehicle could overwrite them and calls the data “likely gone.” No forensic examination has confirmed that loss.
  9. Teare says his office has drafted another search warrant and intends to take it to the ICE facility where investigators believe the SUV is located. Recovering the vehicle would let specialists examine what it recorded and what information remains.
  10. Two detained people were in the SUV's back seat, Teare says. He considers them material witnesses. Their firsthand accounts could help investigators understand what happened inside the vehicle as it approached Parra-Hernandez.
  11. Teare says one of those people was moved to Port Isabel. Investigators have asked ICE not to deport witnesses. Moving a potential witness farther away can make an interview harder to arrange while investigators are still trying to secure their accounts.
  12. Investigators were earlier described as interviewing a detained person. Efforts to reach both back-seat occupants continued afterward. Nobody has confirmed that both interviews are complete or that investigators still have access to the person Teare says was transferred.
  13. Parra-Hernandez remained in a hospital in ICE custody on October 14, after undergoing surgery. His lawyer said he needed further surgery. Earlier, ICE described him as stable, and Homeland Security called his injuries non-life-threatening.
  14. His family initially said one leg was broken in three places. Later, they said both legs were broken. The first description doesn't rule out injuries to the other leg. The full medical picture hasn't been made public, but his treatment has already required surgery.
  15. His lawyer identifies him as 48, an age also given locally. A conflicting figure puts him at 30. That discrepancy hasn't been resolved. His family says he has lived in the United States for 34 years.
  16. Parra-Hernandez has lived in the Houston area for more than three decades. The fuller version of his name is Miguel Parra-Hernandez. Variations in its spelling refer to the same injured man.
  17. ICE's new vehicle-stop guidance prohibited high-speed chases before this collision. It required officers at stops to wear and activate body cameras. Only officers who completed required training could drive during stops. Others could participate in a support role.
  18. The guidance also told officers to record information about vehicles that failed to stop for later investigation. No one has announced whether those rules applied to this encounter or were followed. A person running from an SUV doesn't by itself show a high-speed vehicle chase.
  19. Teare says the investigation could support aggravated assault with a deadly weapon if the evidence bears out his assessment. Whether prosecutors can build that case depends on evidence they're still seeking. It isn't clear whether the new warrant has been issued or served. Access to the SUV, its remaining data and both witnesses is still unresolved.

来源

38 个来源21 家媒体6 个视频

来源地图

追溯本篇报道的依据。图谱展示其关联；下方链接可打开本文引用的来源。

来源图谱将在您阅读时加载。

探索完整的新闻编辑室图谱 ↗

译文更新于

修订记录

  1. r1首次发布。